Skip to main content

Communication failures blamed for friendly fire deaths in Afghanistan

By Gabe LaMonica, CNN
updated 8:21 AM EDT, Fri September 5, 2014
Family of Pvt. 2nd Class Aaron S. Toppen, 19, grieve his death on June 10, 2014 in Mokena, Illinois.
Family of Pvt. 2nd Class Aaron S. Toppen, 19, grieve his death on June 10, 2014 in Mokena, Illinois.
  • Teams involved did not follow established procedures, Pentagon report says
  • One radio had no batteries, while another had a broken talk button
  • Six soldiers, including five Americans, were mistaken for the enemy and bombed

(CNN) -- A friendly fire incident that killed six soldiers in Afghanistan, including five Americans, was a result of botched communication and a series of other errors, the Pentagon said.

The June 9 bombing in Zabul province is among the deadliest friendly fire incidents in the 13-year war. It also left one Afghan soldier dead.

What started as a battle with insurgents on a hillside descended into a tragedy after failures in equipment and communication protocol, according to a Pentagon report released Thursday.

Teams involved did not follow established procedures, and one radio had no batteries, while another had a broken talk button, according to the report.

'A challenging set of circumstances'

In addition, soldiers didn't relay their position correctly, and a supersonic strategic bomber wrongfully relied on a sensor to detect soldiers.

"Though this was a challenging set of circumstances, had the team executed standard tactics, techniques and procedures, and communicated effectively, this tragic incident was avoidable," Air Force Maj. Gen. Jeffrey Harrigian said in the report.

The 300-page report by U.S. Central Command was partially redacted before its release under the Freedom of Information Act.

"The key members executing the close air-support mission collectively failed to effectively execute the fundamentals, which resulted in poor situational awareness and improper target identification," Harrigian said.

At the time, U.S. and Afghan forces were using a supersonic strategic bomber to target insurgents and ensure security at polling places five days before the June 14 presidential runoff election.

Bomber mistakes soldiers for enemy

To tackle fire better from insurgents, a team on the ground split up at the request of Staff Sgt. Jason A. McDonald, the report said.

"Communication degradation due to terrain" made it difficult for McDonald to tell the crew of a B1-B Lancer in the area that the team had split up and moved to higher ground.

McDonald could not contact the team moving to the hillside because one member had a radio that was out of batteries and the other carried one with a broken "push-to-talk" function. McDonald then sent Spc. Justin R. Helton up the hill to act as a verbal communications link.

Meanwhile, at 12,000 feet, a pilot flying the B1-B Lancer scanned the area with night-vision goggles, looking for infrared strobes worn by soldiers to broadcast their presence.

All the pilot saw were occasional muzzle flashes, which he thought were from the enemy, the report said.

Sensors on the B1-B don't detect infrared strobes, and the night-vision goggles the pilot used are not designed to see infrared strobes at an altitude higher than 7,000 feet.

The bomber did not have permission to fly under 12,000 feet because of the presence of U.S. drone aircraft at lower altitudes.

About 7:30 p.m. on June 9, the B1-B dropped the two bombs that killed the soldiers.

Staff Sgt. Scott R. Studenmund, 24, of Pasadena, California, was wearing the strobe on the back of his helmet when he was killed. McDonald, 28, of Butler, Georgia, who split the hillside team, was also killed.

The other U.S. deaths included Helton, 25, of Beaver, Ohio; Cpl. Justin R. Clouse, 22, of Sprague, Washington; and Pvt. 2nd Class Aaron S. Toppen, 19, of Mokena, Illinois.

Part of complete coverage on
updated 1:32 PM EDT, Sat June 14, 2014
Afghans have finished casting their ballots to pick a president in a runoff election between former Cabinet ministers.
updated 8:51 AM EDT, Mon June 9, 2014
Singer and ex-judge on The Voice of Afghanistan advocates women's rights -- despite death threats for not wearing a headscarf.
updated 5:31 PM EDT, Wed June 11, 2014
The improvement in the quality of life for Afghan women is unmistakable, say a bipartisan coalition of women in Congress.
updated 6:33 AM EDT, Thu May 29, 2014
President Barack Obama outlined a foreign policy vision of "might doing right."
updated 1:58 AM EDT, Wed April 9, 2014
She was to be married off to pay for her father's debt -- here's her story.
updated 3:23 PM EDT, Mon April 7, 2014
One music producer hopes to get out Afghanistan's youth vote with a song competition. CNN's Sherisse Pham reports.
updated 8:11 AM EDT, Mon April 7, 2014
Despite threats from the Taliban, Afghans turned out in large numbers to cast their vote for a new president and future.
updated 1:27 AM EDT, Wed April 9, 2014
It was not too long ago -- in 2001, prior to the U.S. invasion -- that Afghanistan's women were all but entirely marginalized.
updated 8:23 PM EDT, Sun April 6, 2014
As Afghan voters prepare to go to the polls in a hugely important election, CNN looks at the main presidential candidates.
updated 8:37 AM EDT, Wed April 2, 2014
Despite the looming Taliban presence, Afghanistan could see its first democratic transfer of power, Peter Bergen writes.
updated 2:03 AM EDT, Fri April 4, 2014
As the U.S. prepares to withdraw troops, an Afghan Army commander says America's support remains critical.
updated 5:24 AM EDT, Fri May 24, 2013
With U.S. Special Forces in Afghanistan, CNN's Anna Coren reports on a Taliban firefight lasting more than 90 minutes.
updated 10:54 AM EDT, Mon April 1, 2013
Mallika Kapur has the story of a young Afghan graffiti artist who, despite Taliban threats, pushes for free expression.
updated 7:35 AM EST, Mon February 11, 2013
Author William Dalrymple's new book "Return of a King" looks at the history of foreign-led wars in Afghanistan.'s 'Home and Away' initiative honors the lives of U.S. and coalition troops who have died in Iraq and Afghanistan.