Skip to main content

Did Oscar Pistorius have time to think?

By Richard Allen Greene, CNN
updated 2:03 PM EDT, Thu July 3, 2014
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • NEW: Oscar Pistorius was shooting to kill, the prosecution argues at his murder trial
  • Pistorius' defense team highlights his disability and vulnerabilities
  • The athlete is accused of deliberately shooting his girlfriend, Reeva Steenkamp
  • He says he shot Steenkamp accidentally in his bathroom, mistaking her for an intruder

Pretoria, South Africa (CNN) -- Did Oscar Pistorius have time to think before he shot and killed his girlfriend Reeva Steenkamp last year? That's the question that state prosecutor Gerrie Nel dug into Thursday with a doctor who has spent years working with the disabled athlete.

"His intention was to shoot, whoever he came across -- if he came across anyone" in his home on a February night last year, Nel put to the doctor, Wayne Derman.

"I suppose if he came across an intruder or danger, he would shoot," Derman responded.

And Pistorius was firing to kill, the prosecutor said.

Derman, a defense witness, paused a long time before he finally responded.

Doctors: Pistorius suffers from PTSD
Pistorius loved Steenkamp, agent says
Pistorius begins mental evaluation
Oscar Pistorius reaches out to his uncle Arnold Pistorius and other family members as he is led out of court in Pretoria, South Africa, after being sentenced to five years in prison on Tuesday, October 21. Pistorius, the first double-amputee runner to compete in the Olympics, was sentenced for culpable homicide in the February 2013 death of his girlfriend, Reeva Steenkamp. Oscar Pistorius reaches out to his uncle Arnold Pistorius and other family members as he is led out of court in Pretoria, South Africa, after being sentenced to five years in prison on Tuesday, October 21. Pistorius, the first double-amputee runner to compete in the Olympics, was sentenced for culpable homicide in the February 2013 death of his girlfriend, Reeva Steenkamp.
Oscar Pistorius trial
HIDE CAPTION
<<
<
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
>
>>
Photos: Oscar Pistorius trial Photos: Oscar Pistorius trial
Pistorius begins mental evaluation

"He was aiming to neutralize the threat," the doctor said.

Nel let those words hang in the air for a long moment before announcing that he was done with his questions for the day.

Pistorius, 27, is on trial for murder, and while he admits firing the bullets that killed Steenkamp, he pleaded not guilty. He says he mistakenly thought he was defending himself from an intruder.

The prosecution says the two had an argument and he deliberately murdered the model and law school graduate, who was 29.

'Two Oscars'

Derman spent all day Thursday on the stand, first testifying under defense questioning that Pistorius' double amputation is key to understanding his behavior.

Do not be taken in by the fact that Pistorius is one of the fastest runners in the world -- remember he is disabled, he argued.

Derman ran through a long list of the difficulties that double amputees experience every day, concluding: "The saddest thing I have learned through my six years of working with athletes with disability is that disability never sleeps.

"It's there when you go to sleep at night and it's there when you wake up in the morning. It affects nearly every aspect of your life," he said.

Pistorius' defense team seems to be trying to establish that he acted reasonably, given who he is, when he killed Steenkamp in the early hours of Valentine's Day 2013.

Judge Thokozile Masipa must decide whether he made a genuine mistake and, if so, whether the mistake and his response were reasonable.

The South African Olympian's defense team has been exploring his psychology this week.

His lawyer Kenny Oldwadge posited Thursday that there were "two Oscars," one of whom was a global sports star and one of whom was "vulnerable" and "scared."

"I am stuffed without my legs on," his lawyer quoted him as saying, using a slang term meaning "in trouble."

Witness reliability

Pistorius evidence revealed
How will Pistorius evaluation play out?

Prosecutor Nel went after Derman aggressively in his cross-examination, exploring whether the shooting was an instinctive "fight-or-flight" response or the result of conscious thought.

The question of whether Pistorius is found guilty of premeditated murder could hinge on the answer.

Exchanges between the two got testy, with Nel trying to get the doctor to explain Pistorius' actions moment by moment on the night he killed Steenkamp.

Derman said it was impossible for him to answer theoretical questions about what Pistorius might have been thinking or doing at a given instant because he, Derman, knew what had actually happened after the moment in question.

Frustrated, he appealed to Judge Masipa, but she sided with Nel, firmly instructing the witness to answer his questions or say he didn't know.

Nel began his cross-examination by suggesting that Derman was not a trustworthy witness because he had a responsibility to Pistorius as his doctor. Masipa rejected the objection.

The prosecutor kept up the attack, demanding to know when Derman had made particular notes on Pistorius, whether the court should believe Derman or Pistorius when their evidence differed, and the meaning of the word "subsequent."

Derman grew irritated with Nel when the prosecutor responded: "That's not true" to a statement Derman gave, and he appealed to the judge that Nel was being "unprofessional."

Masipa agreed and ordered Nel to withdraw the remark.

Nel, in turn, showed annoyance with Derman asking which "incident" he was referring to.

"The killing!" Nel shouted back at him.

Suicide risk

The defense has been exploring Pistorius' mental health for several days.

On Wednesday, his lead lawyer Barry Roux said Pistorius is depressed, suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder, and is a suicide risk, according to the doctors who spent a month evaluating his mental health.

But he does not appear to have a history of abnormal aggression or psychopathic tendencies linked to "rage-type murders in intimate relations," they found.

The conclusions are a "slam-dunk for the defense," CNN legal expert Kelly Phelps said.

The psychiatric report seemed to suggest that Pistorius' version of events was plausible.

"When Mr. Pistorius's appraisal of the situation is that he might be physically threatened, a fear response follows that might seem extraordinary when viewed from the perspective of a normal bodied person, but normal in the context of a disabled person with his history," the doctors found.

Several witnesses have testified that Pistorius tends to arm himself and go toward danger, rather than away from it, when he thinks he is under threat.

At the trial's conclusion, Judge Masipa will have to decide whether Pistorius, 27, genuinely made a mistake or deliberately murdered his girlfriend.

If Masipa does not believe the athlete thought there was an intruder, she will find him guilty of murder and sentence him to a prison term ranging from 15 years to life. South Africa does not have the death penalty.

If Masipa accepts that Pistorius did not know that Steenkamp was the person he was shooting at, she could find him guilty of culpable homicide, a lesser charge than murder, or acquit him, according to CNN analyst Phelps.

A verdict of culpable homicide would leave the sentence at Masipa's discretion.

The trial is scheduled to continue Monday for a 38th day.

Read: 13 things to know as case resumes

Read more: Judge sends Pistorius for psychiatric tests

Read: Is Oscar Pistorius crazy? State wants tests

Read: What life's like in a South African prison

Read: Case highlights South African gun culture

Read: Oscar Pistorius' affidavit to court in full

ADVERTISEMENT
Part of complete coverage on
Oscar Pistorius
updated 3:13 PM EDT, Tue October 21, 2014
A stuffy, overcrowded cell. Perhaps two or three men to a single bunk. Lockdown for most of the day.
updated 5:39 AM EDT, Tue October 21, 2014
He was the so-called "Fastest Man on No Legs," and his inspiring story captured the imagination of the world at the London Olympics.
updated 12:23 AM EDT, Sat September 13, 2014
The striking, platinum-haired model was gearing up for her reality television debut.
updated 10:16 AM EDT, Tue October 21, 2014
Her name is Thokozile Matilda Masipa, and she is the woman who will decides the fate of athlete Oscar Pistorius.
updated 1:45 PM EDT, Mon June 3, 2013
Reeva Steenkamp on the beach in Port Elizabeth, South Africa.
Previously unseen photographs of Reeva Steenkamp show the South African beauty just months before her tragic death.
updated 12:08 PM EST, Sun February 16, 2014
The photos of Oscar Pistorius and girlfriend Reeva Steenkamp appear to show a young couple in love.
updated 11:07 AM EDT, Mon October 20, 2014
A week before her death, South African model Reeva Steenkamp talked about her secure, blissful environment.
updated 4:13 AM EST, Mon March 3, 2014
He was the first amputee to compete at an able-bodied Olympics. Now, he's being accused of murdering his girlfriend.
updated 4:31 AM EDT, Fri September 12, 2014
Judge Masipa has Oscar Pistorius stand up as she reads her verdicts.
updated 11:18 AM EDT, Thu September 11, 2014
CNN's Robyn Curnow looks back at some of the key moments in the trial.
updated 5:07 AM EDT, Tue October 21, 2014
CNN's Robyn Curnow reflects on her visit to athlete Oscar Pistorius' home, before he was on trial for murder.
updated 3:44 AM EDT, Mon June 30, 2014
Take a virtual tour of the athlete's apartment to see what happened.
updated 5:26 AM EDT, Mon April 14, 2014
Prosecutor Gerrie Nel is known as the "bull dog" in South Africa's legal circles, and it's easy to see why.
updated 7:56 AM EDT, Thu April 10, 2014
As the athlete is grilled in court, Becky Anderson asks psychologist Dr. James Thompson about his state of mind.
ADVERTISEMENT