Skip to main content
Part of complete coverage on

McDaniel plans to challenge Mississippi runoff result

By Jeremy Diamond, CNN
updated 9:19 AM EDT, Fri July 4, 2014
  • NEW: McDaniel campaign serves papers to Cochran with intent to challenge
  • The campaign says it found nearly 5,000 "irregularities" in primary voting records
  • McDaniel supporters call foul after Cochran's campaign turns to Democratic voters
  • Conservative group files a lawsuit asking for full access to GOP primary voting records

(CNN) -- More than a week after results declared his defeat, the tea party-backed candidate in Mississippi's GOP primary for the U.S. Senate notified Sen. Thad Cochran on Thursday that he plans to challenge the outcome.

State Sen. Chris McDaniel's campaign served papers to Cochran's son, Clayton, with notice of intent to challenge the results, citing allegations of improper crossover voting, according to the Clarion-Ledger of Mississippi.

Tea party rival refuses to concede

McDaniel's team had dispatched volunteers across the state to investigate election results in the state's 82 counties. An outside group has already filed a lawsuit in federal court.

McDaniel's campaign has retained a legal team and is urging supporters to donate to the campaign legal fund.

The challenge was filed with the state Republican Party executive committee, as required by law, the Clarion-Ledger reported, and an official court challenge could come as early as next week.

Campaign staffers and 150 volunteers have already combed through voting records in 51 counties and claim to have identified nearly 5,000 "irregularities," which are mostly tied to people who were ineligible to vote in the state's June 24 runoff election, McDaniel campaign spokesman Noel Fritsch said.

The McDaniel campaign announced earlier Thursday that it is offering 15 rewards of $1,000 each for individuals who "provide evidence leading to the arrest and conviction of anyone involved in voter fraud." Donations to the campaign's legal coffers will help fund the rewards.

McDaniel supporters called foul after Cochran's campaign and allies turned to African-Americans and other traditionally Democratic voters to help push the incumbent to victory in the primary runoff.

Cochran had finished about 1,500 votes short of McDaniel in the primary three weeks earlier, but a third candidate kept McDaniel under the 50% threshold needed to win outright.

Winning strategy likely to stay in Mississippi

Voters who cast a ballot in the Democratic primary on June 3 were not allowed to vote in the Republican primary runoff last week.

Predicting ineligible votes, conservative groups hired former Justice Department official Christian Adams to train and oversee election observers to monitor polls and note questionable voter activity.

Adams declined to comment for this story and deferred to the groups he is working with, like FreedomWorks, which he said he may represent in a potential legal challenge.

FreedomWorks Executive Vice President Adam Brandon said the group's activists have been helping the McDaniel campaign review election results and will support the campaign if it moves forward with its intent to challenge -- which could come as soon as early next week.

Mississippi primary spending surge pushes advertisers off the air

"We'll ask some of our members to raise the necessary funds to fund such a challenge, and we're standing by and ready to go, period," Brandon said. "It's now up to the folks in Mississippi to figure out what the next steps are."

McDaniel: Miss. election not fair
Senate veteran Thad Cochran wins primary
Tea party leader dead in apparent suicide

Challenger's camp: 'irregularities' growing

The number of inadmissible votes the McDaniel camp said it discovered jumped from about 3,300 to nearly 5,000 on Wednesday after the campaign reviewed records in a dozen more counties.

The irregularities fall short of Cochran's nearly 7,000-vote margin of victory, but McDaniel's campaign is confident it will hit that number after reviewing the results from the remaining third of Mississippi counties.

Shortly before a bizarre turn of events Wednesday when McDaniel supporters crashed a Cochran conference call with reporters, Cochran campaign spokesman Austin Barbour called out the McDaniel camp for drawing out a divisive primary battle.

"I just think the time has come now for the McDaniel campaign to put up or shut up," Barbour said at a news conference Wednesday and later that

Fritsch criticized Barbour's remarks in an interview with CNN and said he hopes those are not the views of the Cochran campaign.

"I find it troublesome that Austin Barbour would call for a movement being led by the people, which is in the pursuit of truth and in the pursuit of the maintenance of electoral integrity, to shut up," Fritsch said.

Fewer wins this time, but tea party has changed the GOP

The McDaniel campaign can only file a formal complaint after the state GOP sends certified election results to the Mississippi secretary of state, according to the state party's communications director, Bobby Morgan.

The Mississippi Republican Party's executive committee and representatives from both campaigns met Tuesday, but the committee did not certify election results, Morgan said, adding that just over half of the counties had so far submitted their results.

Morgan said the state party has followed the law throughout the election.

"We're looking forward to the fall campaign. We want to resolve this as soon as possible," he said. "Republicans have a real legitimate chance to retake the Senate and we want to do all we can to make sure the (Mississippi) seat remains in Republican hands."

Group says requests to view records was denied

True the Vote, a conservative group, filed a lawsuit Tuesday in federal court against the Mississippi secretary of state and the executive committee of the state's Republican Party, after it analyzed electoral turnout and other data and was "inundated" with reports of election violations.

The lawsuit alleges that voters not authorized to vote in the primary runoff may have "diluted" the votes of legitimate Republican voters. It demands that state election officials open up the books and defer to federal law over state statutes in disclosing election records.

The group said it became suspicious after turnout rates shot up in certain precincts and its requests to view records were denied.

"We are not approaching it from a belief of who should have won the race. Let's find out what the actual final score was, and which points were legitimate and which were not on either side," said Carl Logan, True the Vote's communications director. "At the end of the day we don't care who wins or loses."

Logan explained that the group gathered complaints from Mississippi voters who said they observed violations of election law.

One voter complained in an e-mail to Logan that he was not asked for photo identification when he went to vote, which was required for the first time this election under Mississippi law.

"He was concerned that he could not have been the only one not to show an ID in the primary runoff," Logan said.

He added that True the Vote will encourage voters with complaints to contact their local election officials.

State party says group misunderstands the law

The nonprofit's lawsuit was joined by 13 Mississippi voters, several of whom are affiliated with the tea party. They claim that election officials denied some of their requests to view voting records or demanded "exorbitant fees," Logan said.

Joe Nosef, the chairman of the Mississippi Republican Party, said in a statement that True the Vote's lawsuit is based on a "misunderstanding of both Mississippi law" and the state party's role in the election.

"Since these allegations do not include anything the MSGOP did or is doing wrong, we will ask to be released from this lawsuit soon," Nosef said.

The lawsuit asks for full access to unredacted Mississippi election records for the Republican primary -- which would include voters' birth dates and Social Security numbers -- to allow True the Vote to accurately verify whether illegal ballots were counted.

Justin Levitt, a professor at Loyola Law School, Los Angeles, and an expert in national election law, said he believes a thorough review of election records will reveal fewer illegal votes than skeptics of the runoff claim.

Levitt said that partial election records, like those reviewed by True the Vote and McDaniel supporters, can often overstate voter fraud, which is later revealed as clerical error or due to voters with identical names and birth dates -- which Levitt said is actually very common.

"It's always difficult to predict what is going to happen," Levitt said. "They can give more or less of a thumbs up or down on each of the lawsuit's claims."

While the group may gain access to more election records through the lawsuit, Mississippi College law professor Matthew Steffey said it is unlikely the review of records will lead to a new election.

"I don't think showing that 1 to 2% of the electorate had some irregularity is enough," Steffey said. "If it were easy to get courts to order a new election, we would have had a new vote in Florida" during the challenge to the presidential election results in 2000.

Mississippi has no provisions for election recounts.

5 controversial moments in the Mississippi election

Mississippi tea party leader tied to campaign smear dead in apparent suicide

Part of complete coverage on
updated 3:29 PM EDT, Tue June 3, 2014
Their approval rating is horrendous. They rarely get along or get anything done. So here's your chance to do something about it.
Here's CNN's take on the key races in the House and the Senate this midterm year -- along with the key gubernatorial races across the country.
Voters head to the polls over the coming months to choose their candidates for November's general election. Here's a look at who votes when
updated 6:27 PM EDT, Wed July 2, 2014
President Obama is vowing to act on his own due to House inaction on immigration reform But there are limits to the power of his pen.
updated 1:54 PM EDT, Tue July 1, 2014
The major story line so far in 2014 is the ongoing battle that pits mainstream Republicans against tea party and anti-establishment groups.
updated 5:29 PM EDT, Mon June 30, 2014
S. E. Cupp interviews Carly Fiorina about her effort to rally conservative female voters for Senate races.
Some Democrats say there may be a silver lining in the ruling: It could motivate younger women and unmarried women to show up at the polls come November.
updated 9:10 AM EDT, Wed June 25, 2014
The GOP establishment, incumbent and mainstream candidates scored big wins.
updated 3:59 PM EDT, Thu June 19, 2014
This California Republican's back story is full of plot twists.
updated 4:47 PM EDT, Wed June 11, 2014
Why and how did a well-funded, powerful, conservative member of Congress lose to a political novice?
updated 3:44 PM EDT, Tue June 3, 2014
President Obama's new rules aimed at dramatically limiting carbon pollution has been a policy priority of his and one that he hopes will help to shape his legacy.
updated 4:50 PM EDT, Fri May 30, 2014
The Affordable Care Act, aka Obamacare, might not be the Republican Party's key to electoral victory as once thought.
updated 5:43 PM EDT, Thu May 22, 2014
An advocacy group backed by hedge fund tycoon Tom Steyer is set to unleash a seven-state, $100 million offensive against GOP "science deniers."
Mitch McConnell mined decades of battle-hardened experience and carefully-tended relationships inside the GOP to win his primary.
updated 5:56 PM EDT, Fri May 16, 2014
Flooding the airwaves this election year are Democratic ads featuring two men not on any ballot, and not even politicians.
updated 11:23 AM EDT, Thu May 15, 2014
Taking a cue from Beyonce, House Democrats are targeting "all the single ladies" to try to win a few Republican-held seats.
A small edge right now in a key indicator of the midterm elections could lead to a big advantage for the Republicans come November.
updated 2:52 PM EDT, Wed April 16, 2014
Former NYC Mayor Michael Bloomberg plans to spend $50 million this year through a new organization called Everytown for Gun Safety.