Skip to main content

How Hillary Clinton flubbed the wealth question

By Dan Merica, CNN
updated 12:19 PM EDT, Sun June 29, 2014
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • Hillary Clinton has now misstepped twice on questions about her wealth
  • The wealth questions come at the same time that Clinton has stepped up her populist rhetoric
  • Democrats to the left question Clinton's economic ideas and coziness with Wall Street
  • Republicans are trying to create a narrative the Clinton is out of touch with most Americans

Washington (CNN) -- Hillary Clinton had to know she was going to have to talk about her wealth.

The tightly orchestrated book tour for her new memoir has closely resembled a campaign -- with war rooms and surrogate coordination. So one would expect that Clinton was prepared to answer questions on any topic.

Clinton 'not truly well off'
'Truly well off': Hillary steps in it

But when the wealth question came, Clinton, the political heavy hitter, whiffed.

Van Jones: 'Hillary's Blowing it.'

Twice.

The muffed answers have made trouble on their own for the potential presidential candidate by raising new questions about her ability to connect with average voters on economic issues.

But they've also had another consequence.

Prior to her book tour, she'd begun a pivot to the left. Many liberals had questioned her economic themes and coziness with Wall Street. In response, she stepped up her populist rhetoric.

However, because of the blaring headlines on wealth, her outreach to party progressives has gone mostly unnoticed so far, possibly clouding her appeal to another important constituent.

A day to forget

Clinton's first misstep came when she told ABC at the start of her book tour this month that she and her family "came out of the White House not only dead broke but in debt," adding later that her family had "no money" at that time.

She wasn't wrong when she said the first family left the White House way behind financially. She said they were burdened by legal bills and still had to keep a roof -- actually two -- over their heads and send their daughter to college.

But here's a mighty big difference between Clinton and the average person.

For starters, she and her husband were obviously well positioned to quickly capitalize on the post-presidential custom of cashing in.

She left that part out.

Hillary Clinton had a massive book advance in the works and, along with the former president, the prospect of making millions. This is what fueled cries of hypocrisy.

Clinton 'not truly well off'
The Clinton family's road to riches

After quickly trying to clean up the comments, though, Clinton swung and missed again on Sunday when questioned about her own financial standing and wealth inequality in an interview with The Guardian.

Clinton compared herself to others and noted her situation is different, too.

"We pay ordinary income tax, unlike a lot of people who are truly well off, not to name names; and we've done it through dint of hard work," she said.

One reason Clinton's two missteps on wealth are surprising is that questions about the issue are not new and shouldn't have come as a surprise.

Liberal websites like Mother Jones began asking questions about her speaking fees -- upwards of $200,000 -- in early May.

Republican groups like the Republican National Committee and America Rising, an outside anti-Clinton super PAC, had been probing the topic longer.

The progressive connection.

Sally Kohn, a progressive activist and Clinton critic, said she handled the wealth question poorly and "certainly has enough money to hire a better speaking coach."

But she downplayed the mistake.

"Why people do have a problem with her is not because of her personal wealth, it is because of her coziness with Wall Street. That is the problem," Kohn said.

The monied elite is an anathema to liberals, who decry wealth inequality, the corrosive impact of too-big-to-fail businesses and, of course, the overwhelming power in America of the professional investor class vs. average people struggling to save.

For much of Clinton's time on the paid speaking circuit, the former secretary of state has focused on bipartisan issues and kept some distance with hot political issues.

But less than a month before questions about her wealth and understanding of the middle class started to define her book tour, Clinton departed from more bipartisan topics and stepped up her populist rhetoric in a May speech at the New America Foundation.

Victim says Clinton 'lied like a dog'
Victim says Clinton 'lied like a dog'
Victim: Hillary 'put me through hell'

She bashed George W. Bush, embraced material from the liberal playbook, and highlighted populist themes in her speeches.

Clinton charged up her rhetoric, too. She blasted tight-fisted millionaires, decried the current economy as a "throwback to the Gilded Age," and dusted off old standbys about Republican trickle-down economics.

The change in tone hasn't happened in a vacuum, and may have projected that Clinton and her aides expected criticism about her wealth, stature and ability to relate to everyday Americans.

But because of the mistakes, her populist pivot has largely gone unnoticed.

An exclusive club

Instead, it's Clinton's two tone-deaf statements about her family's wealth that have defined her book tour, so far.

They have also begun to shine a light on Clinton's work as a constant fundraiser.

Between her campaign for president in 2008 and her time as the head of a global foundation, she spent a considerable amount of time courting the money of millionaires and billionaires.

Her foundation -- The Clinton Foundation -- has also become a bastion for corporate donors. Stephen L. Bing, the founder of Shangri-La business group; Tom Golisano, the founder of Paychex and Cheryl and Haim Saban, Democratic megadonors and the owners of Univision, have donated between $10 million and $25 million.

Republicans have seized on it and are looking to portray Clinton as out-of-touch and someone who has spent too much time in the "bubble" and in other rarefied surroundings.

They point to her gaffes as well as a comment from earlier in the year when she told a group of auto dealers that she hadn't driven a car since 1996.

And while pro-Clinton Democrats have defended her, others in the party have begun to knock her -- some more subtly than others. They also say she's out of touch.

Vice President Joe Biden, who may be running for president, appears to be getting in on the action.

Biden said on Monday that he "makes a lot of money" as vice president. But he made sure to mention he was "listed as the poorest man in Congress" and said he has "no savings account."

Key point: Biden stressed that he's been "really, really fortunate" compared to the way others have struggled.

Bush is still Clinton's bogeyman

6 times Clinton sounded, acted like a candidate

ADVERTISEMENT
Part of complete coverage on
Hillary Clinton
updated 12:28 PM EDT, Tue June 10, 2014
Here's a look at the life of former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton.
updated 5:49 PM EDT, Wed June 18, 2014
Clinton staked out a position on some issues, catered to her base in others and avoided some questions altogether.
updated 12:19 PM EDT, Sun June 29, 2014
Hillary Clinton had to know she was going to have to talk about her wealth.
updated 6:42 PM EDT, Tue June 17, 2014
Mitt Romney is not running for president, but that hasn't stopped him from offering his advice on how to best beat the likely Democratic nominee, Hillary Clinton.
More than three-quarters of all Americans predict that Clinton will win the Democratic nomination if she runs for the White House.
Six in 10 Americans are dissatisfied with the way the Obama administration has handled the deadly terror attack on the U.S. diplomatic compound in Benghazi.
updated 6:43 PM EDT, Tue June 17, 2014
As recently as 2011, Hillary Clinton was seen by many as a respected but polarizing figure: Smart and accomplished, sure, but controlled and somewhat humorless.
updated 8:51 PM EDT, Fri March 21, 2014
She is crisscrossing the country picking up sizable speaking fees and addressing audiences who cheer any mention of her future plans.
updated 10:40 AM EDT, Sat June 14, 2014
Take a look at Hillary Clinton's career.
Chelsea Clinton announces she is expecting her first child.
updated 5:07 PM EDT, Fri June 13, 2014
Clinton said she wrote her book "for anybody who wants to think about and learn about what is happening in the world today, why America matters, and why the world matters to America."
updated 6:46 PM EDT, Tue June 17, 2014
Hillary Clinton writes about her 2008 loss to Obama, her reaction to the terrorist attacks in Benghazi and her time as America's top diplomat.
Secretary of State Hillary Clinton said the bucks stops with her when it comes to who is to blame for a deadly assault on the U.S. diplomatic mission in Benghazi.
updated 10:23 PM EDT, Thu May 1, 2014
For Bill and Hillary Clinton, their view on the state of journalism in the United States comes from a place of deep knowledge and exposure.
updated 11:05 AM EST, Tue January 14, 2014
In Iowa, Hillary Clinton enjoys stratospheric approval ratings, well-heeled outside groups toiling on her behalf, and important political connections that date back decades.
updated 5:05 AM EST, Wed February 26, 2014
Clinton told an audience last month that she is not thinking about her 2016 presidential plans and told supporters "not to think about it."
updated 8:57 AM EDT, Tue March 18, 2014
During her time as Secretary of State, some Jewish leaders said Clinton's once-consistent, outspoken leadership on Israel was hamstrung by her role as Obama's top diplomat.
updated 3:33 PM EDT, Fri May 9, 2014
Did the State Department under Hillary Clinton err two years ago by not designating Boko Haram a terrorist group?
ADVERTISEMENT