Skip to main content

Catastrophic Washington landslide: Plenty of blame to go around?

By Chelsea J. Carter, CNN
updated 7:47 PM EDT, Wed April 2, 2014
  • Questions have been raised about development, clear-cutting in area
  • Scientist had warned about potential for catastrophe
  • Governor promises thorough review of possible factors

Darrington, Washington (CNN) -- The signs touting logger pride are everywhere in this small town tucked away in Washington's rugged North Cascade Mountains.

It's at the high school, where the school mascot -- the Loggers -- recalls burly men with chainsaws.

It's in the community center's giant hand-painted wall mural that depicts the mountain peaks and thick swaths of Douglas fir that surround this town of roughly 1,300.

And it's in the handmade posters that have been taped to storefronts, offering thanks to the loggers who were among the first to respond after an avalanche of mud, rock and splintered trees wiped out homes in the nearby town of Oso, killing at least 29 people. About 20 people are still missing.

Here, loggers are heroes.

President Obama speaks to first responders, recovery workers and community members on Tuesday, April 22, at the scene of the deadly landslide that devastated Oso, Washington, one month before. The landslide crossed the North Fork of the Stillaguamish River and caused multiple deaths and massive damage. President Obama speaks to first responders, recovery workers and community members on Tuesday, April 22, at the scene of the deadly landslide that devastated Oso, Washington, one month before. The landslide crossed the North Fork of the Stillaguamish River and caused multiple deaths and massive damage.
Washington state landslide
Photos: Washington state landslide Photos: Washington state landslide
27 dead, 22 still missing in Washington
Landslide victim #15, more than a number
Woman loses mother, daughter in landslide

But in the aftermath of the March 22 landslide, there are uncomfortable questions being raised about whether the very lifeblood of these communities -- from development to logging -- and the people who live there, the homeowners, may have a role in it.

And the question about who, if anybody, is to blame has ignited passions.

"You hear these reports that logging is to blame?" says Kenny Friddle, whose family and friends are among the more than 100 volunteers, mostly loggers, trudging into the mounds of mud and debris to search for the missing.

The disgust is thick in his voice.

"Do you seriously think that we'd do something that would kill our own people?"

Questions of clear-cutting, outdated data

Scientists say development and the removal of whole stands of trees -- a controversial practice known as clear-cutting -- in the landslide-prone area likely played a role in the disaster.

An analysis of documents and geographical data by The Seattle Times found state regulators have been using outdated boundaries to restrict logging above the hill that collapsed, failing to incorporate newer research that would have prevented the area from being clear-cut.

Stands of trees anchor soil and divert water, so any mass removal of trees on slopes can contribute to the risk of a landslide.

The rain-soaked hillside that gave way on the north fork of the Stillaguamish River had a history of landslides, including ones in 1937, 1942, 1949, 1951, 1967 and 1988.

It's a peril that was highlighted as recently as the late 1990s in Seattle-based geomorphologist Daniel Miller's report to the US. Army Corps of Engineers that warned of the potential of a catastrophic landslide. A geomorphologist studies land formations and their interaction with storms, fire and landslides.

State conservation officials issued logging restrictions that used older boundaries, rather than a map drawn up by Miller, The Times reported.

In 2004, according to The Seattle Times, officials approved the clear-cutting of 7½ acres on the plateau atop the unstable hill outside Oso — about 5 acres of which would have been protected under Miller's boundaries. Harvesting was completed by the property owner by August 2005.

While landslide risk assessment wasn't the focal point of the late 1990s study, which was designed to look at restoring the ecosystem for the river's nearby fisheries, it certainly was one of the outcomes.

Geologists who have looked at the history of the landslides on that hill have pointed to a number of factors as possible contributors, including heavy rain, river erosion and logging, The Times reported. One of the newspaper's reports indicated the plateau has been logged for almost a century.

In an opinion piece for CNN, Miller wrote analyses indicated "potential instability of a huge mass of material above the zone of previous landslides. As a scientist, I knew that material would someday be on the valley floor." He also cited the continued construction of homes after his analysis.

No thorough mapping of potential hazards

Miller writes that landslide hazards "have not been systematically mapped across the state, much less the country. Where work has been done, maps are hard to find. If found, they are difficult to interpret."

In an interview, Miller said residents are poorly informed and do not understand consequences.

"People need to be aware of and understand the risks posed and the potential consequences of the decisions they make" to live in these areas, he said.

Among those people is 63-year-old Robin Youngblood, who was born and reared in the area. She moved away, but returned in 2012 and bought a house with an expansive view of the river and the hillside.

She was in her house when she heard the roar of the hillside giving way. Out of her window, she saw a wall of mud racing toward her.

"I said, 'Oh, my God,' and it hit us," Youngblood told CNN.

The mud and rock tore her house apart, pushing it a quarter of a mile from its foundation.

She survived by pulling mud out of her nose and mouth so she could breathe and climbing on to a washing machine perched atop the debris.

Now she's wondering why no one ever warned her that the home was in the path of a hillside that had been assessed as potentially unstable.

"Nobody told any of us," she said. "This is criminal, as far as I'm concerned."

More likely it is an example, Miller says, of how the science that cites the likelihood for landslide is not being properly relayed or interpreted by everyone, from state regulators to the timber industry and from the developers to the homeowners.

"The level of knowledge, the level of understanding is dismal," he said.

'We will get to the answer'

Gov. Jay Inslee has acknowledged the need for a broader review of the events that lead to the landslide and how to safeguard people against future ones. A spokeswoman for the state Department of Natural Resources told The Seattle Times it would complete an investigation on the late 1990s watershed analysis.

But for right now, the focus must be on finding those still missing in the mud.

"We will get to the answer," Inslee told CNN. "It's going to take some time."

What makes this remote area, with its trees, lush vegetation and jagged mountain peaks, attractive to so many is also what can make it dangerous. It can get up to 120 inches of rain a year, saturating hillside and causing landslides.

Already there is talk by some whose homes were damaged in the landslide's mud flow about rebuilding, a notion that sits uncomfortably with Miller.

"What people see is a beautiful spot. They don't see the risks that are out there," he says.

Just about everyone here realizes hard questions need to be asked about what happened and how it can be prevented.

And that will likely include a discussion about logging and the timber industry, something that is not likely to go over well in Darrington, where even the mayor owns a logging company.

Loggers crucial to community, economy

By any standard, Darrington is a struggling town. It hasn't recovered from the hit the logging and timber industries took in the 1970s, something the locals blame on government regulations that took hold and changed how logging was carried out.

So many people lost jobs, and it can be seen in the empty, boarded-up store fronts.

"Those people are just looking for a reason" to limit logging, Peter Brandt says, shaking his head at the news. Those people are the government regulators, the officials who will review what happened and make recommendations.

Brandt hasn't lived in Darrington long. But he's been around long enough to know how important loggers are to the community.

For days, loggers have been trudging out into the mud alongside firefighters and search and rescue crews.

They have been carrying their own chainsaws to cut through the mounds of debris that has allowed crews to locate the missing. In many cases, the loggers themselves have found bodies.

"They don't need to hear ... that," Brandt says of the debate about the role of logging in landslides. "They need to hear thank you and God bless you."

CNN's Tom Watkins, Ana Cabrera and Sara Weisfeldt contributed to this report.

Part of complete coverage on
Washington state landslide
updated 7:47 PM EDT, Wed April 2, 2014
The signs touting logger pride are everywhere in this small town tucked away in Washington's rugged North Cascade Mountains.
updated 10:54 PM EDT, Sun March 30, 2014
With land come landslides. While they're inevitable in many ways, people don't inevitably have to die because of them.
updated 6:11 PM EDT, Mon March 31, 2014
A close community has become even closer as they work together to find the missing and clear the mud and debris.
updated 6:55 PM EDT, Thu March 27, 2014
"Well, how do you remember any son?" John Regelbrugge II asked in a telephone call from his home in northern California.
updated 11:05 AM EDT, Tue April 1, 2014
As a landslide near Oso, Washington, tragically highlighted, we remain subject to the forces of nature like all the rest of Earth's creatures.
updated 10:46 PM EDT, Wed March 26, 2014
Four-year-old Jacob Spillers was trapped in mud so thick it was like freshly poured concrete.
updated 8:13 PM EDT, Tue April 22, 2014
The landslide buried 49 structures in up to 40 feet of mud in a square mile and left 175 people unaccounted for.
Satellite images taken before and after a landslide in Washington state show the extent of the damage.
updated 12:23 PM EDT, Tue April 8, 2014
The search continues for those missing after the landslide, but it has been days since anyone has been found alive.
updated 10:03 AM EDT, Wed March 26, 2014
Video shows a 4-year-old boy being rescued on Saturday from the wreckage of a landslide in Washington.
updated 10:14 AM EDT, Tue March 25, 2014
After days of tragedy, one family found a bit of happiness in the rubble from a landslide in Washington. KOMO reports.