Qatar World Cup 2022: FIFA reformer calls for vote rerun

Story highlights

  • Former FIFA insider calls for a fresh vote on the 2022 World Cup
  • The tournament was awarded to Qatar following a FIFA ballot in December 2010
  • Alexandra Wrage says rerunning the vote is the only way to restore confidence in the World Cup
  • Former New York attorney Michael Garcia is investigating allegations of corruption around the vote

Leading former FIFA insider Alexandra Wrage is calling for a new vote over the selection of the 2022 World Cup hosts given the ongoing controversy surrounding the decision to award Qatar the event.

Without any football pedigree and despite concerns over staging the world's most prestigious tournament in a desert climate, the Middle East nation emerged as the surprise winner of the vote by FIFA'S Executive Committee in December 2010, when beating the United States in a 14-8 vote in the decisive round.

The choice has raised far more questions than answers.

Notably regarding the season in which the World Cup would be played. There has been repeated talk of switching the tournament to winter in a bid to avoid the sweltering heat of Qatar's summers.

FIFA president Sepp Blatter has also admitted that the vote to decide both the 2018 and 2022 World Cups led to possible collusion among bidding nations.

Another issue has been many allegations of corruption -- with the latest surrounding former FIFA official, Jack Warner, which were revealed earlier this week.

The Qatari World Cup committee as well as prominent FIFA officials have steadfastly denied the allegations. But the questions prompted FIFA to create an Independent Governance Committee (IGC) in 2011.

The aim was for the IGC to propose methods to restore the reputation of football's global body.

Read: FIFA official envisages winter World Cup

Yet former member Wrage -- an anti-corruption authority who resigned in April 2013 over frustration at what she described as FIFA's resistance to reform -- believes drastic action is needed to correct the decision to award the tournament to Qatar. Even current Executive Committee member Theo Zwanziger has described it as a "blatant mistake."

"The only way to restore confidence in the World Cup selection process is to rerun the vote," Wrage, the president of non-profit international anti-bribery group Trace, told CNN.

"Having said that, I don't expect it to happen and expect, instead, that the process will be further contorted with a controversial move to winter and a great deal of stalling and shifting on the human rights issues raised by the selection of Qatar."

The treatment of migrant construction workers toiling around the clock to deliver new stadiums and, in some cases, whole new cities ahead of the finals has been another unwanted aspect of FIFA's decision to hand the finals to Qatar.

Are Qatar 2022 migrant workers abused?
Are Qatar 2022 migrant workers abused?


    Are Qatar 2022 migrant workers abused?


Are Qatar 2022 migrant workers abused? 02:12
Moving the 2022 Qatar World Cup
Moving the 2022 Qatar World Cup


    Moving the 2022 Qatar World Cup


Moving the 2022 Qatar World Cup 01:22

The global body has since tasked Germany's Zwanziger with addressing the convoluted issue of labor rights in Qatar. A report is expected at this week's FIFA conference in Zurich, which starts on Thursday.

FIFA's Ethics Committee, headed by the former United States attorney for the Southern District of New York -- Michael Garcia -- is also busy, currently investigating allegations of corruption regarding the vote for the 2022 World Cup site.

The American may have more paperwork to sift through after a British newspaper published a damning story this week.

The Daily Telegraph claims a company owned by former Executive Committee member Jack Warner invoiced one owned by Qatar's former FIFA vice-president and Asian football chief Mohammed Bin Hammam for a substantial sum of funds within a month of the 2022 voting decision.

"I have no comment to make on any article -- but feel free to write whatever you wish," Warner told CNN in response to the claims.

Qatar's 2022 World Cup Organising Committee has also issued a statement to refute the allegations made in the Daily Telegraph on Tuesday.

"The 2022 Bid Committee strictly adhered to FIFA's bidding regulations in compliance with their code of ethics," it read.

"The Supreme Committee for Delivery & Legacy and the individuals involved in the 2022 Bid Committee are unaware of any allegations surrounding business dealings between private individuals."

Qatar heat likely problem for World Cup
Qatar heat likely problem for World Cup


    Qatar heat likely problem for World Cup


Qatar heat likely problem for World Cup 03:49
Belounis backs Qatar as World Cup hosts
Belounis backs Qatar as World Cup hosts


    Belounis backs Qatar as World Cup hosts


Belounis backs Qatar as World Cup hosts 03:02

Amidst the constant questioning over the decision to take the World Cup to the Middle East for the first time since the competition started in 1930, Wrage believes more still needs to be done by FIFA.

"To restore confidence, the public needs to see a serious and broad investigation of all allegations - with prompt and meaningful consequences for any wrongdoing," she argues.

"In spite of some recent governance improvements, there is still a widespread sense that FIFA provides far too little transparency."

Shortly after her resignation from the IGC, Wrage wrote a piece for stating her belief that the "only entity capable of insisting on transparency at FIFA is the Swiss government."

This came after FIFA rejected proposals from the IGC to introduce two members to the Executive Committee who were independent as well as a compromise proposal that the Chairman of FIFA's Audit Committee should be an independent observer at all ExCo meetings.

Seeking comment, CNN contacted the four other nations beaten by Qatar: the U.S., Australia, South Korea and Japan. Only the latter replied, saying that it "does not have a comment on a supposition."

Australia has previously said it will pursue compensation if the 2022 finals are switched from summer to winter months.

Read: Blatter -- "Qatar worker conditions unacceptable"

      Football Focus

    • French football great bids adieu

      After 20 years, more than 300 goals and a host of major honors, Thierry Henry has called time on his glittering football career.
    • Mario's 'Queen' tweet tops 2014 list

      He might be struggling to score goals for Liverpool, but Mario Balotelli's cheeky tweet about the British monarch hit the spot during the World Cup.
    • bpr south african soccor senzo meyiwa death _00000402.jpg

      Loss of a South African 'icon'

      Football world mourns South African captain Senzo Meyiwa who was shot and killed during a botched robbery in a township near Johannesburg.
    • German alleged jihadist Kreshnik B (R) listens to his lawyer Mutlu Guenal (L) as he arrives at the higher regional court in Frankfurt. His face is pixelated for legal reasons.

      From Jewish football to ISIS suspect

      Once part of Germany's largest Jewish sports club, now he's the first ISIS suspect to stand trial in a country left shocked by his alleged radicalization.
    • Where has 'Super' Mario gone?

      One goal in eight matches for new club Liverpool, and dumped by the Italian national team -- Mario Balotelli has yet to shine on his English return.
    • Ched Evans smiles during the Wales training session ahead of their UEFA EURO 2012 qualifier against England on March 25, 2011 in Cardiff, Wales.

      Should rapist return to work?

      Should a convicted rapist, who has served their time in prison, be allowed to resume their old job? What if that job was as a high-profile football player?
    • Teen, 15, makes Euro history

      Norwegian 15-year-old Martin Odegaard is the youngest player ever to feature in a European Championships qualifying match.