NFL contemplates on-pitch penalties for derogatory slurs

Story highlights

  • NFL Committee to decide on whether to punish slurs with on-pitch penalties
  • Team guilty of abusive language would be penalized 15 yards
  • Decision to change rules could take place as early as next month
  • Mooted change follows Miami Dolphins scandal of last year

In European soccer, the punishment for racially abusing an opponent is a 10-match ban.

In American football, the same offense could result in the offending team being penalized 15 yards.

That's the proposal on the table when the NFL's Competitions Committee meets next week, as the body considers penalizing players for using abusive language during games.

High on the list of derogatory slurs the NFL is trying to outlaw is use of the 'N-word', while penalties for homophobic comments are also being discussed. A second incident could result in ejection.

Read: What you don't get about NFL bullying

"It is a potential rule modification being discussed by our Competition Committee," the NFL statement read.

"The committee has not decided on a formal proposal to our clubs, who have to approve rule changes by a 3/4 vote (24 of 32 teams).

Text between Incognito & Martin released
Text between Incognito & Martin released

    JUST WATCHED

    Text between Incognito & Martin released

MUST WATCH

Text between Incognito & Martin released 00:36
Richard Sherman: Thug is the new n-word
Richard Sherman: Thug is the new n-word

    JUST WATCHED

    Richard Sherman: Thug is the new n-word

MUST WATCH

Richard Sherman: Thug is the new n-word 03:14
Jonathan Martin: I hope to resume career
Jonathan Martin: I hope to resume career

    JUST WATCHED

    Jonathan Martin: I hope to resume career

MUST WATCH

Jonathan Martin: I hope to resume career 01:03
Incognito: Martin text didn't blame me
Incognito: Martin text didn't blame me

    JUST WATCHED

    Incognito: Martin text didn't blame me

MUST WATCH

Incognito: Martin text didn't blame me 03:09
Alleged NFL bully Incognito speaks out
Alleged NFL bully Incognito speaks out

    JUST WATCHED

    Alleged NFL bully Incognito speaks out

MUST WATCH

Alleged NFL bully Incognito speaks out 02:59

"Rule change proposals are presented to our teams at our annual league meeting in late March.

"The game officials already have substantial authority to police verbal abuse/unsportsmanlike conduct and they understand the league's focus on respect."

Should the Competitions Committee decide to approve the proposal, the body will then present their findings to the NFL's owners at a meeting in March.

Racism became a major issue in the NFL last year after the Miami Dolphins suspended offensive lineman Richie Incognito for detrimental conduct following allegations of misconduct from teammate Jonathan Martin.

An independent investigation found continuing threats and verbal and physical abuse, text messages, racial slurs and vulgar sexual comments made about Martin's mother and sister by Incognito and some of his Dolphins teammates.

Another Dolphins player, an unnamed offensive lineman, was allegedly subjected to homophobic name calling and improper physical touching.

Incognito's lawyer said the report is replete with errors, adding: "The truth....is that Jonathan Martin was never bullied by Richie Incognito or any member of the Dolphins' Offensive line," said Attorney Mark Schamel, in a statement to CNN.

In Europe, racism generated plenty of unwanted headlines throughout 2013 - a year which featured two walk-offs involving famous Italian side AC Milan.

Read: Boateng wants referees to have greater power

Former Ghana international Kevin-Prince Boateng led his team off during a friendly against lower tier Pro Patria in January, while Guinea's Kevin Constant simply left the pitch himself in a separate incident during a match against Serie A side Sassuolo in July.

One of the most high profile cases came in 2011 when Liverpool star Luis Suarez was banned for eight games after a football association panel found him guilty of racially abusing Manchester United's Patrice Evra.

In Italy, several clubs have been punished after their fans were adjudged to have racially abused visiting players - with Lazio alone having paid $300,000 in fines last year after being charged four times by European football's governing body UEFA.

Last year, UEFA announced that players and officials will face a 10-match ban if found guilty of racist abuse.

Hidden Dangers?

In the United States, Ozzie Newscome -- general manager of the Baltimove Ravens and a member of the NFL's competition committee -- believes the proposals need thorough testing before any implementation.

"With any rule that we put into play, we have to look at it from A to Z and find out what are the unintended consequences as much as the consequences," he was quoted as saying on the NFL website.

Boateng: Racism in football must end
Boateng: Racism in football must end

    JUST WATCHED

    Boateng: Racism in football must end

MUST WATCH

Boateng: Racism in football must end 04:09
NFL player accused of bullying teammate
NFL player accused of bullying teammate

    JUST WATCHED

    NFL player accused of bullying teammate

MUST WATCH

NFL player accused of bullying teammate 04:29
Michael Sam and "Locker Room Culture"
Michael Sam and "Locker Room Culture"

    JUST WATCHED

    Michael Sam and "Locker Room Culture"

MUST WATCH

Michael Sam and "Locker Room Culture" 04:08
Congress to NFL: Change 'Redskins' name
Congress to NFL: Change 'Redskins' name

    JUST WATCHED

    Congress to NFL: Change 'Redskins' name

MUST WATCH

Congress to NFL: Change 'Redskins' name 01:46

"But as it was stated in our meeting, there are mics everywhere. So, if something is being said, it's probably going to be captured somewhere. So, it would be an opportunity to get it verified if we had to."

Last week, the head of the Fritz Pollard Alliance, an organization dedicated to promoting diversity and equality of job opportunity in the NFL, said he would be surprised should the move fail to go through.

"I will be totally shocked if the competition committee does not uphold us on what we're trying to do," said John Wooten, the group's Chairman, in an interview with CBSSports.com.

"We want this word to be policed from the parking lot to the equipment room to the locker room. Secretaries, PR people, whoever, we want it eliminated completely and want it policed everywhere."

Last December, shortly after the Incognito story broke, Fritz Pollard called on NFL players to stop using the 'N-word'.

Read: Is Dolphins coach to blame for Incognito mess?

"Simply put, from this day forward please choose to not use the "N" word. Period!," their statement read.

"Do not take the position that you are not bothered by the word. If you tolerate the language being used casually now, at some point in the future, either as a current or former player, you may hear it directed at you. How do you think you will respond?"

In an interview with ESPN, Pittsburgh Steelers safety Ryan Clark, explained that the use of racial slurs is not always as it seems.

"I think it's going to be really tough to legislate this rule, to find a way to penalize everyone who uses this word," said Clark.

"And it's not going to be white players using it toward black players. Most of the time you hear it, it's black players using the word."

      Sports spotlight

    • AG2R pair Peraud and Romain Bardet (right) thrilled the French fans with their performances on the 2014 Tour de France.

      When will French win Le Tour?

      Whisper it quietly, but after years of foreign domination the prospect of a French winner of the Tour de France is more than just a mere pipe dream.
    • Steve Way leads the in the Commonwealth Games marathon with the favorites massing behind him.

      From 20-a-day man to 26.2 miles

      Seven years ago Steve Way was a 20 per day smoker and weighed a hefty 104 kg, but he led the marathon at the 2014 Commonwealth Games.
    • The queen of the selfies

      After just one day of competition, a new sport has emerged at the Commonwealth Games in Glasgow: snapping selfies with the Queen.
    • Joanna Rowsell is flanked by Australian duo Annette Edmonson and Amy Cure (right) after the medal presentation for the women's individual pursuit.

      Rowsell stands proud again

      Inspirational cyclist Joanna Rowsell added another gold to her growing collection in the individual pursuit at the Commonwealth Games.
    • GLASGOW, SCOTLAND - JULY 23: John Barrowman performs during the Opening Ceremony for the Glasgow 2014 Commonwealth Games at Celtic Park on July 23, 2014 in Glasgow, Scotland. (Photo by Ian Walton/Getty Images)

      Gay kiss steals Glasgow show

      At the opening ceremony of the Commonwealth Games in Glasgow, an actor upstaged the Queen by kissing a male dancer.
    • Daniel Carter of the All Blacks in action during the Third Test Match between the New Zealand All Blacks and France at Yarrow Stadium on June 22, 2013 in New Plymouth, New Zealand. (Photo by Anthony Au-Yeung/Getty Images

      Can the All Blacks make history?

      The All Blacks and their fans are focused on one thing, says Dan Carter: becoming the first rugby nation to win back-to-back World Cups.
    • FOR USE ON CNN PHOTO BLOG ONLY

      Three days with 'The Greatest'

      Photographer Danny Lyon spent three days with Muhammad Ali in 1972 and shares his best photos and memories of the champ.
    • SOCHI, RUSSIA - FEBRUARY 23:  Sidney Crosby #87 of Canada celebrates after scoring his team's second goal in the second period during the Men's Ice Hockey Gold Medal match against Sweden on Day 16 of the 2014 Sochi Winter Olympics at Bolshoy Ice Dome on February 23, 2014 in Sochi, Russia.  (Photo by Martin Rose/Getty Images)

      Can ice hockey go global?

      With a growing audience boosted by the drama of ice hockey on show in Sochi at the Winter Olympics, can the sport capitalize on its popularity?
    • The first cover star of Sports Illustrated's swimsuit issue, Babette March

      Swimsuit legacy: First cover model

      Her paintings may sell for thousands of dollars, but she is best known for a modeling shot 50 years ago that helped launch a business empire.