Skip to main content
Part of complete coverage on

China's 21st century challenge: Define your narrative or fall behind

By Damien Ma, Special to CNN
updated 4:49 AM EST, Thu January 23, 2014
In November, China's Communist rulers announced an easing of the controversial one-child policy amid a raft of sweeping pledges unveiled including the abolition of 're-education' labor camps and loosening economic controls. In November, China's Communist rulers announced an easing of the controversial one-child policy amid a raft of sweeping pledges unveiled including the abolition of 're-education' labor camps and loosening economic controls.
HIDE CAPTION
China today
China today
China today
Chinese idea
China today
China today
China today
China today
<<
<
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
>
>>
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • Damien Ma looks for an indigenous idea to carry China forward in the 21st Century
  • And its transition into a modern state has been anything but smooth, he writes
  • He says few Chinese know or agree on what China should stand for in the 21st Century

Editor's note: Damien Ma is a Fellow at The Paulson Institute, focused on investment and policy programs and the Institute's research and think tank activities. He is the co-author of the book In Line Behind a Billion People: How Scarcity Will Define China's Ascent in the Next Decade. The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of Damien Ma. Follow him on Twitter.

(CNN) -- If the 21st century belongs to China, as some have argued, then it is worth asking what the defining Chinese idea will be.

It is unsurprising that this very issue has ginned up ferocious debate within China, as the country's might grows but its voice remains meek on the global stage.

Damien Ma
Damien Ma

Economic success alone has yet to evince a self-assured China that it can offer a set of compelling values and ideas to the world. As a country that prides itself on the continuity of its great civilization and cultural force, China seems to grow increasingly dissatisfied with punching below its weight in the world of ideas.

Indeed, much of the 20th century was defined by the rise of the United States and the dominance of the American idea: It was essentially an articulation of what modernity means.

To be modern meant widespread economic prosperity, a healthy middle class, and technological superiority, combined with values that emphasized individual rights and freedoms to pursue whatever lives, liberties, and happiness that one sought. It was a manifestation of the ideals that were enshrined in the Declaration of Independence, a document that, at the young nation's inception, defined what kind of country the United States ought to strive for.

It seems that China has little choice but to look to its distant past in search of a continuous narrative and an indigenous idea that can carry the nation forward in the 21st Century.
Damien Ma

In many ways, the country was born out of a few central ideas because its existence could not be predicated on strong ethnic kinships, bloodlines, or the old monarchical order. It was not the "Old World" but a new nation that was moving toward collective ideals. The belief in the very idea of America was the strongest glue that could bind together a diverse, continental nation.

That cohesive idea has anchored the "American Dream" and provided ballast for themes that are readily found in Hollywood and other popular culture products that pervade the global market. Whether by design or accidental, the genius of the American idea is that it is simply an open source template, or a "default setting," that can be easily replicated and customized in different cultural and institutional environments.

Its power and universalizing appeal is apparent. Little wonder that the American idea gained immense market share and is still widely equated with the general aspiration of obtaining a high living standard and human dignity.

China, in contrast, is both of the old world and a young republic -- or as scholar Lucian Pye once rendered it, "a civilization pretending to be a nation-state." And its transition into a modern state has been anything but smooth.

The modern Chinese state was forged from a nasty civil war, and its recent history since 1949 has been plagued by a series of highly disruptive discontinuities. It has had no continuous narrative from which to draw inspiration and to define the soul of a nation.

'On China:' Can Xi Jinping lead?
Will clean air goals hurt Chinese economy?
Xi borrows from Mao playbook

In fact, the People's Republic under Mao Zedong primarily defined itself as what it is not -- that is, it wasn't feudal or traditional. For the next six decades, the country lurched from devastating revolution to hyper materialism, breaking with whatever ideological milieu that had existed at the time. When Deng Xiaoping took power in 1978, the only "ism" that mattered was pragmatism, as the country went to work on nation building and zeroed in on material prosperity.

Thirty-five years and several trillions worth of GDP later, an entire generation of Chinese is waking up to the fact that it still has little idea of what kind of nation to strive for.

All this relentless work has built a dynamic middle-income economy, yet cumulative wealth is no substitute for the richness of a nation, especially for a China that believes it has much to offer the world. After all, this is a country that once brought the world paper, gunpowder, and the compass. Virtually every Chinese school child knows that.

But few Chinese know or agree on what China should stand for in the 21st century. It is clearly a global economic power, but unlike the United States, China seems to have little desire to stake out social and political values that others might adopt.

The Chinese government, which tightly controls historical narratives, simply cannot look into its recent past to seek out those values because even communism is derived from a Western political philosophy appropriated for Chinese conditions. And politically, it could be potentially disastrous if the government owned up to all the dark chapters in its recent past.

It seems that China has little choice but to look to its distant past in search of a continuous narrative and an indigenous idea that can carry the nation forward in the 21st Century.

The new leadership of the Communist Party, particularly President Xi Jinping, has prioritized this effort because it understands that a major source of its political power is derived from ideological legitimacy. To keep a continental nation together, China, too, needs a ruling party to govern around a set of ideas so that its people can imagine what the country can and should become.

And so the "great rejuvenation" of the Chinese nation has become the new ideological offering -- an explicit effort to connect today's China to the glories of a former empire that sat at the center of the world. It revives the traditional ideas of wealth and power that have defined the country through much of its history.

The Chinese leadership is leaving little doubt that China will once again be a global force that garners respect.

Yet it is far from clear what a rejuvenated China means or how that force might be employed. Reestablishing "national greatness" may win over some of the Chinese public, but it hardly serves as an idea or value proposition that can extend beyond Chinese borders.

Each nation is entitled to deem itself unique, exceptional, and "great" -- the United States certainly does. But some nations also use their wealth and power to articulate a vision of how to shape the world and aspire to address common challenges. The tagline for a U.S. Navy advertisement, for example, is "a global force for good."

China, at least so far, has exhibited little interest in becoming a charge d'affaires with world-shaping responsibilities, even as outside pressures mount for it to assume them. Indeed, it may simply be comfortable with being just China -- an idea that the rest of the world may have to get used to.

Read more: Xi Jinping's 2014 challenge: Resolving an identity crisis?

China marks muted 120th anniversary of Mao Zedong

Mind the gap: China's great education divide

The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of Damien Ma.

ADVERTISEMENT
Part of complete coverage on
updated 12:14 PM EST, Mon January 27, 2014
The World Economic Forum in Davos was a missed opportunity to start real dialogue and must change if it is to stay relevant, argues Richard Quest
updated 12:00 PM EST, Mon January 27, 2014
Nina dos Santos was in Davos interviewing world leaders by day, mingling at the parties of millionaires by night. So what are they really like?
updated 4:02 AM EST, Tue January 28, 2014
The World Economic Forum usually attracts protesters but this year's were very quiet. So why were they there?
updated 9:19 AM EST, Sat January 25, 2014
IMF chief Christine Lagarde says governments should beware of the global deflation genie coming out of its bottle.
updated 6:36 AM EST, Fri January 24, 2014
A relentless quest for share price boosts can result in disastrous long-term results, writes Andre Spicer.
updated 12:53 PM EST, Fri January 24, 2014
Actress Goldie Hawn says CEOs are discovering how to cope with stress and make better decisions .
updated 5:07 PM EST, Fri January 24, 2014
Richard Quest speaks to U.N. Secretary-General Ban Ki Moon about the progress being made in establishing Syrian peace.
updated 11:58 AM EST, Sat January 25, 2014
selfie Richard Quest
Selfie is the word du jour and CNN's Richard Quest set himself a selfie challenge, but which VIPs agreed to pose?
updated 4:31 AM EST, Fri January 24, 2014
Israel's President points a finger at Iran over the carnage in Syria, due to support for Shiite militant group Hezbollah.
updated 2:55 AM EST, Fri January 24, 2014
World Bank chief Jim Yong Kim calls for a concerted global effort to help Syria's refugees, saying the response so far has been inadequate.
updated 5:06 PM EST, Fri January 24, 2014
Richard Quest speaks to Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu about why cyber security is so important to the Israeli economy.
Think you're paid what you're worth? Explore how your wage compares to the average in your country, then see where you sit globally.
updated 5:25 PM EST, Thu January 23, 2014
CNN's Richard Quest speaks to Cantor Fitzgerald CEO Howard Lutnick about the lack of a crisis at Davos 2014.
updated 5:13 PM EST, Thu January 23, 2014
Richard Quest speaks to the OECD's Angel Gurria on how inequality and lack of economic growth are tied together.
updated 2:10 PM EST, Thu January 23, 2014
It's town of cuckoo clocks, $20 pasta and very slippery pavements -- tread carefully, warns first-timer Chris Pepper.
updated 2:20 PM EST, Thu January 23, 2014
Nina dos Santos speaks to former U.S. Treasury Sec. Larry Summers who says public sector investment should be encouraged.
updated 4:49 AM EST, Thu January 23, 2014
Almost 40 years and trillions worth of GDP after Mao, an entire generation still has little idea of what kind of nation to strive for, writes Damien Ma.
updated 10:18 AM EST, Wed January 22, 2014
CNN anchors Richard Quest and Nina dos Santos disagree as to whether this meeting of power players can make a difference to global inequality.
updated 12:17 AM EST, Thu January 23, 2014
The crisis in Syria was front and center for the movers and shakers as Davos formally got underway.
updated 11:41 AM EST, Wed January 22, 2014
Richard Quest heads to Davos, where everyone, it seems, has an event they want him to attend. Read his view of the parties.
updated 5:04 PM EST, Fri January 24, 2014
Richard Quest speaks to European Commission Pres. Jose Manuel Barroso about what can be done about the Ukrainian protests.
updated 3:18 AM EST, Wed January 22, 2014
Egypt has entrusted its democracy to the army, the police, a disempowered political class, writes Aalam Wassef.
Answer 4 questions to tell us if your mood is up or down, and see how others are responding.
updated 6:01 PM EST, Wed January 22, 2014
Speaking at the WEF in Davos, Japanese PM Shinzo Abe said that by 2020 women occupy 30% of leadership positions.
updated 10:46 AM EST, Wed January 22, 2014
Norway's Crown Prince Haakon says it is dangerous not to let youth help reshape the world, as they have the resources to act.
updated 10:03 AM EST, Wed January 22, 2014
Three years after the Arab Spring, its issues are back on the agenda and Syrian peace talks have begun. A Tunisian writer says little has changed.
updated 2:15 PM EST, Fri January 24, 2014
Ostentation-adverse Pope Francis has some serious cards to lay on the table in the game of global economic reform, writes John Allen.
updated 12:58 PM EST, Tue January 21, 2014
The World Economic Forum is not just a global gabfest. History is often made there, as Nina Dos Santos reports.
updated 7:51 AM EST, Mon January 20, 2014
We need to invest in human capital to combat a predatory capitalist system, argues Anne-Marie Slaughter.
updated 8:04 AM EST, Tue January 21, 2014
today's emerging markets can be divided into the tortoises and hares, CNN's John Defterios writes. But which will win 2014?
updated 5:30 AM EST, Tue January 21, 2014
CNN's Isa Soares talks to chef Alexandre Kroll about the challenges of cooking for the world's financial leaders in Davos.
updated 6:59 AM EST, Tue January 21, 2014
Why would a young person with a job, or in education, or training, want to riot and loot, when they have a stake in the future?
updated 2:29 PM EST, Fri January 24, 2014
The small Swiss town of Davos readies for its annual onslaught of world leaders and power players.
updated 10:52 AM EST, Mon January 20, 2014
CNN's Richard Quest says growing income inequality will be high on the agenda at the World Economic Forum.
updated 6:15 AM EST, Fri January 17, 2014
CNN's Richard Quest ponders whether he's climbing a Swiss mountain to learn the meaning of "heterarchy."
updated 7:14 AM EST, Sun January 19, 2014
What will business leaders, heads of government, entrepreneurs and celebrities discuss in Davos?
updated 12:26 PM EST, Mon January 20, 2014
Davos is invitation-only, but even if you made the cut, could you afford the entry fee? And once there, what do you need to do to fit in?
ADVERTISEMENT