Skip to main content

5 questions about the NSA court ruling

By Evan Pérez, CNN Justice Correspondent
updated 5:07 AM EST, Wed December 18, 2013

Washington (CNN) -- A federal judge ruled the National Security Agency's bulk collection of data on nearly every call made by U.S. phone subscribers is likely unconstitutional, providing ammunition to efforts to rein in surveillance programs that have expanded since the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks.

Judge: NSA domestic phone data-mining unconstitutional

Here are five questions about the implications of the court's ruling:

Snowden writes open letter to Brazil
NSA ruling exonerate Edward Snowden?
Analyst: NSA ruling only affects two

Q: How does the ruling affect the NSA's data collection?

A: The NSA continues to have legal authority, based on Section 215 of the Patriot Act, to collect phone metadata, which includes numbers called and length of calls.

The judge stayed his ruling to give the government time to appeal. But the ruling provides the first indication yet that the courts could put some limits on surveillance that the political branches of government -- Congress and successive administrations under Republican and Democratic presidents -- have not done.

If the ruling stands, it also means that more Americans could sue to have their data removed from the NSA's data collection programs.

Q: Why does the government collect the data and has it been useful for national security?

A: The Obama administration and officials from the Bush administration say the program is crucial to protecting national security.

NSA Director Keith Alexander has said the program, in conjunction with others, has thwarted more than 50 attacks. Supporters of the program in Congress put the number of attacks prevented at closer to 12 or 13.

In Monday's ruling, U.S. District Judge Richard Leon said the program doesn't appear useful at all, adding that government had not cited "a single instance" in which analysis of the NSA phone data program stopped an imminent terror attack.

Q: What have other courts said about the NSA program?

A: Until Monday's ruling, 15 different judges of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court had ruled 35 times that the NSA's phone data collection is legal under Section 215 of the Patriot Act, the government says.

The legality rests also in part on a 1979 Supreme Court ruling, called Smith v Maryland, that phone subscriber rights to privacy didn't include information held by the phone company, such as raw data on phone calls.

Last month, a federal judge in California rejected an attempt to challenge the NSA program, saying the expectation of privacy doesn't extend to phone data.

The Supreme Court, in a separate case last year, required police to seek warrants to attach a GPS device to a suspect's car, but most justices questioned whether the 1979 precedent still was valid given the advances in technology.

Analyst: NSA ruling only affects two
Can Edward Snowden get amnesty?

Q: What does the ruling mean for Edward Snowden, who disclosed the program?

A: The ruling could increase public support for the idea that Snowden deserves amnesty for exposing a program that now at least one judge thinks is unconstitutional. But the Obama administration flatly rejects any talk of amnesty.

Snowden's open letter offers to help Brazil investigate NSA surveillance

NSA official: Snowden amnesty 'worth having a conversation about'

The administration has said there is no plan to seek the death penalty if Snowden returns from his temporary exile in Russia to face federal charges for leaking NSA classified documents.

But Attorney General Eric Holder, in an interview with CNN, said of Snowden: "I think that he has clearly broken the law and harmed the nation that he claims to have loved."

Q: Are there efforts to change the NSA programs?

A: There are multiple proposals to change the NSA data collection programs, but the ones that have the likelihood of passing Congress would still allow the data collection to continue.

Some proposals would take the phone data program out of the NSA's hands and require the phone companies to collect the data, then allow the government to seek access to it. NSA officials call it a "hot potato" that no one wants to hold onto.

Opinion: Who broke the law, Snowden or the NSA?

Part of complete coverage on
Data mining & privacy
updated 10:25 AM EDT, Sun June 23, 2013
He's a high-school dropout who worked his way into the most secretive computers in U.S. intelligence as a defense contractor.
updated 8:26 AM EDT, Thu May 29, 2014
Traitor or patriot? Low-level systems analyst or highly trained spy?
updated 3:27 PM EDT, Thu May 29, 2014
What are the takeaways from Snowden's NBC interview? You might be surprised.
updated 7:52 AM EDT, Fri April 18, 2014
Months after accepting asylum in Russia, Snowden asked Putin about Moscow's own surveillance practices.
updated 12:43 PM EDT, Wed March 12, 2014
A federal judge has refused the Obama administration's request to extend storage of classified NSA telephone surveillance data beyond the current five-year limit.
updated 8:44 PM EDT, Sun March 9, 2014
From his sanctuary in the Ecuadorian embassy in London, Julian Assange said that everyone in the world will be just as effectively monitored soon -- at least digitally.
updated 8:39 PM EDT, Mon March 10, 2014
In a rare public talk via the Web, fugitive NSA leaker Edward Snowden urged a tech conference audience to help "fix" the U.S. government's surveillance of its citizens.
updated 11:55 PM EDT, Thu August 1, 2013
The White House is "very disappointed" that National Security Agency leaker Edward Snowden has been granted temporary asylum in Russia.
updated 8:57 AM EST, Tue December 10, 2013
Spies with surveillance agencies in the U.S. and U.K. infiltrated video games like "World of Warcraft" in a hunt for terrorists "hiding in plain sight" online.
updated 7:39 AM EDT, Fri August 2, 2013
Bradley Manning and Edward Snowden both held jobs that gave them access to some of their country's most secret and sensitive intelligence. They chose to share that material with the world and are now paying for it.
updated 10:35 AM EDT, Thu August 1, 2013
The NSA's controversial intelligence-gathering programs have prevented 54 terrorist attacks around the world, including 13 in the United States.
updated 2:54 PM EDT, Thu August 1, 2013
You've never heard of XKeyscore, but it definitely knows you. The National Security Agency's top-secret program essentially makes available everything you've ever done on the Internet.
updated 9:04 AM EDT, Sun August 18, 2013
You may have never heard of Lavabit and Silent Circle. That's because they offered encrypted (secure) e-mail services, something most Americans have probably never thought about needing.
updated 2:54 PM EDT, Wed July 24, 2013
"Any analyst at any time can target anyone. Any selector, anywhere ... I, sitting at my desk, certainly had the authorities to wiretap anyone."
updated 9:56 AM EDT, Tue July 2, 2013
President Barack Obama responds to outrage by European leaders over revelations of alleged U.S. spying.
updated 3:54 PM EDT, Fri August 29, 2014
Browse through a history of high-profile intelligence leaking cases.
updated 10:37 AM EDT, Tue July 2, 2013
Former President George W. Bush talks Snowden, AIDS, Mandela and his legacy.
updated 9:04 AM EDT, Wed June 26, 2013
Edward Snowden took a job with an NSA contractor in order to gather evidence about U.S. surveillance programs.
updated 6:47 AM EDT, Wed June 19, 2013
With reports of NSA snooping, many people have started wondering about their personl internet security.
updated 9:52 AM EDT, Wed August 14, 2013
Click through our gallery to learn about other major leaks and what happened in the aftermath.
updated 4:02 PM EDT, Sun June 9, 2013
What really goes on inside America's most secretive agency? CNN's Chris Lawrence reports.