Skip to main content

New York train wreck raises questions about 'alerter' devices

By Ray Sanchez, CNN
updated 2:48 PM EST, Tue December 10, 2013
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • Rail experts question a step taken to make trains safer after Metro-North wreck
  • Authorities are requiring "alerters" in every operator cab by end of 2015
  • Expert: "Alerter devices ... only partially effective"

(CNN) -- Rail experts Tuesday questioned the effectiveness of one step being taken by New York's Metro-North Railroad to ensure safety one week after the derailment of a speeding commuter train killed four people and injured dozens of others.

The Metropolitan Transportation Authority, which operates the railroad, said late Sunday that "alerter" systems -- which require engineers to respond to alerts, sound an alarm if they are unresponsive and eventually brake the train in an emergency-- will be installed in every operator cab within the next year. Currently, such systems in the engineer's position are present in two-thirds of the railroad's fleet.

The Hudson line train that derailed on December 1 had an alerter system in the engine car at the rear but not in the front cab, where the engineer apparently nodded off at the controls as the train approached a curve at 82 miles per hour. The engineer's lawyer and union representatives said the train's hypnotic motion may have caused him to nod off -- a case of what the lawyer termed "highway hypnosis."

Man vs. machine: Who should be at the wheel?

Steven Harrod, a University of Dayton professor and expert on railway operations, said the effectiveness of "alerter" systems is debatable.

"It's not the cure all for all problems," he told CNN. "Research has been done showing that some crews are adapting to these 'alerters' and they're still sleeping to the 'alerters.' It's that whole highway hypnosis thing."

A 2007 study of "alerter" technology by Massachusetts Institute of Technology said, "Engineers can become inattentive and keep hitting the alerter even when nodding off. 'Alerter naps' has become a commonly used term."

The study cited a 2006 National Transportation Safety Board investigation report on a freight train collision in Macdona, Texas, in which escaping liquified chlorine ultimately killed the conductor and two local residents. The study said the engineer experienced what it called "alerter naps" in which he "apparently drifted in and out of micro-sleep."

"I view the alerter devices as being only partially effective," Steven Ditmeyer, a former Federal Railroad Administration official who teaches at Michigan State University, said in an e-mail. "During my years in the railroad industry, there have been numerous occasions when locomotive engineers have responded to alerter alarms while being in less than a fully conscious state."

While two-thirds of Metro-North's operating fleet is equipped with alerters in the engineer's position, the remaining one-third is equipped with "dead man" controls, another safety measure which theoretically requires the conductor make continuous conscious input to keep the train running.

At the time of the accident, the train was in "push mode," meaning that the locomotive was in the rear of the train pushing it along the tracks, with engineer William Rockefeller in a cabin at the front operating it remotely. His cabin was equipped with a "dead man pedal" that required constant downward pressure with the foot to keep the train moving, the MTA has said. The dead man pedal was working properly, authorities said.

The newer model locomotive in the rear, however, was equipped with an alerter system which sounds a tone every 25 seconds, requiring the engineer to respond with a tap within 15 seconds while the train is in steady motion.

Late Sunday, the MTA said it was taking additional safety measures: Signal crews installed new protections at the bend near the Spuyten Duyvil station in the Bronx -- where the fatal derailment occurred -- to warn engineers of the speed reduction and automatically apply emergency brakes if speed is not lowered to 30 mph.

By Tuesday morning, the MTA said, Metro-North also enhanced communication between engineers and conductors to ensure trains are operated at safe speeds at four other critical curves and five movable bridges. Conductors will stand with engineers at the control cab through the critical curves or they will communicate by radio.

On Monday, the NTSB continued to rule out mechanical causes in a deadly crash while adding to the possibility that human error was involved. The NTSB said it has completed its inspection of the train and found no anomalies.

The board found no problems with speed sensors, the brake control unit or the train's propulsion controller.

At 7:11 a.m. that Sunday -- about 11 minutes before the derailment -- the engineer did not dim the train's headlights as required when it passed another train, the NTSB said Monday.

It also said it believes that positive train control, a costly, high-tech system that targets human error, could have prevented the crash. The safety board has pushed the system for about 20 years. Congress is requiring most major railroads, including Metro-North, to install the costly systems by the end of 2015.

David Rangel, an instructor at the Modoc Railroad Academy in Marion, Illinois, advocates putting another person in the engineer's cab of commuter trains, a practice that is common in freight trains and airplane cockpits.

"It will increase the cost, of course, but the alternative that the railroads are looking at, and the federal government is trying to force on the railroads, positive train control, is certainly much more costly," Rangel told CNN. "We're into the hundreds of millions of dollars right now and we haven't even had the implementation of that system. ... The problem here is that we are dealing with humans in the cabs of those locomotives and we have frailties."

ADVERTISEMENT
Part of complete coverage on
Industrial incidents
updated 9:37 AM EDT, Thu May 8, 2014
U.S. regulators issued a safety advisory urging freight railroads to avoid using older tank cars when hauling highly volatile crude oil when possible.
updated 10:03 PM EDT, Wed April 30, 2014
A pillar of black smoke billowed over downtown Lynchburg, Virginia, after a train carrying crude oil jumped its tracks and caught fire.
updated 4:15 PM EDT, Fri March 14, 2014
Stories continued to emerge as firefighters ferreted through the piles of bricks and wreckage on the East Harlem block where a powerful explosion and fire leveled two buildings.
updated 9:24 AM EDT, Mon March 17, 2014
Those two New York buildings were served by a very old gas main -- 127 years old to be exact. It's the latest incident in what experts warn is a dangerous trend plaguing the nation's oldest cities.
updated 7:56 PM EDT, Wed March 12, 2014
Some thought it was a bomb. Others thought it was the commuter train that runs behind their buildings jumping the tracks.
updated 7:48 PM EDT, Fri March 14, 2014
Metro-North Railroad, the second largest commuter rail line in the country, has a "deficient safety culture" and overemphasizes on-time performance.
updated 6:32 AM EST, Tue February 18, 2014
A roof collapsed at a resort retreat for college freshmen in South Korea, killing 10 people and injuring more than 100.
updated 11:45 PM EST, Thu February 13, 2014
An old auditorium collapsed at a village wedding in eastern China, killing at least nine people and injuring some 90 others.
updated 1:14 PM EST, Sun January 5, 2014
At least 14 people were killed when a building under construction at India's seaside tourist resort of Goa caved in.
updated 7:16 AM EST, Mon December 30, 2013
Part of a picturesque toll highway that tourists use to travel between the Mexican towns of Ensenada and Tijuana collapsed.
updated 2:16 PM EST, Sun December 8, 2013
Given the New York train derailment, are we approaching a time when machines should be powering our methods of travel forward?
updated 8:58 AM EST, Mon November 18, 2013
At least 27 people were killed when a cargo train slammed into two cars south of Cairo.
updated 12:43 PM EST, Sat November 23, 2013
Latvia's president has described the deadly collapse of a supermarket roof in Riga as "basically mass murder" of defenseless citizens.
updated 7:27 AM EST, Wed November 20, 2013
South Africa's Department of Labour is visiting the site of aroof collapse near the eastern city of Durban, in which at least one person died and 30 people were injured.
updated 4:28 AM EDT, Mon September 30, 2013
Authorities say they now know what may have caused a five-story building in Mumbai to collapse: a decorator who removed a central wall and supporting beams without permission.
updated 5:03 PM EDT, Tue July 30, 2013
The driver of a train that derailed in northwestern Spain, killing 79 people, was on the phone with railway staff when the train crashed.
updated 3:06 AM EST, Mon December 1, 2014
See images of industrial incidents spanning modern history
updated 7:52 AM EDT, Wed May 15, 2013
A city is in despair after many are killed in a garment factory collapse
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT