Skip to main content

Obamacare fix could add millions of dollars in government costs

By Adam Aigner-Treworgy, CNN
updated 7:56 PM EST, Fri November 15, 2013
  • Under plan, companies share costs of insuring customers
  • But new scenario may have them often facing a shortfall
  • That's when Uncle Sam steps in to make up difference

(CNN) -- President Barack Obama's proposal to allow people to keep canceled health plans for one year could end up costing the government millions of dollars.

This is due to a provision of the Affordable Care Act called risk corridors that allows for insurers to share the cost of insuring more expensive customers.

"The idea of the risk corridor was that insurers that made out real well, whose expenses ended up being much less than revenues would pay into the fund, and then insurers who ended up losing money would collect from the fund," said health law expert and Washington and Lee University law professor Timothy Jost.

"But, apparently, if less money is paid in then is paid out, the Treasury makes up the difference."

Democrats defect, back GOP Obamacare fix
President losing trust over Obamacare?

On a conference call with reporters before the president's announcement on Thursday, a senior Obama administration official admitted that the risk corridor program would likely have to be adjusted due to "the fact that there may be some people in these excepted plans and not in the marketplace."

"Given all the uncertainty about who's coming in and what's happening in this market, there's a risk sharing that goes on so that if the premiums are way off one direction or another, the government will share in that risk," the official said.

There's no good estimate yet as to how much the government's share may be, but a rough calculation from the Kaiser Family Foundation said the difference could be tens of millions or even hundreds of millions of dollars.

Actuaries assume that the pool of people who will choose to keep their current plans are generally healthier than the pool of people who will choose to enter the exchange. If those assumptions prove true, the makeup of exchange participants would skew towards older, sicker customers, resulting in higher costs for the insurance companies.

Insurance companies structured their premiums based on a balanced mix of healthy customers and sicker customers. That balance could now be in question.

"Political panic rarely makes for sound, considered policy decision-making," one health care executive said, in reaction to the president's proposal.

The cost to the federal government depends on how many state insurance commissioners allow canceled plans to continue next year, how many insurance companies decide to renew canceled plans, and how many consumers choose to keep their plans.

"In some ways, the insurance commissioners are the ballgame here," the executive said. "Even if insurers want to and can reinstitute plans, state commissioners can put the kibosh on them if they choose."

Already, Washington state Insurance Commissioner Mike Kreidler has announced that he will not allow canceled plans to be renewed for 2014.

What are the Obamacare trade-offs
More honest salesmanship on Obamacare?
How to fix Obamacare?

The risk corridors are not the only provision in the ACA meant to distribute risk among insurers and, in general, these provisions were expected to be paid for with money they take it. One key outstanding question is how the other risk sharing provisions of the ACA will apply to these old plans.

Ross Winkelman, a health actuary at Wakely Consulting Group, said that before the president's announcement, it was unclear whether the risk corridor program would force insurance companies or the government to pay more, but the new proposal will likely shift the balance towards insurance companies.

"If I had to bet, the net payment would be from the government coming back to the insurance companies now," Winkelman said.

Elaine Corrough with the Society of Actuaries agreed that the president's decision is likely to increase the number of insurance companies who will "expect to receive checks from the government."

The risk corridor provision is not required to be budget neutral, and is the only such provision that could result in a direct federal payment to insurance companies if too many younger, healthier consumers stay out of the exchange because of the president's proposal.

"To the extent that the risk pool changes in ways that were not foreseen by the insurers because of the announcement yesterday and they are not included in the bids that they proposed to the government and that their selection is riskier and more adverse that they anticipated then that could be an additional cost to the government," said Melinda Buntin, a former deputy director for health at the Congressional Budget Office and current chair of the Department of Health Policy at Vanderbilt University.

White House officials said the administration hasn't determined how the program will need to be adjusted due to the new proposal.

"It is premature to estimate any impact since HHS has not yet made a proposal," the administration official said.

Part of complete coverage on
updated 11:05 AM EDT, Wed July 23, 2014
On Tuesday, two U.S. appeals courts issued conflicting rulings on a subject that's important to millions of people: the availability of subsidies to help purchase coverage under the health-care law.
updated 10:06 AM EDT, Wed July 23, 2014
It was a tale of two rulings -- the best of times and the worst of times for Obamacare in the federal appeals courts.
updated 6:00 AM EDT, Wed July 23, 2014
President Barack Obama's poll numbers are nothing to brag about, but there's little evidence he has suffered so far this year a "Katrina moment" that caused his predecessor's numbers to plummet.
updated 6:00 AM EDT, Wed July 23, 2014
More than half the public says Obamacare has helped either their families or others across the country, although less than one in five Americans say they have personally benefited from the health care law, according to a new national poll.
updated 8:01 AM EDT, Fri July 11, 2014
House Republicans are going forward with plans to sue President Barack Obama and will base their legal case on the sweeping health care law he championed and they despise.
updated 4:13 PM EDT, Fri July 11, 2014
They tried in Congress, at the ballot box and in the Supreme Court, but Republicans have been unable to stop Obamacare.
updated 9:21 PM EDT, Mon June 30, 2014
The Supreme Court's decision was "sweeping," a "huge blow to the Obama administration," and a "shot in the arm for the evangelical movement," analysts said.
updated 7:45 PM EDT, Mon June 30, 2014
The ruling gives certain companies a right to raise religious objections to providing some types of birth control insurance to their employees leaves a number of important questions in its wake.
updated 6:41 PM EDT, Tue October 29, 2013
Nationally, consumers are learning a number of well-known hospitals won't accept insurance under Obamacare.
updated 1:16 PM EST, Mon December 23, 2013
Open enrollment started October 1. Here's a step-by-step guide to navigating the insurance marketplaces, also known as exchanges.
updated 4:37 AM EDT, Sat October 19, 2013
Obamacare has survived a Supreme Court appeal, a government shutdown and ongoing challenges by opposing politicians. With few exceptions, every American must have health insurance by March 31 or pay a penalty fee.
updated 10:44 AM EDT, Thu September 26, 2013
If you don't know what all those health insurance buzz-words like "co-pay" and "premium" mean, you're not alone.
updated 11:57 AM EDT, Wed October 2, 2013
Lauren Zanardelli and Graham Foster are the kind of customers the government needs to make Obamacare work.
It's a popular assertion, but is it true? The CNN Politics team hunts down the facts.
Some may offer help navigating the new health insurance marketplace for a fee. Others will warn that you will need a new Medicare card.
updated 12:57 PM EDT, Mon September 30, 2013
Who's in, who's out... and what about the costs? CNN Chief Medical Correspondent Dr. Sanjay Gupta breaks down Obamacare.
Consumers can avoid the exchanges by buying plans directly from insurers or through brokers. But should they?
Here's the first look at insurance premiums on 36 exchanges run by the federal government.
updated 10:46 AM EDT, Wed September 25, 2013
If we want to be realistic about health care reform, we have to acknowledge that everything comes with a tradeoff, Dr. Aaron E. Carroll says.
Check out our page with all things you need to know about Obamacare and how it will affect you.