Skip to main content

Australia's bushfires inflame climate change debate

By Peter Shadbolt, CNN
updated 9:22 PM EDT, Tue October 22, 2013
  • Australia has a long history of bushfires that predates white settlement
  • Scientists say that, despite shallow records, bushfire seasons are getting longer
  • Firefighters are reporting that fires are becoming larger and more aggressive
  • One scientist says forest fires around the world are contributing to global warming

(CNN) -- Australia's bushfires have such a long and destructive history there's almost no day of the week that hasn't been dubbed "black" or "ash" to mark a major conflagration.

There was Black Thursday in Victoria in 1851, which destroyed five million hectares and claimed 12 lives -- the first large-scale bushfire in the history of white settlement in Australia.

Since then there's been Red Tuesday in 1898 in Victoria, which consumed 2,000 buildings, Black Friday in Victoria in 1938 that killed 71 and destroyed 3,700 buildings, and Ash Wednesday in the early 1980s that left 71 dead in the state of South Australia.

Most recently in 2009, Black Saturday claimed 173 lives in the state of Victoria in southern Australia -- many of the victims unable to even get the distance of their own driveways before they succumbed to the intense radiant heat generated by a bushfire.

Many argue that Australia's catastrophic bushfires are simply a fact of life on a continent where its flora, heavy with combustible eucalyptus oil, constitute something of a seasonal time bomb.

Winds could cause Australian 'megafire'
Bush fires could head toward Sydney
Politics exacerbating raging wildfires?

Others say more sinister man-made factors are at work.

Changing climate

Australia has had a troubled relationship with climate change -- its confused policies on a controversial carbon tax are credited with felling the Labor Party at the last election, while the new government controversially disbanded the country's Climate Commission -- but scientists say the latest bushfire season may turn up the heat on the climate-change skeptics.

While the jury is still out on whether climate change is making conditions perfect for large-scale bushfires, scientists agree that bushfire seasons -- a regular occurrence on the Australian seasonal calendar -- are getting longer and the fires more intense.

According to David Bowman, professor of forest ecology at the University of Tasmania, who has studied bushfires for more than 30 years, bushfire behavior is showing signs of change.

"The problem with Australia is that the records are pretty shallow, which makes it really difficult to talk conclusively about any of the fire activity. But when you piece everything together there's some very convincing evidence.

Aggressive fires

"Even the firefighters are reporting really unusual behavior," said Bowman, adding that firefighters are fighting bigger and more aggressive fires.

"Normally at night -- and this is borne out by firefighters in the United States -- the fire will quell as the temperature cools. But firefighters are saying that because of the heat, bushfires are burning just as fiercely at night. It's all getting pretty worrying."

He said duration was also a factor that was changing in bushfire behavior.

"It's no big deal to have a fire in October but to have one that has burned like this for more than a week at this level of intensity is unprecedented.

"We are now looking at really catastrophic fire weather -- for October it just doesn't compute."

Anatomy of a bush fire: How Australia's explosive forest fires work

A nation built on fire

Fire has been part of the Australian landscape since the dawn of time and its people have used fire as a farming tool for more than 40,000 years. One of the earliest colonial watercolors shows an Aboriginal man gently setting fire to land that now makes up Sydney's most expensive waterside suburb of Vaucluse.

We are now looking at really catastrophic fire weather -- for October it just doesn't compute
Dr David Bowman

Known as fire-stick farming, this mosaic of fire management systems not only flushed out game such as kangaroos and possums, it created new growth which in turn attracted more game.

With indigenous people no longer part of the forest management equation, some scientists argue the fuel load that builds up from Australia's notoriously combustible vegetation is now one aspect that needs to be addressed.


Meanwhile, the emerging academic discipline of pyrogeography is looking at bushfires in Australia -- not just as a one-off catastrophic event -- but as part of an interconnected whole where forest fires around the world feed climate change and make conditions ripe for the propagation of even more fires.

Bowman says that deforestation fires alone -- the fires that have been used to destroy forests since the industrial revolution -- account for about one-fifth of all carbon dioxide committed to the atmosphere.

"That's a very significant component in global warming," he said.

One thing that is being noticed by scientists is that black carbon from forest fires is landing on ice sheets and accelerating ice melt.

Slippery factors

"These are tricky and slippery factors because there are places where feedback from fires is actually causing cooling, especially in places where the loss of forest has caused the snow to lie for longer leading to regional cooling."

Vegetation and natural conditions may change dramatically between New South Wales, Sumatra and California, but one thing these fires all share in common is that they are becoming more regular because the climate is becoming warmer.

Bowman said that vegetation in parts of Victoria, which normally completely regenerates over a 50-year cycle, is now being burned as often as three times in the period of one decade.

The particles from forest fires, he said, actually inhibit rainfall contributing to regional drying and warming, which creates a weather cycle conducive to fires. The problem for scientists, he added, was in connecting the dots with these patterns.

"It's like trying to find needles in haystacks."

Part of complete coverage on
Australia's bush fires
updated 5:26 PM EDT, Tue October 22, 2013
CNN's Jenny Harrison explains how small amounts of rain only hamper back burning efforts by Australian firefighters.
updated 4:21 PM EDT, Tue October 22, 2013
Robyn Curnow reports on the people who have lost everything in the Australia fires.
updated 9:22 PM EDT, Tue October 22, 2013
A firefighter hoses a tree, working to contain fires in a resident's backyard at Faulconbridge in the Blue Mountains on October 22, 2013.
Australia's bush fires have such a long and destructive history there's almost no day of the week that hasn't been dubbed "black" or "ash" to mark a major conflagration.
updated 7:00 PM EDT, Mon October 21, 2013
Meteorologist Tom Sater reports that dry conditions and warm temperatures caused a bad start to Australia's fire season.
updated 9:50 AM EDT, Tue October 22, 2013
CNN's Robyn Curnow talks to one Australian family who lost everything when wildfires destroyed their home.
updated 9:20 PM EDT, Tue October 22, 2013
Unpredictable and capricious, bush fires are an erratic phenomenon -- houses burn but kitchen tables are left intact, garages burn to the ground leaving cars inside untouched.
updated 1:26 AM EDT, Wed October 23, 2013
A swath of wildfires nearly 1,000 miles long coursed through Australia's most populous state Tuesday, and firefighters fear the worse is yet to come.
updated 12:51 AM EDT, Tue October 22, 2013
Australian residents lived in fear of a "megafire" Monday as dozens of bush blazes threaten to converge.
updated 2:52 PM EDT, Mon October 21, 2013
CNN's Christiane Amanpour speaks with Stan Grant, international editor of Sky News Australia.
updated 8:23 PM EDT, Sun October 20, 2013
Firefighter Michael Green shares his firsthand account of the intense bushfires in Australia with CNN's Patricia Wu.
updated 6:07 AM EDT, Sun October 20, 2013
Weather conditions are expected to worsen, making the battle against Australia's bushfires tougher. Seven Network reports.
updated 11:55 AM EDT, Mon October 21, 2013
Australian residents live in fear of a "mega-fire" Monday as blazes threaten to converge after already consuming an area roughly the size of L.A.
updated 8:31 AM EDT, Sat October 19, 2013
Two of the dozens of bush fires burning out of control in New South Wales were sparked by power lines that had been buffeted by strong winds, officials say.
updated 6:17 AM EDT, Mon October 21, 2013
Officials fear several fire fronts may merge into a "megafire." CNN's Robyn Curnow reports.
updated 7:16 AM EDT, Fri October 18, 2013
Bush fires blazing in Australia claimed their first victim Friday after a man died of a suspected heart attack defending his home.
updated 7:41 PM EDT, Fri October 18, 2013
Hundreds of homes have burned in Australia's Blue Mountains. Sky News Australia's Ahron Young reports.