Skip to main content

Judge expanding investigation of Spain train crash to include executives

By Al Goodman, CNN
updated 12:14 PM EDT, Tue September 10, 2013
Spain's Princess Elena, left, Princess Letizia and Prince Felipe attend <a href='http://www.cnn.com/2013/07/29/world/europe/spain-train-crash/index.html'>a funeral Mass for the victims of a train</a> derailment at a cathedral in Santiago de Compostela on Monday July 29. At least 79 people have been confirmed dead in the July 24 crash in northwest Spain. Spain's Princess Elena, left, Princess Letizia and Prince Felipe attend a funeral Mass for the victims of a train derailment at a cathedral in Santiago de Compostela on Monday July 29. At least 79 people have been confirmed dead in the July 24 crash in northwest Spain.
HIDE CAPTION
Spanish train crash aftermath
Spanish train crash aftermath
Spanish train crash aftermath
Spanish train crash aftermath
Spanish train crash aftermath
Spanish train crash aftermath
Spanish train crash aftermath
Spanish train crash aftermath
Spanish train crash aftermath
Spanish train crash aftermath
<<
<
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
>
>>
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • Preliminary charges in the Spain train crash will now include top railway officials
  • Judge Luis Alaez Legeren is adding the charges because the train lacked a safety system
  • He notes there were systems in place at various places, but driver error was not anticipated
  • The crash took the lives of 79 people and injured some 170

Madrid (CNN) -- The judge investigating the train crash that killed 79 people last July is expanding the preliminary charges to include numerous top officials of the state railway infrastructure company, Adif, for alleged negligence, a Tuesday court order shows.

Judge Luis Alaez Legeren wrote that five Adif officials in charge of track and signal security, along with the current and two former Adif presidents, will face preliminary charges because there was no safety system that would have compensated for any human error by the train driver.

The prime suspect remains the driver, Francisco Jose Garzon, who already faces preliminary charges of 79 counts of homicide by professional recklessness.

The judge's latest order states that the passenger train was going more than twice the speed limit when it derailed on a curve near the northwest city of Santiago de Compostela. In addition to 79 fatalities, some 170 passengers were injured.

Desperate train crash audio released
Court: Train driver on phone during crash
Pilgrims mourn Spain train crash victims

Just before the crash, the driver took a phone call from another official on the train to discuss the train's route farther north on the journey, the judge wrote.

An Adif spokeswoman said the company had no immediate comment about the judge's order, and company lawyers were studying it.

In the eight-page order sent by the court to reporters, the judge cites various security systems in place along the section of track where the accident occurred. But he adds it appears that Adif officials did not adequately mitigate all the predictable scenarios of human error by the driver.

Since the accident, the speed limit at the curve has been reduced from 80 kilometers per hour (50 mph) to just 30, Adif has confirmed.

Last week, Spanish newspaper El Pais exclusively obtained audio of the driver's first, desperate phone call, while injured and still trapped inside the engine, to the train's control center.

The court said it did not release the audio, but there are several parties to the case who may have had access to it.

In the audio, the driver told his control center he "got distracted" and was going 190 kilometers an hour when he should have been doing 80.

News media reported that part of the conversation in the days after the crash, citing officials, who blamed excessive speed for the crash.

But the audio recording also contains allegations by the driver that were not widely reported weeks ago, namely his contention that he had warned authorities about what he called the dangerous curve.

"I had already told security it was dangerous, that one day we were going to eat it, and it happened to me," the driver, Garzon, is heard telling the control center in the audio recording.

A few moments later he added, "Oh God, I had already told the people from security that it was very dangerous. We are human ... and this can happen... that this curve is inhumane. Understand? If there was a warning light ..."

For weeks, the judge has been investigating other potential causes for the accident, beyond the train's excessive speed.

In the court order Tuesday, he also asked Adif to provide the names of all company board members and all rail security senior officials, since December 2011. That's when the section of track where the accident occurred, and its security systems, went into operation.

READ: Spain train crash victim: 'It felt like a roller coaster'

ADVERTISEMENT
Part of complete coverage on
Spain Train Crash
updated 10:53 PM EDT, Thu July 25, 2013
The train races into view, and in the space of a heartbeat, the cars derail and crash into a wall of concrete, flipping onto their sides and skidding along the track with terrifying speed and force.
updated 12:51 PM EDT, Sun July 28, 2013
A train crash in Santiago de Compostela, Spain, poses questions for investigators, who are homing in on what role the train's speed may have played in the crash.
updated 4:56 PM EDT, Thu July 25, 2013
CNN's Jonathan Mann speaks with train expert George Bibel about the factors that can cause a derailment.
updated 12:26 PM EDT, Mon July 29, 2013
See images of from the scene of the crash.
updated 5:09 AM EDT, Thu July 25, 2013
CNN iReporter captures images of a deadly train crash in Spain.
updated 12:51 PM EDT, Sun July 28, 2013
The last thing Elder Stephen Ward remembers is flying sideways out of his seat.
updated 8:50 AM EDT, Fri July 26, 2013
Spain's King Juan Carlos and Queen Sophia visited with train crash survivors at the hospital. CNN's Al Goodman reports.
updated 2:07 PM EDT, Thu July 25, 2013
iReporter Ivette Rubiera describes what she saw in the aftermath of a train crash and fire in Spain.
ADVERTISEMENT