Skip to main content

Mom anguishes over child poisoned by lunch: Why aren't you coming back?

By Harmeet Shah Singh, Sumnima Udas and Ashley Fantz, CNN
updated 8:27 PM EDT, Thu July 18, 2013
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • NEW: Authorities had previously criticized food safety problems in the state's schools
  • Investigators are searching for the headmistress and her husband for questioning
  • Statements from the cook about the cooking oil seem contradictory
  • Authorities believe the poison is a sarin-like nerve gas used in agriculture

Bihar, India (CNN) -- A father holds his limp child in his arms, carrying her from the school he trusted to take care of her. A video camera focuses on his face locked in total anguish. Everyone around him is shouting. He goes to the back of an open van and struggles to keep the white blanket he's wrapped around his child's body from slipping as he lays the body down.

The mother of a 5-year-old repeatedly calls her daughter's name.

Why aren't you coming back, she pleads.

"Why isn't anyone bringing Dipu back?!"

These moments came in the wake of the deaths of 23 Indian children who were poisoned by school lunches they were given Tuesday, authorities say.

A woman rests with her child at a ward housing the poisoned schoolchildren at the Patna Medical College and Hospital, in the eastern Indian state of Bihar, Wednesday, July 17. At least 22 schoolchildren died in northeastern India after eating free school lunches that contained an insecticide commonly used in agriculture. Officials are investigating whether the poisoning was accidental or deliberate. A woman rests with her child at a ward housing the poisoned schoolchildren at the Patna Medical College and Hospital, in the eastern Indian state of Bihar, Wednesday, July 17. At least 22 schoolchildren died in northeastern India after eating free school lunches that contained an insecticide commonly used in agriculture. Officials are investigating whether the poisoning was accidental or deliberate.
Deadly school lunch in India
HIDE CAPTION
<<
<
1
2
3
4
5
6
>
>>
Deadly school lunch in India Deadly school lunch in India
Indian village devastated by deaths

The students, who authorities said were between the ages of 5 and 12, started vomiting soon after their first bite of rice and potatoes at their government primary school in the northern state of Bihar. Some fainted.

Earlier, authorities had said 22 children had died, but on Thursday district magistrate Abhijit Sinha explained that one deceased boy had not been counted in the initial death toll because his father had taken his body without handing it over for autopsy.

Grief and anger so permeate this poverty-stricken community that parents of at least three children have buried their lost ones near the school -- one right in front of the building, according to CNN journalists who saw the burial mounds. Sinha told CNN that the burials were acts of protest.

Demonstrations have popped up around the area as people seek answers about how this tragedy could have happened. One video segment showed men apparently attacking a school bus with sticks. Others gathered and held signs.

Students at nearby schools refused to eat.

"I am scared now. ... There is fear in our hearts," one child told CNN sister network CNN-IBN.

Meanwhile, a top federal official said authorities had warned of safety problems with the state's school meal program months ago.

And police told CNN that investigators have been unable to find the headmistress of the school in order to question her.

Authorities have not named the headmistress and her husband, whom they also want to interview, local police chief Sujit Kumar said Thursday.

Was it the oil?

On Thursday, 25 people remained hospitalized. Cameras captured children lying in an open space on cots; one writhed and sobbed while another stayed still, staring with glassy eyes.

The school cook, Manju Devi, is also hospitalized. The cook's accounts of the incident are under scrutiny.

Bihar state Education Minister P.K. Shahi said the children were poisoned by an insecticide that was in the food.

Shahi said he heard reports that the cook had questioned the quality of the oil she was supposed to use, but was overruled by the school's headmistress.

"The information which has come to me indeed suggests that the headmistress was told by the cook that medium of cooking was not proper, and she suspected the quality of the oil," Shahi said. "But the headmistress rebuked her, and chastised the children, and forced them to continue the meal."

It's unclear how the children were "forced" to continue eating.

On Thursday, the cook told Reuters on tape: "When I saw the oil it looked like it had a layer at the bottom of the jar. I thought that this is locally made oil, as often there is an accumulation of residual waste at the bottom when the oil is domestically prepared. Generally we get just about enough oil to prepare one meal, as there is no space for storage."

But in a later interview with CNN the same day, the cook said she didn't suspect anything unusual about the oil.

Report expected Thursday night

Sinha, the district magistrate, said an inquiry into the deaths is under way, CNN sister network CNN-IBN reported.

India's school meal program: Ambitious, but far from perfect

Investigators have taken seven samples of food at the school and have sent them for examination, Kumar told CNN, adding he expects a report back Thursday night.

Authorities have gone to the headmistress' house and found stacks of vegetables and grains, Kumar told CNN Thursday. They did not find any pesticides, he said.

"In any Indian home you will find vegetables and grains. These are all allegations," he said. "Everybody is alleging that she is the one responsible and as a professional police officer, I'll collect evidence and only then I will know."

He said the investigation is ongoing and that "if there is a basis for it," authorities will arrest the headmistress.

"But we at least have to speak with her and get her statement," he said.

Kumar told CNN that he was going to the hospital, where he hoped to speak with the ailing children and their families.

Government standards

Attention is turning to government accountability over the school food program that feeds more than 100 million children, but often with different standards across the country.

Investigators had previously flagged food safety issues at schools in Bihar state, noting in a report that "most schools served often average quality of food items in unhygienic condition."

The food, according to an April report from India's Ministry of Human Resource Development, "was kept in open and dirty ground."

"We had alerted the Bihar government quite a few months back about shortcomings in its food storage. We had expected that the Bihar government would have acted on the recommendations," Human Resources Development Minister Pallam Raju told CNN-IBN. "It is a failure in the system that the rectification has not been done, and I certainly hope that accountability will be called for."

"It is just a reflection of the sort of neglect ... and these sorts of concerns in that state and states around that area," said Reetika Khera of the Indian Institute of Technology in Delhi.

"In the southern part of the country, children get not only good quality food, they also get very nutritious food," she said. "But this is not the case in Bihar."

The school meal program is run by the Indian government in collaboration with state governments, Khera said.

But she said substandard school food is "a reflection of a more general problem, which is the lack of political interest in these programs and -- very importantly -- the lack of accountability."

Education official: We're trying to improve

Shahi, the Bihar state education minister, told CNN that 20 million children receive hot meals in about 73,000 elementary schools.

"We have been endeavoring to improve the quality and ... try to get good food served," he told CNN's Michael Holmes.

"However, the challenge is still there because the magnitude of this program is so huge that there are a number of challenges." He said those challenges are at least partly financial.

"Even though I would unhesitatingly admit that there are some quality issues before us, this is the first incident which has happened in the state," Shahi said. "In the past, we have received complaints regarding quality, but the incident of this nature ... has really shocked us -- shocked the entire state."

What was the poison?

It's unclear whether the children were intentionally or accidentally poisoned.

But officials believe the poison was an organophosphorus compound, a type of chemical that the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention says is commonly used in agriculture.

It's a nerve agent related to sarin gas, which is used in chemical warfare, the U.S. Health Department says.

Exposure to a high dose can cause an irregular heartbeat, difficulty breathing, paralysis and seizures.

Violence erupted Thursday when dozens of men reportedly attacked one of the base kitchens of the Ekta Shakti Foundation -- a non-governmental organization that supplies lunches to more than 1,200 schools in the Chhapra district of Patna.

The group's vice president, Rajnikant Pathak, told CNN the foundation had already stopped supplying meals to students Wednesday after news of the deaths.

Free meals to tackle malnutrition

A program providing one free hot meal a day to school children has proved incredibly popular as part of India's wider effort to tackle malnutrition. Children ages 6 months to 14 years get take-home rations or are provided with hot cooked food.

The wider $22 billion-a-year welfare scheme aims to sell subsidized wheat and rice to 67% of its 1.2 billion people.

According to the Indian government's figures, nearly half of India's children suffer from malnutrition of some sort.

Since a landmark Supreme Court decision in 2001, all government schools in India have been required to provide free meals to students younger than 13.

In 2012: Poisoning sends 38 Mexican kindergarteners to hospital

CNN's Sumnima Udas, Harmeet Singh and Aloke Devich reported from Bihar; Holly Yan and Ashley Fantz wrote from Atlanta. Elizabeth Joseph contributed from Hong Kong. CNN's Aliza Kassim, Tim Hume and journalist Neha Sharma also contributed to this report.

ADVERTISEMENT
Part of complete coverage on
updated 4:01 PM EDT, Mon September 22, 2014
The U.S. has promised to supply and train "acceptable" rebels in Syria to counter ISIS. But who are they and are can the strategy work?
updated 10:57 PM EDT, Mon September 22, 2014
Do the Chinese really like to mix their Bordeaux with Coca-Cola?
updated 6:34 AM EDT, Tue September 23, 2014
Al Qaeda's new Syrian branch, Khorasan, is seeking new ways to attack America and Europe, with a top U.S. intelligence official saying it has "aspirations for attacks on the homeland."
updated 8:39 PM EDT, Mon September 22, 2014
Branded an "extremist" by China's state-run media, Joshua Wong isn't even old enough to drive.
updated 2:55 AM EDT, Mon September 22, 2014
Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi surprised political pundits with his rapid rise to power. CNN meets the man behind the enigma.
updated 7:44 AM EDT, Mon September 22, 2014
Liverpool's Italian forward Mario Balotelli reacts during the UEFA Champions League Group B match between Liverpool and Ludogorets Razgrad at the Anfield stadium in Liverpool on September 16, 2014.
British police launched an investigation into abusive tweets sent to Liverpool striker Mario Balotelli.
updated 7:44 PM EDT, Sun September 21, 2014
A woman who was texting her husband before he was killed reflects on the Westgate attack.
updated 11:54 AM EDT, Mon September 22, 2014
The real secret to a faster commute has been with us all along -- the bus.
updated 9:16 AM EDT, Mon September 22, 2014
13 brands retained their Top 20 status from last year, according to an annual survey.
updated 11:49 AM EDT, Mon September 22, 2014
Think your new tattoo is cool? Look at how our ancestors did it and think again.
updated 7:00 AM EDT, Mon September 22, 2014
Each day, CNN brings you an image capturing a moment to remember, defining the present in our changing world.
Browse through images from CNN teams around the world that you don't always see on news reports.
ADVERTISEMENT