Arizona mayor opposes razor wire on border fence

A proposal to put razor wire atop parts of the border fence near Nogales, Arizona, shown here in 2010, faces opposition.

Story highlights

  • Razor wire could be placed atop the border fence near Nogales, Arizona
  • The area is considered part of the Border Patrol's Tucson Sector
  • The Tucson Sector is a major drug and human trafficking corridor
  • Mayor, a Nogales native, serves on Southwest Border Task Force

An Arizona mayor is comparing a Border Patrol proposal to put razor wire on portions of the U.S.-Mexico border fence to building the Berlin Wall.

"We've had a black eye because everybody is using the border as a political issue," Nogales Mayor Arturo Garino said.

The proposal, according to Garino, would put concertina wire on top of the 20-foot-high fence to the east and west of town.

"Tucson Sector Border Patrol is considering a proposed deployment of concertina wire in the Nogales area," Border Patrol spokesman Brent Cagen wrote in an e-mail. "Currently this proposal is still under review. Specifics concerning this proposal are unavailable at this time."

Should the U.S. be more like Mexico?

Nogales is a major trade hub on the border, abutting the Mexican state of Sonora. It is considered part of the Border Patrol's Tucson Sector, which consists of 262 miles stretching from the Arizona-New Mexico border to Yuma County, near Lukeville.

The push for immigration overhaul

    Just Watched

    The push for immigration overhaul

The push for immigration overhaul 01:18
Agreeing to disagree on immigration

    Just Watched

    Agreeing to disagree on immigration

Agreeing to disagree on immigration 02:09

Garino, a former law enforcement officer and member of the Southwest Border Task Force, praised the Border Patrol for the "tremendous" decrease in drug and human trafficking in southern Arizona. But he said that adding razor wire will negatively affect international trade.

"I strongly believe we don't need it," he said. "It's an eyesore. It's a dangerous thing. We need to build relations with Sonora and Mexico. Let's become a power in the world economy."

Victor Brabble, public affairs manager for U.S. Customs and Border Protection, said Garino's concerns will be taken into account before a final decision is made.

"We are consulting with community leaders to evaluate the economic, environmental, political, and social implications our proposals may have on the communities we serve," he wrote in an e-mail.

House GOP split over immigration reform

Nogales City Councilman John Doyle, a Nogales native, echoed Garino's opposition to the proposal and said he was shocked to learn about it.

"We've always been the home of the brave, and now we are living in fear," he said.

Nogales officials will meet with Homeland Security personnel this week to continue reviewing the proposal, which is being considered as a deterrent to would-be illegal crossers, Garino said.

"Right now, it's a proposal," he said. "But if somebody says 'yes,' it's going up."

Garino also grew up in Nogales and said he thinks the best deterrent is increased manpower. Agents should be reassigned from checkpoints and interior bases to the border, he said.

"Bring the Border Patrol to the border and have them do their jobs."

'The Bridge' brings U.S.-Mexico border tensions to TV