Skip to main content

Airliners too close for comfort over New York

By Laura Ly, CNN
updated 11:52 AM EDT, Tue June 25, 2013
  • FAA: Planes were about a half-mile apart horizontally and about 200 feet vertically
  • FAA reports close encounter between Delta 747, Shuttle America E170
  • The June 13 incident ended with both planes landing safely
  • Delta says it's cooperating with the FAA investigation

New York (CNN) -- A pair of large passenger jets passed alarmingly close to each other in the busy skies over New York, the FAA said Friday.

Although the Delta Boeing 747 and Shuttle America Embraer E170 landed safely, the June 13 incident has triggered an FAA investigation, the agency said.

It happened about 2,000 feet above the borough of Queens, the FAA said, as the 747 Jumbo Jet was approaching John F. Kennedy International Airport and shortly after the E170 had taken off from nearby LaGuardia Airport.

Both planes were turning away from each other at the point where they "lost the required separation," an FAA spokeswoman said. Delta Air Lines said it was cooperating with the FAA's investigation.

The incident offers an unsettling reminder of the region's complicated and crowded air traffic landscape.

At their closest, the two planes were separated by about half a mile horizontally and about 200 feet vertically, the FAA said.

Under FAA regulations, they were required to be at least three miles apart horizontally or 1,000 feet apart vertically.

Air traffic control audio recordings revealed how a controller alerted the larger Delta plane and rerouted it as the Shuttle America Embraer jet closed in.

"Delta 172 Heavy, traffic, 12 o'clock, 1,400 feet Embraer," a controller says on the recording. "OK, we're turning right," the Delta pilot tells the controller.

A Delta Boeing 747 similar to this one and a Shuttle America Embraer E170 passed alarmingly close on June 13, the FAA said. Both planes landed safely.
A Delta Boeing 747 similar to this one and a Shuttle America Embraer E170 passed alarmingly close on June 13, the FAA said. Both planes landed safely.

The 747 is one of the world's largest passenger airliners, with a capacity of about 350 to 400 seats. The Shuttle America E170 has a capacity of 70 to 80 passengers, according to Embraer's website.

What makes daily air traffic in the region challenging are its three major airports -- JFK, LaGuardia and Newark's Liberty International Airport in New Jersey -- all sharing airspace over one of the nation's most populated cities.

"New York has a very, very tight airspace," said Phil Derner, founder of the aviation news site "You're talking about three major, packed airports that are trying to act in unison. It can be very unforgiving."

The scare follows a string of close calls during the past few years across the nation's skies.

Last year, a control tower miscommunication resulted in three airplanes barely missing each other over the nation's capital.

Also last year, a passenger plane over Denver was caught on radar steering directly into the line of other aircraft, narrowly avoiding a collision.

In 2010, a pilot took a wrong turn at Boston's Logan International Airport, steering directly into the path of another plane. A crash was avoided after an air traffic controller quickly called for the plane to stop.

Passenger plane, military helicopter come close near D.C. airport

CNN's Mike M. Ahlers, Jesse Solomon, Dave Alsup and Rene Marsh contributed to this report.

Part of complete coverage on
It's New Year's Eve, and we're suspended 2,000 feet over Atlanta by an iconic gas bag. Hard to believe I'm actually flying the Goodyear blimp.
Superjumbo, the world's largest passenger plane, has finally conquered the world's busiest airport.
The Soviet shoot-down of Flight 007 killed 269 people, triggering outrage, conspiracy theories and an activist movement that lives on.
A pilot/film consultant with time in Cessnas, fighter jets and airliners reveals behind-the-scenes details about the aviation version of "Cars."
These huge planes have names like Dreamlifter and Super Guppy. Conversations stop. Fingers point. How can something so big defy gravity?
Pilots ranked Hong Kong's now-closed Kai Tak among the world's trickiest airports. Even top pilots said landing was hair-raising. Here are their stories.
It's an airport security idea that could sweep the U.S.: aviation enthusiasts who alert police about potential terrorism. They're doing it in Chicago.
Where avgeeks get REALLY close. It's arguably the most famous spotting destination on the planet: Maho Beach on the island of St. Maarten.
Here's the inside scoop on the plane crash scene in Denzel Washington's film "Flight" and how real pilots worked to save lives aboard United Flight 232.
He's a "hillbilly" who's been going full speed his whole life. Finally, Preston Henn got his hands on the fastest executive jet on the planet: the G650.
A coach class seat can be a chair of torture. Airline seat experts talk frankly about the anger and discomfort surrounding airline seats.
Can you analyze a traveler's personality by their favorite airplane seat? Of course not; don't be ridiculous. But let's do it anyway.
The Air Force calls it 309 AMARG: a 2,600-acre parking lot for about 5,000 retired U.S. military aircraft. And it's on my avgeek bucket list.
Join us aboard United Flight 1. For the first time since it was grounded for battery troubles, Boeing's 787 Dreamliner returns to domestic service.
 AF447 Rio-Paris plane flight black boxes displayed during a press conference on May 12, 2011, at the BEA headquarters at the airport of Le Bourget.
If data had been uplinked from Air France Flight 447 to satellites before it crashed, would loved ones have been spared some of their anguish?
Hijacker "D.B. Cooper" jumped from a 727 with $200,000. He was never caught. What happened to the top witness, an ex-flight attendant?
The Disbergers have turned airline getaways into an art form: 243 family trips, 7.5 million miles. Here's what they've learned.