Skip to main content

No evidence global warming spawned twister

By Elizabeth Landau, CNN
updated 1:13 PM EDT, Wed May 22, 2013
CNN iReporter Brenton Leete took this photo of the tornado on the ground in Moore, Oklahoma, on Monday.
CNN iReporter Brenton Leete took this photo of the tornado on the ground in Moore, Oklahoma, on Monday.
  • Expert: Moore tornado likely would have happened regardless of global warming
  • Science has stronger support for connection between climate change and drought, heat wave
  • More research and discussion is needed about future warming and storms

(CNN) -- Yes, climate change is happening. But it's hard to say that the tornado that ripped through Moore, Oklahoma -- or any given tornado, for that matter -- was influenced by climate change.

Scientific research has not made a clear connection between tornadoes and climate change, said J. Marshall Shepherd, climate change expert and professor at the University of Georgia.

There is currently a much better understanding of how climate change increases the risks of droughts, heat waves and precipitation, he said. There are also indications that changing patterns may influence the intensity of hurricanes. But as far as tornadoes: There's just not a lot of information.

As far as the Moore tornado, "This tornadic storm, in my view, probably would have happened irrespective of whether there's climate change or not," Shepherd said. "The question is: Are we increasing the risk and probability of more extreme events in general as our climate differs?"

See physics behind why buildings crumble
FEMA deployed to Oklahoma City
Myers: Like a bowling ball went through

More research and discussion is needed about future warming and the environments that might produce storms, he said.

Trends in tornado occurrence over the last 50 years do not appear to have changed in conjunction with more greenhouse gases in the atmosphere and patterns of rising temperatures, Shepherd said.

Beyond the climate change question, meteorologists don't know a lot about why some thunderstorms produce tornadoes and not others. According to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, only about 1% of thunderstorms generate tornadoes. However, tornado prediction is advancing and evolving.

Weather, says Shepherd, is like mood -- it changes all the time. The deeper underlying forces we call "climate" are like personality. Greenhouse gases building up in our ocean atmosphere system, from human activity, influence that personality -- which is much harder to undo.

To put it a different way, a driver who is sober has a certain risk of getting into an accident, said Patrick Kinney, the study's senior author and director of the Columbia Climate and Health Program at Columbia University's Mailman School of Public Health. The risk goes up with a couple of drinks. Similarly, as humans pump more greenhouse gas into the atmosphere, that raises the likelihood of extreme weather events.

"Greenhouse gases are kind of like the alcohol in the system of the climate," Kinney said.

Climate change will mean more heat deaths

Earlier this month, scientists measured for the first time an average carbon dioxide concentration of 400 parts per million at Mauna Loa Observatory in Hawaii, representing a new peak for this iconic monitoring station.

More space and science news from CNN Light Years

Part of complete coverage on
Oklahoma City Tornadoes
updated 1:30 PM EDT, Tue May 20, 2014
Max Broderick remembers exactly what he did a year ago Tuesday.
updated 9:58 AM EDT, Mon June 3, 2013
Heavy storms and tornadoes once again ripped through the Midwest. Already devastated areas of Oklahoma were hit again, and this time the damage spread to neighboring states. Here's how you can help.
updated 11:30 AM EDT, Thu May 30, 2013
Families share memories and snapshots of those we lost in the Oklahoma tornado devastation.
updated 1:11 PM EDT, Wed June 5, 2013
The Oklahoma medical examiner's office says 18 people in that state were killed in the storms. The office has released the names of 11.
updated 9:58 AM EDT, Tue June 4, 2013
They chased tornadoes not so much for the thrill, but in the hope that their research might help people avoid the fate to which they succumbed last week.
updated 10:14 AM EDT, Tue June 4, 2013
A menacing tornado churned behind Mike Eilts as the storm chaser's truck sped away.
updated 6:26 AM EDT, Mon May 27, 2013
Why do people in Tornado Alley keep rebuilding and staying in place after storms rip through? People from Moore share their reasons why.
updated 5:07 PM EDT, Mon May 27, 2013
See the best images from the deadly storm.
updated 10:39 AM EDT, Wed May 22, 2013
It's one of the most familiar pieces of advice from authorities to people in the path of a tornado: Get into your basement.
updated 7:55 AM EDT, Thu May 23, 2013
On Sunday, a mystery photograph fluttered from the sky and landed near Leslie Hagelberg's mailbox in West Tulsa, Oklahoma.
The tornado spanned 1.3 miles -- the length of more than 22 football fields lined up end-to-end -- carved a 17-mile path of destruction.
updated 2:31 PM EDT, Wed May 22, 2013
Second-grade teacher Tammy Glasgow walks around what's left of Briarwood Elementary, struggling to pick out of its wreckage the things that once made a school.
updated 9:19 AM EDT, Wed May 22, 2013
It was the end of the school day. The kids at Plaza Towers Elementary School were stuffing their backpacks, looking forward to going home, playing with friends, eating snacks.
updated 11:31 AM EDT, Sun April 27, 2014
The "Tri-State Tornado" killed 695 people and injured 2,027, traveling more than 300 miles.
See the path of the tornado that ripped through Moore, Oklahoma.