Skip to main content

Cleveland abductions a chilling reminder of 'House of Horrors'

By Ben Brumfield, CNN
updated 11:44 PM EDT, Tue May 7, 2013
The home of convicted serial killer Anthony Sowell in Cleveland has been demolished.
The home of convicted serial killer Anthony Sowell in Cleveland has been demolished.
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • The abductions of women freed Monday have things in common with the "House of Horrors"
  • In October 2009, 11 female bodies were discovered at one man's property
  • The women in both cases had things in common with each other
  • In both cases, the abductions occurred in a neighborhood the women knew

(CNN) -- Like Amanda Berry, who ran to freedom Monday after years in captivity, Tonia Carmichael was abducted and held by a male captor not far from her Cleveland home.

Berry, whom police took to safety along with two other women they rescued from a home at 2207 Seymour Ave., could be seen healthy and beaming in a photo snapped Monday at an area hospital. She endured 10 years of confinement, but her life will go on.

Carmichael was less fortunate.

Her life and those of 10 others ended just over five miles away in the notorious "House of Horrors," at 12205 Imperial Ave., at the hands of convicted sex offender Anthony Sowell, who had moved to the address after serving 15 years in prison for attempted rape.

Eleven bodies were found in and around Anthony Sowell\'s house in Cleveland.
Eleven bodies were found in and around Anthony Sowell's house in Cleveland.

Many of their bodies were exhumed in October 2009 from shallow graves on Sowell's property.

When news of the serial killing broke back then, the investigation revealed that all of the victims had ties to the neighborhood where they died.

Things in common

At that time, the grisly graveyard at Sowell's Cleveland home made Berry's aunt think of her lost niece.

"She's got to be around (her neighborhood) somewhere then," Gale Mitchell told CNN's Anderson Cooper on Monday.

Indeed, Mitchell was onto something.

Berry and one of the other women, whom police say Ariel Castro held captive, disappeared from the same neighborhood, within five blocks of each other, starting in 2003. The third one was last seen about two miles away from the neighborhood, according to the Cleveland Plain Dealer.

Berry was 16 when she vanished on April 21, 2003, after she left her job at a Burger King just a few blocks away from home, the FBI said then.

Mitchell never gave up hope that Berry was still alive. "Me and my daughter -- neither one did," she said.

She was ecstatic when she heard her niece is free and still alive.

"I'm just happy and excited," she said. "It's just so great!"

Unfortunately, Berry's mother, Louwana Miller, died in 2006. She did not live long enough to share in the joy.

"She went with a broken heart," Mitchell lamented.

Berry and the two others had something else in common: They were teenagers at the time of their abductions. Georgina DeJesus was 14, when she went missing. Michele Knight was 19.

House of Horrors

The House of Horror victims also had a common profile: They were all African-American mothers who had hit upon hard times. Almost all of them struggled with drug addiction at some time in their lives, and many turned to prostitution and stealing to support their habits, according to court records.

Carmichael, who was 52 when she vanished, had routinely left home for days or weeks at a time. So, on November 10, 2008, when her children heard she was missing, it seemed, sadly, like nothing new.

She was gone. Four women had fallen victim to Sowell before her. Six more followed her. Most of them were over 40.

They all disappeared in the same neighborhood, and their bodies lay on one man's property. Apparently no one noticed.

Carmichael's body was the first to be identified. Her remains were unearthed from a grave in the backyard, decayed beyond recognition, except for plastic jewelry falling off her skeletal fingers.

Police believe the women were easy prey for Sowell.

Nobody cared?

Criminologists say serial killers often target people whose lives may be messy or off the grid -- prostitutes, runaways and drug users -- because their absences might not raise red flags, even for their families.

After pleading not guilty by reason of insanity, Sowell was convicted in July 2011 of 11 murders, a few rapes and other related charges, according to the Cleveland Plain Dealer. The court sentenced him to death.

After the bodies were discovered, other women came forward, alleging Sowell attacked them.

His home was in a neighborhood that care forgot.

His two-story house sat in a dilapidated neighborhood known as Mount Pleasant, where one in five homes were in foreclosure and at least a third of the residents receive food stamps, according to a study by Case Western Reserve University's Center on Urban Poverty and Community Development.

Neighbors and even a councilman had failed to realize that a stench wafting in the area around Sowell's home was rotting human flesh.

Some in the neighborhood complained then that another factor may have been in play: No one cared when 11 destitute African-American women died.

Trend: escaping alive

More and more people who were abducted escape alive, a spokesman for a nonprofit organization that tracks missing children told Anderson Cooper.

"We are seeing more of them being found as survivors like the three women in Cleveland," said John D. Ryan, CEO of the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children.

But years in captivity can turn into decades of confinement.

"We actually celebrated this past summer the longest recovery of a missing person," Ryan said.

A boy kidnapped at age 2 was found 41 years later and reunited with his mother.

Despite the proximity of the House of Horrors and the similarities between these two grim cases, there is one difference that many were cheering Monday.

The girls who were allegedly abducted and held at 2207 Seymour Ave. made it out alive.

ADVERTISEMENT
Part of complete coverage on
Ohio women found
updated 6:36 PM EDT, Wed September 4, 2013
Ariel Castro who was sentenced to life plus 1,000 years for kidnapping, raping and holding captive three women was found hanging in his prison cell, authorities said told CNN affiliate WOIO.
updated 12:32 PM EDT, Thu August 1, 2013
Amanda Berry and Gina DeJesus weren't in the courtroom. But their diaries gave authorities a window into the horror they suffered for a decade.
updated 1:37 PM EDT, Sun August 4, 2013
They were living in hell, and Ariel Castro did all he could to make sure they'd never escape it.
updated 6:38 AM EDT, Mon August 5, 2013
Michelle Knight, one of three women kidnapped by Ariel Castro, returned Friday to the Cleveland house where she was chained up and tormented for 11 years, a neighbor said.
updated 2:22 PM EDT, Thu August 1, 2013
When her chance came, kidnapping victim Michelle Knight lit into Ariel Castro, the man who held her captive and raped her in his Cleveland home for a decade.
updated 9:54 AM EDT, Fri August 2, 2013
The woman's voice wavered, just for a moment.
updated 9:56 AM EDT, Fri August 2, 2013
From the outside, the home at 2207 Seymour Avenue looked like most any other in Cleveland's Westside neighborhood.
updated 10:06 AM EDT, Tue July 9, 2013
For the first time since their rescue, the world is hearing directly from the three women who were held captive in Cleveland for a decade.
updated 3:57 AM EDT, Fri August 2, 2013
For his victims, Thursday was roughly a decade in coming.
updated 7:51 AM EDT, Tue July 30, 2013
In his first television interview, Ariel Castro's son said that his dad belongs in prison for the rest of his life and he doesn't plan on ever visiting him.
updated 8:25 PM EDT, Thu May 9, 2013
In retrospect, there were plenty of signs that something was wrong.
updated 1:10 PM EDT, Thu August 1, 2013
For the first time, take a look inside the Cleveland house where three women were held captive for a decade.
updated 7:50 AM EDT, Thu August 1, 2013
When an judge denied a request for Castro to visit the 6-year-old girl he fathered with one of the women he kidnapped and raped, the reason seemed pretty clear.
updated 6:55 AM EDT, Mon May 13, 2013
How the macabre enslavement of two girls and a woman began has deeply disturbed a nation, if not the world.
updated 11:37 AM EDT, Sun May 19, 2013
When the police arrived at Castro's house, it was almost peaceful. As if nobody else was there. And then they heard the sound of scurrying feet upstairs.
updated 10:53 AM EDT, Mon May 13, 2013
Ariel Castro's brothers say he's "a monster" who should rot in jail and they "want the world to know" they had no idea their brother was holding women captive.
updated 8:00 AM EDT, Thu August 1, 2013
Two were just teenagers when they were kidnapped, but the three women have finally been found a decade later.
updated 5:33 AM EDT, Wed May 8, 2013
When Amanda Berry screamed for help through a crack in the front door of the house where she was being held, she set in motion an end to roughly a decade of captivity for herself and two other women.
updated 9:19 AM EDT, Fri May 10, 2013
His Cleveland neighbors are trying to come with grips with the two personas -- the first, they thought they knew, the other, the one that authorities describe.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT