Skip to main content

In Swat Valley, U.S. drone strikes radicalizing a new generation

By Nic Robertson, CNN
updated 5:35 AM EDT, Mon April 15, 2013
  • Sabaoon School in Pakistan's Swat Valley works to de-radicalize local youth
  • U.N. Special Rapporteur: U.S. drone strikes here have radicalized a new generation
  • Up to 3,500 people have been killed in Pakistan by U.S. drone strikes since 2004
  • Between 18% and 23% of those killed were not militants, according to one report

Swat Valley, Pakistan (CNN) -- The Sabaoon School for boys in northern Pakistan is anything but average.

Nestled amid the bucolic charm of the Swat Valley's fertile terraced fields and steeply rising crags it looks idyllic. But if you get up close, a harsher reality becomes clear.

Two army check-posts scrutinize visitors entering the sprawling site. Once inside, the high razor wire-topped walls around the classroom compounds create a feeling reminiscent of a prison.

The boys here, aged 8 to 18, were all militants at some point. Some are killers, some helped build and plant improvised explosive devices, and others were destined to be suicide bombers until they were captured or turned over to the Pakistani army. All of them are at the school to be de-radicalized.

Ninety-nine percent of the boys, I am told, have never heard of Osama bin Laden, despite the fact he was killed by U.S. Navy SEALs in the next valley over from here. What has radicalized these boys instead, the school's director says, is what turns teenagers the world over to crime: poverty, poor education, limited prospects and often lack of parental control.

Secret drone deal between Pakistan, U.S.
U.S. drone policy creating terrorists?
CIA no longer in control of drones?
CNN Explains: Drones

It is in this setting that the boys have made ready recruits for Taliban scouts who wean them on tales of the U.S. drone strikes that have killed scores of Pakistani women and children over the past few years.

EXCLUSIVE: Musharraf admits to secret drone deals

The walls of the school, I learn, are not so much to keep the boys in, but to keep the local Taliban out. A few years ago they held sway in the Swat Valley, and while the army has since reclaimed control, the militants remain a threat -- particularly for the teachers.

The boys here are being schooled in basic math and literature. Drama and sports are also encouraged, as is art. Physiologists evaluate the boys and offer council, and a religious scholar is attempting to draw them away from extremist ideology and back towards mainstream Islam.

For Pakistan it is a new approach to radicalism that has been forged out of necessity.

The director tells me the need for more resources in Swat is huge. Just a few days before our visit, a dozen more child militants were arrested by Pakistani officials.

The U.N. Special Rapporteur on drones, British lawyer Ben Emmerson, recently visited Pakistan and told me: "The consequence of drone strikes has been to radicalize an entirely new generation."

READ MORE: U.S. drone program by the numbers

In early March he spent close to a week in Pakistan meeting government officials and tribal leaders, some of who claim to have lost family members in strikes. Since 2003 there have been more than 350 drone strikes in Pakistan, but no one has a reliable figure for precisely how many have been killed.

The New America Foundation estimates that in Pakistan, drones have killed between 1,953 and 3,279 people since 2004 -- and that between 18% and 23% of them were not militants. The nonmilitant casualty rate was down to about 10% in 2012, the group says.

A study by the Bureau of Investigative Journalism estimates that since 2004, Pakistan has had 365 drone strikes that have killed between 2,536 and 3,577 people -- including 411 to 884 civilians.

U.S. President Barack Obama has maintained the strikes are necessary for defeating al Qaeda and the Taliban, but others including Emmerson have their doubts.

READ MORE: U.S. drone kills 4, Pakistani sources say

He said: "Through the use of drones you may win the immediate battle you are waging against this particular faction or that particular faction ... but you are losing the war in the longer term."

Emmerson's legal insights will form the basis of his report to the U.N., expected later this year. For the United States, at least, it could make for a damning read.

Emmerson says the drone strikes are illegal under international law as they violate Pakistan's sovereignty and fly in the face of Pakistani government calls for them to desist -- and that they also legalize al Qaeda's fight against America.

He said: "If it is lawful for the U.S. to drone al Qaeda associates whereever they find them, then it is also lawful for al Qaeda to target U.S. military or infrastructure where ever (militants) find them."

Until now the U.S. has used its own lawyers to give legitimacy to the covert war being waged by drones. Now Emmerson believes it is time to challenge them.

"There is a real risk that by promulgating the analysis that is currently being developed and relied up by the United States they legitimize, in international law, al Qaeda, by turning it in to an armed belligerent involved in a war and that makes the use of force by al Qaeda and its associates lawful," he told me.

The boys of Sabaoon School are at the sharp end of the drone debate and are living with its consequences.

And in the relative safety of these classrooms, there's little doubt change is long overdue.

Drones killing innocent Pakistanis, U.N. official says

Part of complete coverage on
updated 5:59 AM EDT, Wed July 30, 2014
This ocean drone can survive typhoons and collect data from the center of the storm.
updated 12:36 PM EDT, Thu July 3, 2014
Forget selfies. Those are so 2013.
updated 8:09 PM EDT, Tue June 10, 2014
Beyond military surveillance and warfare, drones have proven themselves useful in a number of ways.
updated 5:09 PM EDT, Wed June 4, 2014
It's almost entirely illegal to use drones for money-making purposes in the United States. But a little Hollywood magic could change that.
updated 3:33 PM EDT, Thu May 22, 2014
A bird's eye camera sweeps over the green fields of Ireland, flies over the towering Cliffs of Moher and pans the ocean hundreds of feet below.
updated 11:58 AM EST, Fri January 24, 2014
Marque Cornblatt's interest in drones began with a bit of playful drone-on-drone violence.
updated 5:57 PM EST, Mon December 2, 2013
drones amazon
Imaginations everywhere have been stoked since Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos announced his company plans to start offering 30-minute deliveries via drone-like "octocopters."
updated 10:03 AM EST, Mon February 3, 2014
Ice fishers in Minnesota are reeling from a recent FAA decision prohibiting beer delivery by drone.
updated 8:56 PM EDT, Tue May 13, 2014
Drones are everywhere. They are our present and our future, especially concerning warfare, Peter Bergen writes.
updated 9:25 AM EDT, Fri March 28, 2014
Two thirds of the world population does not have Internet access. Before Facebook can sign up the rest of world it needs to get them online.
updated 5:23 AM EST, Mon November 18, 2013
Apart from what they do for the military; drones have already proven themselves capable sheep herders, delivery boys, tour guides, filmmakers, archaeologists, and -- possibly -- spies.
updated 9:32 AM EST, Fri December 6, 2013
The evolution of drones continues.
updated 8:47 AM EST, Wed November 20, 2013
Flying robot Skycall guides a student around MIT.
It's your first day at university and you've got 15 minutes to get to room 9-209. Easy, right?
updated 3:51 PM EDT, Fri July 19, 2013
Deer Trail, a small Colorado town, is considering a measure that would allow its residents to hunt for federal drones and shoot them down.
updated 3:24 PM EST, Tue November 12, 2013
The Federal Aviation Administration's "Road Map" to integrate drones into civilian airspace by 2015 has provoked strong reactions from privacy advocates.
updated 2:39 PM EST, Wed November 6, 2013
"Live every week like it's Shark Week." Those immortal words come not from the Discovery Channel's marketing department but from Tracy Morgan on "30 Rock."
updated 9:26 AM EDT, Tue August 6, 2013
Click through our gallery to learn more about the varied appearances of drones.
updated 9:16 PM EDT, Wed May 22, 2013
Catch up on everything you need to know about drones.
updated 8:20 AM EDT, Thu July 12, 2012
Drone sixton-a
Drones are currently a growth industry in the aviation sector, with scores of new companies competing for a slice of the market.
updated 3:43 PM EST, Fri February 8, 2013
Here are some key facts about the U.S. drone program, including how and when they are used, and where.
updated 11:12 AM EST, Fri February 15, 2013
The use of drones to carry out military strikes is controversial, to say the least.