Skip to main content

Report: Mali refugees endure 'appalling' conditions at Mauritania camp

By Laura Smith-Spark, CNN
updated 3:50 PM EDT, Sun April 14, 2013
  • Report: Malian refugees are suffering a lack of food, water and shelter in the desert camp
  • Child malnutrition rates are going up, the Doctors Without Borders report says
  • Conditions are so poor that people who arrive at the camp healthy become ill, it says
  • The Mbera camp was set up in early 2012 after violence first broke out in northern Mali

(CNN) -- About 70,000 refugees who fled violence in Mali are living in "appalling" conditions in a camp in the middle of the Mauritanian desert, Doctors Without Borders said Friday.

The situation has only got worse in Mbera camp since French forces entered Mali in January to help local forces take on Islamist militants, the humanitarian group said.

About 15,000 more refugees have flooded into the camp since the fighting, and conditions are so bad there that many who were healthy became ill or malnourished after they arrived.

Mauritania: Slavery's last stronghold

The number of children admitted to clinics in the camp for severe malnutrition more than doubled in that time, climbing from 42 to 106, Doctors Without Borders said.

What led to Mali's disintegration?
Mali's refugee crisis worsening

About 85% of the children under treatment arrived between January and February, despite the nutritional status of the new refugees being generally good when assessed on arrival.

"These statistics show that the refugees have grown weaker whilst in the camp, the very place where they should have been receiving assistance, including correctly formulated food rations from aid organizations," said Henry Gray, emergency coordinator for Doctors Without Borders.

"There has clearly been a lack of preparation for this new influx of refugees."

The camp was set up by the U.N. refugee agency, UNHCR, with the Mauritanian government 60 kilometers (about 37 miles) from the border when refugees started arriving in early 2012.

The report, "Stranded in the Desert," is based on testimonies collected from more than 100 refugees at the Mbera camp between February and mid-March of this year.

The majority of the refugees in Mbera camp are pastoralists who lived nomadic or semi-nomadic lifestyles in northern Mali, according to the report. Some of the families left their young men behind to tend to their herds while they fled over the border into neighboring Mauritania.

"Most of the refugees are from the Tuareg and Arab communities," said Gray.

"They fled preemptively, often for fear of violence due to their presumed links with Islamist or separatist groups. Their home in northern Mali is still in the grip of fear and mistrust."

Limited water, poor hygiene facilities

While some improvements have been made at the camp since the mass influx of new refugees three months ago, Doctors Without Borders said, "the challenge will be to continue to provide assistance that meets humanitarian standards."

Water is still in short supply in the desert camp, a situation made worse by daytime temperatures that reach 50 degrees Celsius (122 degrees Fahrenheit).

Refugees at Mbera receive just 11 liters of water per person per day, instead of the 20 liters recommended by humanitarian standards, the report said.

Some of the families that arrived in January had to wait more than a month for materials to build shelters, the report said. They were forced to do what they could with sticks and scraps of cloth in the meantime.

There is also a serious shortage of toilet facilities.

When the camp was extended in January to accommodate the influx of refugees, there were four latrines for 12,000 people -- far below the recommended minimum of one per 20 people. More are now being built, but the hygiene situation remains difficult.

Another problem is that the rations provided by the U.N. World Food Program, mostly rice and pulses, are very different from the pastoralist refugees' customary diet, which is based on meat and milk. Many new arrivals also suffer from delays in getting food supplies, the report said.

And with the situation in northern Mali still volatile as French and African forces hunt down the remaining Islamist fighters -- and against a backdrop of complex ethnic and political tensions -- it's unclear when the refugees will feel able to return home.

Mali: The long, troubled desert road ahead

'This time, we left early'

A 71-year-old Malian interviewed for the report, Ibrahimou, said three sons had stayed in their village to care for the livestock, but the rest of his family had left.

"With the other village chiefs, we took the decision to leave out of fear of the Malian army," he said.

"I lost brothers and cousins in 1992. I saw a lot of atrocities and I lost a lot of loved ones in the conflict. I almost lost all my animals too. This time, we left early. Nobody knows when we will be back but, at my age, I have no desire to go into exile every 10 years."

About a quarter of those interviewed said they'd fled direct fighting where their lives or family members' lives were in danger.

A small percentage said they had fled because of the seizure of power by Islamist groups in cities such as Timbuktu, Gao and Kidal.

Islamist extremists carved out a large haven in northern Mali last year, taking advantage of a chaotic situation after a military coup by the separatist party MNLA.

Many of the most recent arrivals in the camp told Doctors Without Borders they had left Mali because of food shortages and other problems.

"Life has become very hard. I had nothing to give to my children. There was nothing to eat, shops were closed or empty. There was no market for cattle. I could not stay because I have small children to feed," said Halima, aged 24.

Doctors Without Borders has been working at Mbera camp since February 2012, when the first groups of refugees from Mali began to arrive.

Its teams have treated about 1,000 malnourished children since then and delivered about 200 babies.

Even before the latest influx of refugees, the nutritional situation was critical, with a study by Doctors Without Borders in November revealing mortality rates above the emergency threshold for children under 2 years old.

Since the French-led intervention in January, the number of consultations at its clinics in the camp has gone up from 1,500 to 2,500 per week, Doctors Without Borders said.

UNHCR has said that it and partner agencies "struggle to maintain minimum humanitarian standards in Mbera Camp."

CNN's Laura Perez Maestro contributed to this report.

Part of complete coverage on
Conflict in Mali
updated 1:02 PM EST, Fri February 8, 2013
Restoring territorial integrity of Mali is more than bombing Islamist hideouts.
updated 10:38 AM EST, Wed January 16, 2013
The world is responding to an uprising of Islamist militants, hoping to inject stability in a country once hailed as a model for democracy in Africa.
updated 5:51 PM EST, Thu January 24, 2013
Nima Elbagir talks with victims of war and displaced people from Gao now living in Mali's capital.
updated 6:20 AM EST, Thu January 17, 2013
After intense airstrikes against rebel strongholds, French ground forces are moving north to try to dislodge the fighters.
updated 1:01 PM EDT, Wed March 13, 2013
Residents of Gao, Mali, celebrate their town's liberation from rebel rule.
updated 10:40 AM EST, Mon January 28, 2013
Sankore mosque, built in 15th-16th centuries , Timbuktu city, Timbuktu region, Mali.
The offensive against Islamist militants gained further ground as French and Malian forces reportedly took control of the airport in ancient Timbuktu.
updated 1:27 PM EST, Tue January 15, 2013
France intervenes according to doctrine and the pragmatic parameters of circumstance, says the president of the Institut des Ameriques.
updated 6:07 PM EST, Mon January 14, 2013
CNN's Nima Elbagir reports on the conflict in Mali, how the country got to this point and what the international reaction means.
updated 5:36 AM EDT, Fri July 27, 2012
Islamic radicals linked to al Qaeda have seized northern Mali, and there are widespread concerns that the region could soon become a terrorist haven.
updated 10:25 PM EST, Fri January 25, 2013
Erin Burnett discusses al Qaeda involvement in the Algeria attack and how the U.S. will deal them in northern Africa.
updated 8:10 AM EST, Mon January 28, 2013
The United States is intensifying its involvement in Mali, where local and French forces are battling Islamic militants.
updated 7:33 PM EST, Mon January 14, 2013
CNN's Erin Burnett reports on the situation in northern Mali and its consequences for U.S. homeland security. Watch to find out more.
updated 5:08 PM EST, Sat January 12, 2013
French troops face fierce combat against Islamist militants in Mali and in Somalia during a failed rescue attempt.
updated 10:15 PM EST, Fri February 8, 2013
As Mali military braces against Islamist insurgents and French military strikes targeted Islamist rebels, both sides are determined to win.
updated 6:13 AM EDT, Wed July 4, 2012
Islamist militants destroying an ancient shrine in Timbuktu on July 1, 2012.
The Old Mostar Bridge, the Buddhas of Bamiyan, and now the Timbuktu. Once again, culture is under attack, UNESCO's Irina Bokova writes.
updated 2:03 PM EST, Sun November 11, 2012
African leaders hold an emergency summit to discuss plans to rid Mali of Islamic extremists accused of atrocities.