Skip to main content

Drones killing innocent Pakistanis, U.N. official says

By Ben Brumfield and Mark Morgenstein, CNN
updated 11:09 AM EDT, Fri March 15, 2013
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • The U.N. says the U.S. stands alone in its legal perspective on drone attacks
  • U.N.: Drones kill Pakistani men doing everyday chores
  • U.S. has 8,000 drones and unmanned planes flown by remote control
  • Obama says a target must meet "very tight and very strict standards"

(CNN) -- Farmers are on their way to tend their crops when a missile slams into their midst, thrusting shrapnel in all directions.

A CIA drone, flying so high that the farmers can't see it, has killed most of them. None of them were militants.

Such attacks by U.S. drones are common, the United Nations' special rapporteur on counterterrorism and human rights said Friday in a statement on strikes in Pakistan's tribal region of North Waziristan.

The rapporteur, Ben Emmerson, told CNN the actions are of dubious international legality, despite the United States' assertions.

"I'm not aware of any state in the world that currently shares the United States' expansive legal perspective that it is engaged in a global war -- that is to say a non-international armed conflict with al Qaeda and any group associated with al Qaeda, wherever they are to be found, that would therefore lawfully entitle the United States to take action involving targeted killing wherever an individual is found," Emmerson said.

The American Civil Liberties Union and other U.S. groups are questioning the legitimacy of the President Obama-approved drone program, and they're looking for evidence for a legal battle.

On Friday, a U.S. federal appeals court ruled the CIA must acknowledge the existence of any records related to military unmanned drone strikes targeting individuals, such as overseas terror suspects.

The ACLU and others had filed a Freedom of Information Act request, but the CIA refused to confirm or deny it had any such records, citing national security.

READ: The trouble with U.S. drone policy

Emmerson has just returned from Pakistan, where he listened to residents of North Waziristan talk about terrifying encounters with one of America's weapons in the war on terror.

What in the World? Drones
What's legal in drone warfare?
Al Qaeda's guide to avoiding drones
CNN Explains: Drones

"Adult males carrying out ordinary daily tasks were frequently the victims of such strikes," the statement from the U.N. office for human rights said.

First on CNN: Iran confronts U.S. drone over Persian Gulf

Some Pashtun men dress the same as Taliban members from the same region, hence the drone operators mistake them for terror targets, the statement said. It is also customary for Pashtun men to carry a weapon, making them virtually indistinguishable from militants to an outsider.

A beard and a turban

A Pakistani tribal elder who spoke with CNN noted hasty judgments based on appearances can be wrong.

"Just because I have a beard and wear a turban, does that make me part of the Taliban?" asked Malik Jalaluddin.

READ: What is the drone industry really worth?

The United States has 8,000 drones, unmanned planes and helicopters flown by a remote control. They are outfitted with a video camera to help the operator spot targets and often armed with weapons used to neutralize them.

President Barack Obama has told CNN that a target must meet "very tight and very strict standards."

CIA director John Brennan has said that only in "exceedingly rare" cases have civilians been "accidentally injured, or worse, killed in these strikes."

READ: CNN Explains: U.S. drones

Reports back the U.N. conclusion

Reports by independent groups corroborate Emmerson's account, concluding that drones mistakenly target and kill a significant number of civilians.

The New America Foundation estimates that in Pakistan, drones have killed between 1,953 and 3,279 people since 2004 - and that between 18% and 23% of them were not militants. The nonmilitant casualty rate was down to about 10% in 2012, the group says.

A study by the Bureau of Investigative Journalism estimates that since 2004, Pakistan has had 365 drone strikes that have killed between 2,536 and 3,577 people -- including 411 to 884 civilians.

READ: Hagel to review criteria for drone medal

The study concludes that the strikes have killed far more people than the United States has acknowledged, and traumatized many more innocent people.

That trauma is destroying a way of life, Emmerson said. "The Pashtun tribes of the ... area have suffered enormously under the drone campaign."

And tribal law prescribes revenge for the killing of a tribe member, which serves to radicalize more young men against the United States, he said.

Pakistan considers the strikes counterproductive, illegal and a violation of its sovereignty.

READ: 5 questions about drones

CNN's Saima Mohsin, Salma Abdelaziz and Bill Mears contributed to this report

ADVERTISEMENT
Part of complete coverage on
updated 5:23 AM EST, Mon November 18, 2013
Apart from what they do for the military; drones have already proven themselves capable sheep herders, delivery boys, tour guides, filmmakers, archaeologists, and -- possibly -- spies.
updated 9:32 AM EST, Fri December 6, 2013
The evolution of drones continues.
updated 8:47 AM EST, Wed November 20, 2013
Flying robot Skycall guides a student around MIT.
It's your first day at university and you've got 15 minutes to get to room 9-209. Easy, right?
updated 3:51 PM EDT, Fri July 19, 2013
Deer Trail, a small Colorado town, is considering a measure that would allow its residents to hunt for federal drones and shoot them down.
updated 3:24 PM EST, Tue November 12, 2013
The Federal Aviation Administration's "Road Map" to integrate drones into civilian airspace by 2015 has provoked strong reactions from privacy advocates.
updated 3:19 AM EDT, Fri October 25, 2013
Years of aiming missiles at people on the other side of the world left Brandon Bryant a broken man.
updated 2:39 PM EST, Wed November 6, 2013
"Live every week like it's Shark Week." Those immortal words come not from the Discovery Channel's marketing department but from Tracy Morgan on "30 Rock."
updated 9:26 AM EDT, Tue August 6, 2013
Click through our gallery to learn more about the varied appearances of drones.
updated 9:16 PM EDT, Wed May 22, 2013
Catch up on everything you need to know about drones.
updated 10:51 AM EST, Fri March 8, 2013
Drone warfare has always been a controversial method of war. But it became virtually sensational during the heated discussion over John Brennan's nomination to be CIA chief.
updated 8:20 AM EDT, Thu July 12, 2012
Drone sixton-a
Drones are currently a growth industry in the aviation sector, with scores of new companies competing for a slice of the market.
updated 3:43 PM EST, Fri February 8, 2013
Here are some key facts about the U.S. drone program, including how and when they are used, and where.
updated 11:12 AM EST, Fri February 15, 2013
The use of drones to carry out military strikes is controversial, to say the least.
updated 9:23 AM EST, Sat February 23, 2013
A list of 22 techniques for evading drone strikes shows that militants are trying to share their knowledge and reduce the number of casualties that American attacks are costing them.
ADVERTISEMENT