Skip to main content

Cancer survivors: Mixed feelings on Armstrong

By Elizabeth Landau, CNN
updated 1:06 PM EST, Fri January 18, 2013
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • Lance Armstrong is still an inspiration for some cancer survivors
  • Others are angry at Armstrong but still support his Livestrong foundation
  • Some say Livestrong wristbands are "tainted" by Armstrong

(CNN) -- In an interview with Oprah Winfrey, Lance Armstrong has admitted using performance-enhancing drugs while cycling. He's already been stripped of his seven Tour de France titles and this week had to give back his Olympic bronze medal.

But he still must face judgment from a different group of fans: those who have personal experience with cancer.

Armstrong, founder of the cancer charity Livestrong and a survivor of testicular cancer, is still a hero to some cancer survivors. But others express a mix of emotions and are trying to distance their support of his cancer efforts from their anger about his cheating.

What did you think of the interview?

Bob Denton, 64, of Tucson, Arizona, said he was surprised that the disgraced cyclist appeared, in his view, "honest but insincere" in his apology in the interview, as if "whatever he was admitting was for his own benefit."

But Denton doesn't hold that, or the doping, against Armstrong. In Denton's mind, Armstrong is still a winner.

"Really, compared to the life and death issues of cancer that Lance has embraced, cheating in the Tour is small potatoes," Denton said in an e-mail.

Bob Denton, 64, is a cancer survivor who still finds Lance Armstrong inspirational.
Bob Denton, 64, is a cancer survivor who still finds Lance Armstrong inspirational.

Denton, who cycles as a hobby, has worn a Livestrong wristband every day since 2004, even at business meetings. He sent an iReport to CNN.com about it, too.

He had known Armstrong only in the context of cycling before getting a wristband at a 100-mile bike ride in Florida, which prompted him to research Armstrong's battle with cancer. At that time, he saw the wristband as a symbol of "Lance's total victory over adversity."

"When I would be exhausted trying to keep up with the pace line, I'd look down at that yellow band and get my second wind," Denton said.

The wristband took on a different meaning when Denton developed a cancerous tumor at the base of his tongue in 2009. Then, the wristband became an inspiration for him to overcome the illness.

"Every time the treatments became intolerable, and I felt like my life was over, I'd see that yellow band and it gave me hope that I too would be back on my bike," Denton said.

Denton's last treatment was in September 2009, and he has been in remission ever since. These days, he still cycles about 2,000 miles a year.

Can Armstrong repair his image?
Why we cheat: The ethics of cheating
Lance Armstrong: A champion at cheating?

Armstrong's cheating in cycling also hasn't tarnished his image as a source of inspiration for Amy Wadsworth, who found out she had breast cancer at age 29.

She feels grateful for all that Armstrong has done for the cancer community, and appreciates that Livestrong had offered to help her pay for egg preservation because cancer and treatment for it could have impaired her fertility. (She ended up not doing the preservation, but is glad she had the option.)

"I think we should accept his apology and move (on) because what he has done to help people with cancer definitely out weighs the 'bad.' He didn't give up when he was (stared) in the face with cancer," Wadsworth said of Armstrong. "He kept going and encouraged many other survivors to the same."

Breast cancer awareness: Not so pretty pink

Other cancer survivors, however, aren't so quick to forgive.

Caden Brody, 49, a two-time cancer survivor who also lost his brother to leukemia, said in an e-mail that he does not believe Armstrong is "an evil man," but in a comment on a recent CNN.com story he harshly criticized Armstrong's behavior:

"We cannot deny he raised a lot of awareness and money for cancer. As a survivor I commend that," Brody wrote. "Unfortunately, he undid everything, in many ways, by his sociopathic need to bully, win, play mind games, and he used cancer as a cloak to cover his sins. If he'd confessed ages ago in true remorse? We're a pretty forgiving people. But this is a forced, 'I still want to compete in something so I better apologize' thing."

A CNN commenter threw away all of his or her Livestrong gear because of Armstrong\'s alleged actions.
A CNN commenter threw away all of his or her Livestrong gear because of Armstrong's alleged actions.

CNN.com user "jackiero" had an even more scathing view of Armstrong, posted in the comments on a recent story:

"As an avid cyclist and a cancer survivor who used cycling to aid in my recovery, I am disgusted by this man," jackiero wrote. "I threw away all my (Livestrong) gear not because I don't support the cure -- of course I do -- but because I support the cure without the taint of a cheater like Armstrong. He was an inspiration until I learned that he was just like all the other chemically induced sports stars who rake in millions and millions."

Livestrong likely to survive Armstrong doping admission

Bruce Ross, 64, of Ajijic, Mexico, near Guadalajara, is also dealing with his mixed feelings about Livestrong and Armstrong. Ross has worn his two Livestrong bracelets, one for each time he had cancer, every day since his second surgery in 2006. He gives Livestrong cancer guidebooks to patients he meets who have been newly diagnosed, but has separated his feelings about the foundation from Armstrong.

"When people ask me about Lance, I try to leave him out of the conversation if I can discuss Livestrong in the answer," he said in an e-mail. "For me, the last year has been all about the foundation."

Armstrong's actions have also changed the way some family members of cancer survivors view him. Susan Moberg Hopkins of Seattle, who submitted an iReport about her family, still supports Livestrong, but has a cynical view toward Armstrong.

Hopkins' family contacted Livestrong after her late husband, Marty, found out he had a brain tumor, and she said the staff there was very responsive. Marty was a big fan of Armstrong, and the Hopkins used the cyclist as a way of explaining to her children, who were 12 and 17, that it's possible to recover from cancer and accomplish many things.

"You look for role models, you look for people that help get you through things, and I would say Lance did that," she said Friday.

Armstrong is less of a role model now, she said, because he lied about what he did to get ahead in cycling. The Livestrong bracelets, she believes, are "tainted" by Armstrong.

He affected people "in a way that is far more significant than a bike race," she said. "It's about life and death. I don't know if he will ever be able to say he's really sorry."

CNN's Henry Hanks and Nicole Saidi contributed to this report.

ADVERTISEMENT
Part of complete coverage on
Lance Armstrong
updated 8:19 AM EDT, Wed August 20, 2014
He admits to having a "f**k you" attitude, but Lance Armstrong insists he "never gets crap" following his long-awaited admission of long-term doping.
updated 6:17 AM EDT, Tue August 19, 2014
CNN's Alex Thomas talks to CNN.com writer Matt Majendie about his interview with Lance Armstrong.
updated 10:13 AM EST, Sat January 19, 2013
The fairytale of a cancer survivor who beat the odds to win the Tour de France a record seven times has ended badly. What can we learn?
updated 10:18 AM EST, Sat January 19, 2013
When it comes to seeking public redemption for cheating the sporting public, surely being interviewed by Oprah Winfrey is, well, cheating.
updated 10:25 AM EST, Sat January 19, 2013
After years of tenacious spin that he was innocent, Lance Armstrong has finally confessed to using performance-enhancing drugs.
updated 1:06 PM EST, Fri January 18, 2013
Lance Armstrong still must face judgment from a different group of fans: those who have personal experience with cancer.
updated 11:06 PM EST, Thu January 17, 2013
In a sense, Fred Schuster has a permanent reminder of disgraced cyclist Lance Armstrong etched into his skin.
updated 1:43 PM EST, Fri January 18, 2013
Jan Ullrich of Germany (left/silver), Viacheslav Ekimov of Russia (center/gold) and Lance Armstrong of the United States (right/bronze) celebrate their medals after the final of the Men's Individual Time Trial at the 2000 Olympic Games in Sydney.
Cheating arises from desires, incentives, pressures.
updated 7:56 AM EST, Fri January 18, 2013
Lance Armstrong
Lance Armstrong admitted to using performance-enhancing drugs. Here's a look at what they are, and how they work.
updated 2:39 PM EST, Fri January 18, 2013
CNN asked for views on whether disgraced cyclist Lance Armstrong deserves another chance.
updated 8:46 AM EST, Thu January 17, 2013
As well as denying using banned drugs, Lance Armstrong also viciously attacked those who told what they knew about doping in cycling.
updated 4:27 PM EST, Tue January 15, 2013
The court of public opinion weighed in decidedly against Lance Armstrong, even before the broadcast of his confessional interview.
updated 6:14 PM EST, Fri February 22, 2013
Lance Armstrong's feat of winning seven consecutive Tour de France titles was like the demigod Hercules achieving his "Twelve Labors."
updated 3:40 PM EDT, Mon October 22, 2012
The International Cycling Union announces that Lance Armstrong is being stripped of his seven Tour de France titles.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT