Skip to main content

Should Santa Claus still be fat?

By Jacque Wilson, CNN
updated 8:50 AM EST, Wed January 2, 2013
Roy Pickler, a professional Santa, dropped 88 pounds on
Roy Pickler, a professional Santa, dropped 88 pounds on "The Biggest Loser."
  • CDC: About 12.5 million children age 2 to 19 are obese in the United States
  • Kids learn healthy habits from those they admire most, and Santa is a role model
  • Culture may already be changing with Santa races, healthy gifts

(CNN) -- Roy Pickler lay on the floor, dripping with sweat, as trainer Bob Harper quipped, "You look like you got run over by a reindeer."

Pickler's job as a professional Santa was a constant joke on the latest season of "The Biggest Loser." With his long white beard and protruding stomach, the 63-year-old looked every bit the part he played.

By the time he was voted off the show, Pickler had lost 88 pounds. During his elimination interview, he donned a Santa hat and told viewers his toned physique wouldn't stop him from bringing Christmas joy to children.

"The world is going to have to change their acceptance of what Santa looks like," Pickler said. "Santa is a role model, and kids don't want to have a role model that's fat."

Since 1980, obesity rates among children and adolescents have almost tripled, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Approximately 12.5 million children age 2 to 19 are obese; that extra weight can lead to serious health problems, including type II diabetes, cardiovascular disease and psychosocial issues such as peer discrimination or poor self-esteem.

The epidemic has gotten a lot of attention in the past few years. Everyone from first lady Michelle Obama to Shaquille O'Neal is trying to figure out the best way to inspire kids to get and stay fit.

The world is going to have to change their acceptance of what Santa looks like.
Roy Pickler

Children learn healthy (or unhealthy) habits from those they admire. And Santa is one of the most recognizable figures in America.

For at least a month every year, he appears on billboards, storefronts and TV commercials. Millions of kids stand in line to sit on his comfortably padded lap and whisper secrets in his ear. They write letters to him, sing songs about him and read stories about him.

Photos: Santa over the years

We worry about the effect fast-food advertisements have on students in school. With all his free publicity, should Santa still be fat?

"Let's put it this way," registered dietician Beth Kitchin said with a laugh. "I don't think Santa should be skinny."

There are a lot of other markers to consider in measuring health. Research shows that people can have a higher body mass index and still be healthy, Kitchin said. One can assume Santa is pretty active, wrangling hundreds of elves and nine reindeer every year. And his cheery disposition says a lot about his stress level, which could relate to low blood pressure.

Of course, Santa does have a penchant for sugary treats. One fan estimated the big man eats more than 5,000 tons of cookies on Christmas Eve alone. If Santa isn't diabetic, Christmas magic really does exist.

A 2009 study published in the British Medical Journal determined that Santa could very well be a "public health pariah." The light-hearted research by Nathan Grills of Monash University in Australia found a correlation between countries that recognize Santa and a high rate of childhood obesity.

The cold water of Barcelona's Port Vell doesn't deter this swimmer dressed up as St. Nick from joining in the Copa Nadal swimming race, a traditional holiday event in the Spanish seaport, on Tuesday, December 25. The cold water of Barcelona's Port Vell doesn't deter this swimmer dressed up as St. Nick from joining in the Copa Nadal swimming race, a traditional holiday event in the Spanish seaport, on Tuesday, December 25.
Santa sightings around the world
Photos: Santa sightings around the world Photos: Santa sightings around the world
Track Santa with your smartphone
Signing Santa brings big smile to child

Santa's weight is a longstanding tradition, said Tom Kliner, founder of Santas Across the Globe and the Fraternity of International Real Bearded Santas. The character originated with St. Nicholas, who lived in Turkey during the fourth century. Nicholas was a wealthy young bishop who started giving away all his gold after his parents died.

"Back in those days, extra weight was a sign of wealth and affluence," Kliner said.

Hollywood used to have a set of numbers -- waist circumference, face shape, beard length -- that Santas were supposed to adhere to, Kliner said. But around the world, the legendary giver comes in all shapes and sizes. Coca-Cola's Santa, whom many in America try to emulate, is very round: round face, round nose, round stomach. The Santa imitated in Europe is a thinner man with more squared-off features.

Kliner said he sees Santa as more of a public figure than a role model. "I've never seen anybody aspire to become Santa Claus."

Changing Santa's iconic image would be hard, said Meg Cox, author of "The Book of New Family Traditions." Comfort and security come with seeing the same character year after year.

"We carry these traditions forward from our childhood," she said. "Some of us are pretty emotional about them. And yet I think there's nothing wrong with having a sense of play about it."

If you want Santa to be skinny, Cox said, make it happen: Tell your kids Santa is tired of eating cookies, and leave an apple out instead.

"Having your own take on Santa might be the ultimate personalized Christmas."

It's possible our culture is already changing. Santa races are becoming as much of a tradition as candy canes and Christmas lights. Kids are finding active video games under the tree alongside step counters and organic cookbooks for Mom or Dad.

10 healthy gifts that keep giving

Chris Pickler lost 77 pounds on \
Chris Pickler lost 77 pounds on "The Biggest Loser," dropping to 163 pounds.

Pickler recently called a couple of companies he has contracts with and asked whether they were OK with a trim Santa.

"They both said, 'We want you just the way you are. Your idea of a healthy Santa is the one we want to go with.' "

Since "The Biggest Loser" finale, Pickler and his wife, Chris, have spoken to kids across the Midwest about nutrition and exercise. Pickler often walks in to schools dressed as Santa Claus and then takes off his suit, Superman-style, to reveal his new fit self.

In an upcoming documentary about Santas titled "They Wore a Red Suit," Pickler implores his colleagues around the country to get fit.

"We cannot use (our role) as an excuse, because it influences kids in the wrong direction," he said.

Maybe one day, instead of a belly that shakes like a bowl full of jelly, Santa will have a six-pack. Maybe his cheeks will glow not from the cold but because he's consuming the recommended doses of omega-3 fatty acids. Maybe Mrs. Claus will take up gardening. (Granted, that would be hard to do at the North Pole, but surely the elves can build a greenhouse or two.)

Eventually, in addition to being a role model for the Christmas spirit, our beloved St. Nick could become a healthy role model for kids.

Until then, save some cookies -- Santa Claus is comin' to town.

Lightbulb babies and fairytale castles: Your Christmas traditions

Part of complete coverage on
updated 1:43 AM EST, Thu December 18, 2014
Any old city can string up a few lights downtown and call it a holiday celebration.
updated 7:48 AM EST, Fri December 19, 2014
Christmas in the United States is a combination of traditions from around the world.
updated 10:29 AM EST, Mon December 8, 2014
There, glaring in red and green at the bottom of the holiday party Evite, lurks the season's most vague directive: "Dress festively."
updated 9:56 PM EST, Thu December 18, 2014
Need gift ideas? We're here to help.
updated 5:36 AM EST, Mon December 24, 2012
Jen Best from Liberty, Misouri, snapped this adorable picture of her six month old nephew, Grayson, playing with fairy lights after seeing the idea on Pintrest.
Christmas is synonymous with colorful decorations, festive markets and extravagant quantities of food.
christmas pudding
As winter arrives, British minds turn towards comfort food, and there's nothing more comforting than a traditional suet pudding. Suet, as in, beef fat? In a dessert? Why yes, actually.
updated 8:51 AM EST, Sun December 23, 2012
Santa's reindeer have a story and a history all of their own, one tied to the oldest indigenous culture in Northern Europe and accelerated by an American entrepreneur.
Throughout the years, Magnum's photographers have captured Santa Claus around the globe in humorous circumstances.
Where did the tradition of kissing under the mistletoe come from? And is the plant a tree-killer?
updated 10:45 AM EST, Sat December 22, 2012
Here's a partridge-in-a-pear-tree approach to dealing with anything (and anyone) that the season throws your way.
updated 7:08 AM EST, Thu December 20, 2012
Don't let squabbles over traditions and simple things ruin your holiday this year. Here are tips and tricks on how to avoid family feuds and failed friendships.
updated 6:43 AM EST, Fri December 19, 2014
The holidays are supposed to be the happiest time of the year, yet for many, they trigger deep feelings of sadness and anxiety.
updated 4:33 PM EST, Wed December 19, 2012
I'm not a Grinch or a Scrooge or any of the other soot-stained slurs hurled by people fed up with a loved one's reluctance to join the reindeer games. What I am is depressed.
updated 10:22 AM EST, Sun December 23, 2012
For something intended to bring pleasure to loved ones, Christmas shopping in the Internet age can be a peculiarly joyless and atomized activity. But European Christmas markets are pure magic.
updated 8:00 AM EST, Mon December 10, 2012
Prepare yourself: Some of these are pretty quirky. How much do you know?
updated 4:36 PM EST, Mon December 23, 2013
With Christmas comes Christmas trivia. Here's a look at the holiday by the numbers:
updated 8:50 AM EST, Wed January 2, 2013
Roy Pickler lay on the floor, dripping with sweat, as trainer Bob Harper quipped, "You look like you got run over by a reindeer."