Skip to main content

Niall Ferguson: 'West less good at being West'

From Andrew Stevens, CNN
updated 2:22 AM EST, Mon November 26, 2012
  • Ferguson: 'Things that worked well in the West for over half a millennia don't work so well now"
  • Success of welfare state has lengthened lifespans, but concept of retirement hasn't changed
  • Swelling Western bureaucracies and regulations also hamper growth, Ferguson says
  • Growing Chinese middle class will help demand changes in the rule of law from Beijing

(CNN) -- The speed at which the global economy has pivoted from the West to emerging economies like China is astounding, says author Niall Ferguson.

"If you think back to 1978 when I was a teenager, the average American was 22 times richer than the average Chinese. And today it's less than five times," said Ferguson, a Harvard history professor and a former adviser to 2008 Republican Party presidential candidate John McCain. "That's an amazing reduction in the global imbalance and it's happen in the space really of 30 years."

"The West is at a different phase of development -- economically, demographically -- and it's also at a different place culturally from these countries that are emerging from various forms of economic control -- whether the bureaucratic system of post-Raj India or the communist system that was gradually dismantled economically in China after 1978," he said. This is bringing back one of the most remarkable shifts in the global balance of economic power."

Ferguson sat down last week with CNN's Andrew Stevens in detailed talk on the global economy.

What are the underlying reasons for the decline of the West?

In our lifetime Western ascendancy is coming to an end, after 500 years, when the story was the great divergence -- when the west got much richer than everybody else. And it's extraordinary that really since the 1970s, this historical tide has turned.

New age of U.S. prosperity?
Are central banks doing enough?
Niall Ferguson: The West and the Rest
Sharing the wealth of ideas

I think there are two processes at work here. One is the rest of the world -- led by China -- have been downloading our killer applications. They have been imitating the things that work well in the West, particularly in the realm of business. And this is to be celebrated. It's great to see countries like China and India lifting hundreds of millions of people out of poverty by essentially copying Western ways of doing things.

But I think there is another process at work, which is in some ways independent -- the West is becoming less good at being the West. The things that worked well in the West for over half a millennia don't work so well now. And one way of looking at it is to say: Why is it that the Western economies have malfunctioned? It's not just that there ways a financial crisis and bankers are terrible people. It's much more profound than that.

Why are Western economies performing so badly?

One way of thinking about this is to ask why so many economies, most of them Western -- Japan is the exception -- are currently crushed by debt, which in some cases exceed 100% of GDP? And these debts are forecast to rise even further in the U.S. The simple answer is to say there is a terrible problem of government extravagancy, but I don't think that's the right answer. One way of thinking about this is to say that debt represents a tax on the future. And the big accumulation of debt that we've seen over the last 20 or 30 years in the Western world reflects a breach of contract between the current generation and the next generations. And these debts represent a big burden on the future. And that is one reason I think we've seen a slowdown in the Western world because these burdens of debt act as a major check on economic dynamism.

Why has this generation decided to ignore future generations? Why have we become so selfish?

At some level I think it's a cultural shift. We've moved a long way from our ideals of self-sacrifice for the future that characterized the West during its hay days of industrialization, overseas expansion -- not to mention large-scale warfare. So there's partly been a cultural shift towards the 'me generation' -- consume now, live in the present. But I think it's slightly more than that.

I think what happened after World War II was that it was decided in most Western countries to create pretty generous welfare states that were going to exist to transfer resources from the rich to the poor. And that worked pretty well. It did reduce inequality in those countries when these systems were introduced. But over time the welfare state has become dysfunctional in a surprising way. But in a way it became a victim of its own success: It became so successful at prolonging life, that it becomes financially unsustainable, unless you make major changes to things like retirement ages. And everywhere you see the same basic story, whether you're looking at northern Europe, southern Europe, or north America -- welfare states become harder and harder to finance, and structural budget deficits emerge.

That's to say deficits that are there even when the economy is growing well. And I think these are symptoms of a more profound problem that is causing the Western slowdown. Contrast that with the story in Asia, where welfare states, let's say in China, are much less well developed.

Is it going to take something like a fiscal cliff -- a sovereign debt crisis -- to bring this period to an end?

The European experience suggests nothing gets done until there is a crisis. And this crisis has begun in countries like Spain, Greece, Ireland, and I think soon it will spread to France, as people begin to realize that the French position is actually no better than the other Latin European countries. At some point one can imagine a crisis like that happening in the most developed Asian economy, Japan. And I think sooner or later it may end up happening in the U.S. Although I must say I'm becoming less and less sure that will happen soon. There are things happening in the U.S. that make it quite different, in the sense for example that the demographics are not so bad -- partly because of immigration -- and also interestingly the U.S. is about to have the most amazing free lunch on the back of shale gas and shale oil. The US economy is going to get a really big shot in the arm.

U.S. set for fracking bonanza, says historian Ferguson

What then is the restructuring that needs to happen at an economic level in the West?

Well, I think the most important thing to recognize is that it's not just about taxing and spending. If you define this too narrowly in fiscal terms then you end up in the mess that southern Europe is in -- trying to balance the budget, even as your economy is shrinking. It's better I think to ask questions of a more profound nature about the institutional framework within which society operates. To me one of the most profound contrasts between the West and the rest is that things like the rule of law -- regulation, bureaucracy -- are becoming more burdensome in Western countries, even as they are becoming less burdensome in emerging markets.

You mean they are getting in the way of development?

They really are. I mean one of the main arguments that I make in my new book, "The Great Degeneration," is that the rule of law in the US is becoming the rule of lawyers. The legal profession has become a very major source of cost for business. You have very complex regulation and a very parasitic legal profession, and it battens off the private sector. It's almost impossible for any major organization to function without a huge compliance department and teams of lawyers. And that is all just dead cost. It doesn't really add to the productivity of the economy.

And I think that's one of the things that I am trying to focus on: Why is our regulation so over-complicated? Why does the tax code occupy shelves, rather than just a few pages? And why is it that if you want to regulate the financial sector, you need a bill that is 2000-plus pages long? If we could aspire for greater simplicity and transparency in the tax code and most regulation, I think there would be real benefits.

As China cherry picks the best of the West, do you think they may also fall into Western excesses as well: Is this an evolutionary likelihood?

It's possible. They have some way to go. Short-term, I think the biggest problem facing the Chinese is the rule of law question. It's not the democracy question. It's more -- can China transition to a system in which the rule of law really works? That matters a lot for China's rapidly growing middle class. They want security for their property. They do not want to feel that they could have their property confiscated by an all powerful party at the drop of a hat.

It's not difficult to see what China needs to do, but whether it can do it politically, whether it can override the vested interests, or not, I really don't know.

If you think about it China is acquiring this huge middle class that's one of the direct consequences of rapid growth. And historically if you look at the Western experience it's the middle class that starts to push for rule of law and representative government and freedom of the press -- those are middle class things to want. You really don't worry about those things if you're a peasant or an industrial worker. It's inevitable I think that as this class grows in China, it will start to behave in the ways that middle classes always behave. And the Communist Party is not well set-up to meet those demands.

Interview edited for space and clarity. CNN's Kevin Voigt contributed to this article

Part of complete coverage on
updated 8:47 AM EDT, Fri April 18, 2014
One Square Meter explores how Detroit is building for the future after filing for bankruptcy in 2013.
updated 7:07 AM EDT, Fri April 18, 2014
A British luxury retailer known for high-teas and hamper baskets opens its first ever shop abroad. John Defterios reports.
updated 7:03 AM EDT, Fri April 18, 2014
Already the world's second biggest retail destination, the city is investing in a semi-yearly fashion event for regional talent. Leone Lakhani reports.
updated 11:37 AM EDT, Thu April 10, 2014
Cyprus, the tiny Mediterranean island bailed a year ago, is starting to rebuild itself, the finance minister tells CNN.
updated 7:57 AM EDT, Thu March 13, 2014
Mobile World Congress spans the full spectrum of untethered gadgetry Explore this year's top trends with Stuff Magazine Editor Will Findlater.
updated 8:03 AM EDT, Tue April 8, 2014
CNN's John Defterios says India's election race will likely boil down to three simple numbers: growth, inflation and interest rates.
updated 7:07 AM EDT, Thu April 17, 2014
More than a million Londoners live in flatshares. And while this used to be associated with students, more mature people find themselves sharing.
updated 6:50 AM EDT, Wed April 2, 2014
Nina Dos Santos visits Baselworld the world's most prestigious event for top jewelry and watch brands.
updated 9:24 AM EDT, Wed April 2, 2014
Will Xi Jinping's historic visit to the European Union headquarters help the Chinese leader get what he needs from the EU?
updated 9:28 AM EDT, Fri March 28, 2014
Binnaz Saktanber says many feel trapped between their brains, telling them to leave Turkey, and hearts, which tell them to stay.
updated 6:57 AM EDT, Tue April 1, 2014
"I thought I'd sold it," says Norwegian man who left luxury boat in marina two years -- with keys tied to railings. What happened?
updated 6:27 AM EDT, Wed April 2, 2014
The United Kingdom is champagne's biggest export market. CNN's Isa Soares reports on what's driving sales.
updated 7:51 AM EDT, Wed March 26, 2014
"Sorry, I don't go south of the river," was once a common refrain from London taxi drivers. Not anymore. South London is booming.
updated 2:34 PM EDT, Fri March 21, 2014
The list of Russians targeted by Western sanctions includes people from Vladimir Putin's inner circle -- including his judo sparring partner.
updated 11:58 AM EDT, Tue March 25, 2014
Her passion for public speaking and networking have earned Julia Hobsbawm the moniker "queen of networking." What is her secret?
Google Glass is trying to shed its public relations problem of a nerdy image by teaming up with the company behind Ray-Bans and Oakley sunglasses.
updated 9:37 AM EDT, Mon March 24, 2014
European leaders are meeting in Brussels to discuss further sanctions against Russia. But they are likely to be cautious. Here is why.