Skip to main content

A field guide to 20 great American sandwiches

By Andy Murdock, LonelyPlanet.com
updated 4:58 PM EDT, Fri October 19, 2012
The New Jersey Sloppy Joe served by the Town Hall Deli in South Orange is not the beef concoction served elsewhere.
The New Jersey Sloppy Joe served by the Town Hall Deli in South Orange is not the beef concoction served elsewhere.
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • Many sandwiches around the country can only be found in one area (or restaurant)
  • Every region can lay some culinary claim, from grilled meat to chow mein
  • The Cuban is best enjoyed down South, in Florida, while the lobster roll is great up North

(Lonely Planet) -- Behold the sandwich: a modern culinary wonder of the world. Named for a British Earl, borrowed from the Dutch, invented by some unheralded genius that first stuffed something tasty inside of bread and ate it, and, in modern day, mastered by the Americans.

Take a trip across the United States and look beyond the chain restaurants, and you'll find a whole world of unique regional sandwiches that speak to the history and ingredients of the area.

10 of America's best historic restaurants

Many American sandwiches can only be found in one very specific location or region (or restaurant), but even those that have ventured beyond their birthplaces are generally best enjoyed in their original context. Sandwich history can be layered and complicated, but, like a good sandwich, rarely dry.

American sandwiches are often surrounded by unexpected controversy, and naming the definitive version of any one of these sandwiches will almost certainly spark an argument. Argue if you will, but let's argue it over one of these 20 American regional sandwiches:

1. Beef on Weck

Range: Buffalo and western New York State

The beef is straightforward, but what the heck is weck? It's the shortened local name for a kummelweck roll: a German-style soft roll topped with salt and caraway seeds. To make the sandwich, dip half of the split roll in beef jus, and pile on thinly sliced rare beef and horseradish.

Salty, spicy, messy and designed to be eaten with beer, the beef on weck proves that Buffalo is about more than chicken wings. If you're in the area, give it a taste at Bob & John's.

A second helping of America's best historic restaurants

2. BLTA

Range: Native to California but now commonly found in other parts of the U.S.

California's official motto is 'Eureka!' but you'd be forgiven for thinking that it's 'Eureka! We've discovered the avocado!' In California, you are more likely to get a spin on the classic bacon, lettuce and tomato sandwich, with the addition of the 'A' and served upon toasted sourdough bread, even if you didn't expect it.

There's nothing wrong with a classic BLT, but the avocado does add a welcome dimension (and can almost convince you that it's bordering on healthy). Who makes a great BLTA? Check out the version at the long-lined Bay Area sandwich shop Ike's Place (where they call it a CA-BLT), or the thick-cut bacon version at Rudy's Can't Fail Cafe (where they call it a BLAT).

Lonely Planet: America's best craft breweries

3. Breaded Tenderloin

Range: Restricted to Indiana, occasionally spotted in surrounding states

This breaded tenderloin sandwich should consist of one much-too-large breaded and pounded pork loin on a much-too-small hamburger bun served with fries. Any speck of color on the plate is entirely optional and likely to come from a pickle or a scrap of iceberg lettuce.

A characteristic sandwich of Indiana, the tenderloin has a long list of devotees and is the subject of a great 12-minute documentary that will tell you everything you need to know about this Hoosier classic. Try one around Indianapolis at the Mug-N-Bun or the Tie Dye Grill.

4. Chow Mein

Range: Southeastern Massachusetts and Rhode Island

If you haven't encountered a chow mein sandwich before, it probably sounds a little strange: noodles on bread? Why? More precisely it's fried chow mein noodles in a brown sauce with stir-fried pork or chicken and vegetables placed into a hamburger bun. Strange perhaps, but also strangely delicious.

Originating in Fall River, Massachusetts, the chow mein sandwich hasn't spread far (although it was formerly served at Nathan's at Coney Island and spotted and sampled by this author in this unlikely location).

5. Cuban

Range: Florida, first from Tampa or Key West, but popular in Miami and elsewhere

Any time you mention "Cuba" and "Florida" in the same breath, don't be surprised if an argument erupts nearby. This holds true even for the state's native (some argue adopted) sandwich. Invented in Cuba or invented in Florida; first from Tampa where salami makes an appearance in the sandwich, or first from Key West sans salami.

The debate goes on. What the sides will agree on is that the sandwich must be served on Cuban-style bread, with mustard, roast pork, ham, Swiss cheese and thinly sliced pickles -- we'll let the purists argue the rest. Try La Segunda Bakery in Tampa, El Cristo in Miami, or El Siboney in Key West for a range of experiences.

6. Denver (aka Western)

Range: Highly endangered. Native to Denver but has not been seen in the wild for some time

Which came first: the Denver sandwich or the omelet? Given that the Denver sandwich is a Denver omelet in a roll, you would assume that the omelet predates the sandwich. Oddly, this doesn't appear to be the case, with published references to Denver sandwiches predating the standalone omelet by several years.

The Denver omelet -- the classic blend of ham, bell pepper, onions and egg -- in evolutionary terms is a sandwich that lost its shell. The Denver sandwich is currently the ivory-billed woodpecker of the sandwich kingdom (if found once again in its home range, it will be the best modern example of a Lazarus sandwich). Avid sandwich spotters will undoubtedly be on the watch for this one.

7. French Dip

Range: Los Angeles and springing up in numerous other locations around the U.S.

Another sandwich of hotly debated origin, two Los Angeles restaurants -- Cole's Pacific Electric Cafe and Philippe the Original -- claim to have invented the French dip. Similar to the beef on weck and the Italian beef, a French dip consists of thinly-sliced rare beef on a French roll served au jus, typically with a bowl for extra dipping.

As with its drippy cousins, prepare to use many napkins in the course of a sandwich.

8. Gerber

Range: St Louis

The sandwich cousin of St Louis pizza, the Gerber sandwich is an open-faced toasted sandwich made with crispy Italian bread, garlic butter, ham and processed Provel cheese -- a cheese only a local could love.

A grilled ham and cheese meets garlic bread: what could be wrong with that? Nothing, unless you actually call it a "Gerber" and you aren't Ruma's Deli, where it was invented in the early 1970s. The Gerber has spread around the area and become a local standby, but don't call it a Gerber unless you're at Ruma's.

9. Horseshoe

Range: Restricted to Springfield, Illinois and the surrounding area

An open-faced sandwich composed of two slices of toasted bread topped with two hamburger patties and a whopping pile of french fries all smothered in a cheese sauce, obviously, the horseshoe isn't the prettiest or the healthiest sandwich in America. For the health conscious sandwich lover, there's the pony shoe, with just one slice of bread and one hamburger patty.

(The meat can vary, so keep an eye out for the heart healthy chicken breast version. It will be hiding somewhere beneath the hillock of fries and cheese.)

Lonely Planet: Chicago: a starter guide to the Windy City

10. Hot Brown

Range: Louisville, Kentucky

Louisville's Brown Hotel created this local variation on Welsh rarebit in 1926. A proud member of the open-faced sandwich family, the original Hot Brown recipe used white bread, turkey and bacon, all covered in Mornay sauce and broiled until brown and toasty. J. Graham's Cafe in the Brown Hotel still serves the Hot Brown, and variations are found at other cafes in the Louisville and Lexington area (some heathens replacing the Mornay sauce with American cheese).

11. Italian Beef

Range: Chicago

A wet beef sandwich, along the lines of a beef on weck or a French dip; the Chicago Italian beef comes topped with a spicy giardiniera (sautéed peppers and onions) or sweet peppers, with the entire sandwich dipped in juices. Find classic examples at places like Al's #1 Italian Beef (a favorite of Hilary Clinton) or Mr. Beef (a favorite of Christopher Walken) -- and don't wear your Sunday finest unless you don't mind wearing it au jus.

12. Jersey Breakfast

Range: New Jersey

Pork roll (sometimes called by the trade name Taylor Ham), egg and cheese on a hard roll. Sounds simple, but just mentioning this sandwich caused a small argument among the Jersey contingent of the Lonely Planet office. "Don't call it Taylor Ham, call it pork roll," said one. "No one I know would eat it with pork roll, maybe ham or bacon and it would be on a bagel. And I might even call it a New York breakfast because it's commuter food," said another.

And then it got ugly. Apparently it all depends on where you're from.

13. Lobster Roll

Range: Maine and nearby states

Maine's signature sandwich, the lobster roll is a beautiful marriage of the high- and the low-brow: the king of seafood (the Maine lobster) with the peasant of breads (the hotdog bun). But there's no need to get highfalutin with the bread, it's just a vehicle for piles of fresh lobster tossed with mayonnaise (or drawn butter in some versions).

Crab and clam and other rolls are out there for the tasting -- lobster tends to get the most accolades, but decide for yourself.

14. Mother-in-Law

Range: Chicago

Another addition to the sandwich family from Chicago, the mysteriously but presumably unflatteringly named mother-in-law sandwich consists of a Chicago-style corn tamale in a hot dog bun covered in chili. This is no gourmet affair, rather a treasured local junk food that Anthony Bourdain once called "a truly magnificent mutation."

The tamale isn't a lovingly handcrafted steamed masa dough pocket like you'll find in the Southwest, it's a mass-produced extruded hotdog-shaped meat-filled cornmeal log. If this sounds like your type of sandwich, give it a taste at Fat Johnnie's Famous Red Hots in Marquette Park.

15. Muffuletta

Range: New Orleans

One of New Orleans' signature sandwiches (the other of note being the Po' Boy), the Muffuletta starts with Muffuletta bread, essentially a round focaccia layered with a mixture of Italian meats (typically capicola, salami and ham) topped with cheese and a marinated olive and chopped vegetable salad.

Muffulettas can be found throughout the city, but it's worth trying one at its 1906 birthplace, the Central Grocery in the French Quarter, one of the last remnants of New Orleans' Sicilian history.

16. New Jersey Sloppy Joe

Range: South Orange New Jersey

Forget the minced beef Sloppy Joe found in greasy-spoons across the U.S., the New Jersey Sloppy Joe more closely resembles the love child of a Cuban sandwich and a club sandwich. Three layers of rye bread, two meats and a cheese (traditionally ham, tongue and Swiss), coleslaw and Russian dressing, the original sloppy Joe was patterned after a memorable sandwich eaten at Sloppy Joe's Bar in Havana by a former Maplewood mayor who wanted to recreate the sandwich on his return home.

The Town Hall Deli is the original and still favorite purveyor of the New Jersey Sloppy Joe -- it ain't cheap, but it's huge and designed to be split among several people so don't feel the need to tackle this one alone.

17. Pit beef

Range: Baltimore

Baltimore's answer to the barbecue brisket sandwich, the pit beef sandwich is a working-class staple of the region. Despite the name, there is no pit in the strict sense (sorry to disappoint if you were expecting a hole in the ground) -- pit beef is a char-grilled top round of beef, sliced very thin, and served with horseradish on a kaiser roll (or rye at some restaurants).

If you're in the area, Chaps Charcoal Restaurant and Pioneer Pit Beef are two local faves.

Lonely Planet: Classic New York food

18. Po'boy

Range: New Orleans

The classic New Orleans submarine sandwich, the beloved Po'boy comes in a variety of forms (mostly fried seafood or roast beef) served on a distinctive French-style baguette with a crusty outside and light inside. Who makes the best? Check out our New Orleans author's top 5 po' boy picks for the best in and around town.

19. Spiedie

Range: Found only in the greater Binghamton, New York region

The name spiedie is derived from the Italian word for spit-grilled meat, spiedini. Cubes of marinated meat, ranging from chicken to lamb, are spit grilled over charcoal much like souvlaki, and then tucked into a soft roll or sliced bread with little more than the meat drippings to keep the cubes company.

If you're a fan of the spiedie, mark your calendars for the annual Spiedie Fest and Balloon Rally in early August.

20. St. Paul

Range: St Louis

St. Louis is home to several regional American sandwiches -- it's one of the last bastions of the once popular fried-brain sandwich, and it's home to the St. Paul: an unusual Chinese-American sandwich composed of an egg foo young patty (egg, onion and bean sprouts) with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles and mayonnaise between two slices of white sandwich bread.

Reportedly invented by a chef hailing from Minnesota -- hence the other saint in the name -- the St. Paul was an attempt by Chinese restaurants in the 1940s to attract local customers unaccustomed to Chinese cuisine.

What's your favorite regional sandwich? What's it made with and where is it found?

Originally published as "A field guide to 20 great regional sandwiches of the USA" © 2012 Lonely Planet. All rights reserved.

© 2011 Lonely Planet. All rights reserved.

ADVERTISEMENT
Part of complete coverage on
CNN recommends
You don't have to be an adrenaline junkie to take a dare.
updated 1:23 PM EDT, Wed April 23, 2014
Fireworks are fantastic and human endeavor has its place, but sometimes Mother Nature outshines any performance we can produce.
updated 2:09 PM EST, Sat February 22, 2014
They're almost unbelievable. Impossible blues, electric greens, depths as clear as glass -- all bathed in blinding sunshine.
updated 10:53 AM EDT, Thu July 31, 2014
Check out the photos CNN.com readers have shared and submit your own.
updated 5:25 PM EST, Fri January 17, 2014
Earth never stops surprising us. Every corner of the planet offers some sort of natural peculiarity.
updated 10:58 AM EDT, Wed July 23, 2014
Not many cities evoke as many instant associations as Las Vegas.
For 24 hours, we made the world's busiest airport our destination and found a world unto its own. Join us on our journey. What you see will surprise you.
updated 3:34 PM EDT, Tue August 13, 2013
Beaches along the coasts of the United States call to shoreline explorers year-round.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT