Skip to main content
Part of complete coverage on

Video of autistic child being beaten provokes Internet outrage

By Jaime A. FlorCruz, CNN
updated 3:46 AM EDT, Fri October 5, 2012
Video grab taken from Chinese news report posted on YouTube purportedly shows girl being manhandled.
Video grab taken from Chinese news report posted on YouTube purportedly shows girl being manhandled.
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • Footage purportedly shows four-year-old girl with autism being manhandled and beaten
  • The girl apparently collapsed and lost consciousness as other adults looked on
  • Caused outrage among Chinese netizens after video has been posted on the Internet
  • Much concern about the treatment of children, especially those with mental disabilities

Editor's note: "Jaime's China" is a weekly column about Chinese society and politics. Jaime FlorCruz has lived and worked in China since 1971. He studied Chinese history at Peking University (1977-81) and was TIME Magazine's Beijing correspondent and bureau chief (1982-2000).

Beijing (CNN) -- Even a grainy three-month-old video clip can stir up a controversy.

A closed-circuit television clip, posted and shared on Chinese social media and reported by the local press this week, has triggered sympathy and outrage here in China.

The footage purportedly shows a four-year-old girl with autism being manhandled and beaten by a female assistant at a children's rehabilitation center in the southern city of Guangzhou.

The girl apparently collapsed and lost consciousness as other adults looked on passively. She was rushed to the hospital for emergency treatment, Chinese media reports said.

Watch: Footage of disturbing incident

Qiu Yaoyao (not her real name), an only child, has since undergone neurosurgery and is slowly recovering, a local Guangzhou newspaper reported last week.

She can sit but she can't stand yet, the newspaper said, and her speaking ability is still impaired.

Autistic kids are extra vulnerable because they are unable to independently control their behavior.
Actress Ma Yili

The assistant in the video has been charged with assault and battery, media reports said, though CNN has not yet been able to verify this.

Even though the incident happened three months ago, the newly uploaded video has sparked heated debate about the treatment of children -- particularly those with disabilities -- generating over 180,000 re-posts and 28,000 comments on one social media website alone.

There is massive public outrage.

Critics condemned the teacher's behavior, one calling it a "bestial act."

Film actress Ma Yili took to Weibo, China's Twitter-like service, to say, "This kind of behavior should be charged with intentional homicide. Autistic kids are extra vulnerable because they are unable to independently control their behavior. We as parents will be closely watching how (the teacher) will be punished in court."

Another Weibo user, named @Yaliju, asked, "Doesn't she have a child herself? How on earth could kindergarten teachers be so cold-blooded? Who would dare entrust their kids to these peoples' hands?"

Other netizens blame the lack of trained teachers, especially for children with autism and other disabilities.

"This is heart-wrenching," posted @alwaysyouyou. "And why were all the other teachers just standing there watching? I'm deeply worried about how teachers get their qualifications nowadays."

Still others question how Chinese children are reared and educated.

Educators should be more thoughtful in the way they discipline students.
Yang Jiangding, Shanghai Children's Research Center

Zheng Yuanjie, a writer of children's books, wrote on his microblog: "Parents make so much effort to secure a slot for their kids in the kindergarten, but do they know what's happening behind closed doors once they get in?

"When I was in kindergarten, a kid accidentally dropped his bowl while eating. The teacher asked all other kids to take turns to slap him."

Like many places around the world, Chinese teachers and parents do resort to corporal punishment at times to discipline misbehaving children.

But no one is defending the brutal treatment of Qiu Yaoyao.

"Surely it must be severely punished," wrote Zhang Jie, a commentator at China Central Television (CCTV) in a microblog post. "The kindergarten and its supervisors must be held responsible too."

"Educators should be more thoughtful in the way they discipline students. No matter what, corporal punishment in public will harm the students' self-esteem for sure," said Yang Jiangding, Director of the Shanghai Children's Research Center.

Qiu Yaoyao's maltreatment has also put the spotlight on the plight of autistic children in China.

Prevalence of autism in the world's most populous country, experts say, is largely underestimated because many Chinese doctors, parents and teachers typically do not know enough about the condition to be able to identify and diagnose it. Though awareness is growing and early intervention is improving, the social stigma remains strong.

Read: What is autism?

Autism in Chinese is known as "zibizheng," literally "self-isolation syndrome," or loneliness disease.

It's a feeling shared by the parents of autistic children.

"I feel depressed and helpless I don't know how to deal with this," said Meng Xi in an interview with CNN.

He said sometimes it seems his daughter barely knows he's there but the loving father said he is always there. He does not dare leave her side.

Meng Xi brought his daughter to a special center for autistic children on the outskirts of Beijing. There, some 30 children, from toddlers to five and six years old, get specialized one-on-one care. Teachers use music and animal therapy to help unlock what could be inside the children's world.

But these facilities are rare in China and parents and teachers complain of a lack of such facilities.

The government helps subsidize the center, but parents still need to pay a lot of money for their children's special education. Meng Xi pays the equivalent of $500 a month -- almost his entire monthly salary.

Autism is China's number one mental disorder, according to a research paper presented at the International Autism Research Conference in Shanghai last year.

Yet a recent survey by the Shenzhen Autism Society in southern China reveals an alarming lack of professional or government support.

The brutal treatment of four-year-old Qiu Yaoyao, shockingly captured in that grainy closed-circuit television clip, is a grim reminder of that.

ADVERTISEMENT
Part of complete coverage on
updated 4:44 AM EST, Thu December 26, 2013
The mood at the 120th anniversary of Chairman Mao Zedong's birthday is relatively muted, by Chinese standards.
updated 8:15 PM EST, Sun December 22, 2013
Every December, foreign correspondents in China go through the rigmarole of renewing press cards and visas.
updated 11:35 PM EST, Mon December 9, 2013
"Stand to attention," barked the class monitor as we walked into the classroom at the Shahe Primary School in a remote region in Yunnan Province.
updated 10:53 PM EST, Wed November 20, 2013
After presiding over a smooth leadership transition in his first year, what will Xi Jinping's next move be?
updated 12:28 AM EST, Sat November 9, 2013
China's elite gather for what could be the most significant Communist Party meeting in decades.
updated 1:58 AM EDT, Mon October 7, 2013
China's Class of '77: The very different paths taken by three classmates show how China has changed over the past 25 years.
updated 12:52 AM EST, Mon February 11, 2013
Hold the shark's fin soup. Cancel the elaborate pre-Chinese New Year parties.
updated 7:34 PM EST, Sun March 3, 2013
Many of China's Catholics are awaiting the election of Pope Benedict XVI's successor with high expectations.
updated 1:29 PM EST, Sat January 19, 2013
CNN's Jaime FlorCruz describes bad-air days in Beijing, when "you can barely see, you can barely breathe."
updated 9:40 PM EST, Tue January 8, 2013
A rare protest by Chinese journalists at the Southern Weekly poses a test for Xi Jinping and his Communist Party.
updated 4:01 AM EDT, Fri September 7, 2012
Divining what is going in China's opaque political world is like reading tea leaves: it may be interesting but it's ultimately a futile exercise.
updated 12:12 AM EDT, Fri August 31, 2012
As China looks to usher in its new leaders, one of the messiest political scandals to hit the Communist Party in years continues to fester.
ADVERTISEMENT