Skip to main content
Part of complete coverage on

Opinion: Why file-sharing cannot and should not be stopped

The development of technology means that
The development of technology means that "anybody can sit in a café and copy the entire collection of human music to anybody else in the café, completely without traceability," Falkvinge says.
  • Rick Falkvinge is the founder of the Swedish Piratpartiet, the first Pirate Party worldwide
  • He argues that the development of mobile devices makes it impossible to stop file-sharing
  • He argues this means almost everybody can access all of humanity's collective knowledge and culture

Editor's note: Rick Falkvinge is the founder of the Swedish Piratpartiet, the first Pirate Party worldwide, and a campaigner for "next-generation civil liberties and sensible information policy to safeguard the parts of Internet that guarantee civil liberties."

(CNN) -- For the past 20 years, the copyright industry has waged a war against teenagers sharing culture and knowledge with each other. First, it was music ("home taping will kill music"), then games, then movies, then books.

The copyright industry has tried to portray the teenagers and others who are thus sharing as if they were somehow being immoral.

Rick Falkvinge
Rick Falkvinge

The problem with this depiction is that it resonates very poorly with the people doing the actual sharing -- to them, sharing a record or a game with a friend or a stranger is a good social act.

Read related: How mobile tech affects the family

Thus, we have a severe disconnect in how different parts of society regard the activity of sharing culture and knowledge on the sidelines of the established distribution chains -- or in violation of copyright, if you like.

As mobile devices develop, it becomes increasingly clear that this is a war that cannot be won. Today, our mobile devices can typically house some 16 to 64 gigs of data.

Guarding against smart phone hackers
Fun on the road

Hard drives that can hold 60 terabytes have been announced and are just around the corner. As this storage capacity becomes affordable and even expected for one person to carry around, each and every person can hold a complete copy of all music ever produced.

Read related: We never talk any more: The problem with text messaging

When connecting this phenomenon to mobile devices that can broadcast information anonymously, over technologies like Bluetooth and ad-hoc wi fi, it means that anybody can sit in a café and copy the entire collection of human music to anybody else in the café, completely without traceability: they wouldn't even know themselves whom they were copying to and from.

Train and subway cars will form spontaneous clouds of connections that keep owners of mobile devices up-to-date with all music ever produced.

Shortly thereafter, personal storage capacities will also be enough to house all movies ever produced. Regrettably, cellphones are a centralized, trackable technology -- they have been called "governmental tracking devices that you can also use to make phone calls", and rightly so -- the built-in trackability possibilities are something that goes far beyond what existed east of the former Iron Curtain.

Read related: On second thought: Maybe smartphones make us 'SuperStupid'?

But mobile phones can also connect directly to each other, without central trackability, logs or traces -- as long as they are within short range of one another. "Short range" usually means about 10 to 25 meters in practice.

Paying with your phone.. and your face
Open Mic: Mobile devices in Kenya

This kind of person-to-person distribution of digitizable material -- sometimes called a "sneakernet", as people use their feet to move data -- is not as effective in distributing information as the internet, but effective enough.

It's how we shared primitive games on the early computers, before we had BBSes, and before we had the internet. It took about three days for a new game from its release somewhere in the world to reach everybody who wanted it. That's fast enough.

So realizing that people cannot be stopped from sharing knowledge and culture, in violation of the distribution monopoly we know as copyright, because of the rapid development of mobile devices -- seeing that it cannot be stopped with any amount of applied violence, is there a flip side to this?

It turns out that there is a rather strong flip side.

For the first time in history, all of humanity -- at least everybody with an internet connection, which is increasingly fast becoming "everybody" -- can access all of humanity's collective knowledge and culture, as well as contribute freely to it.

That is a huge leap ahead for us as a civilization.

Read related: Handheld device that saves lives

It's not even a fantasy project with a ridiculous price tag to it, like the space elevator, vacuum-tube satellite launcher, or moon base. All the technology has already been developed, all the infrastructure has already been built, all the tools have already been rolled out.

All that we have to do to achieve this leap of civilization is just to remove the ban on using the greatest library mankind has ever built.

(Ironically, the exact same discussion about sharing knowledge and culture was held when public libraries were introduced into law in the 1850s, when publishers had argued that people should be banned from lending books from one another. The more things change, the more they stay the same.)

So not only can sharing not be stopped -- I argue that it shouldn't be stopped, either, once you see the flip side.

The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of Rick Falkvinge.

Part of complete coverage on
updated 9:47 AM EDT, Mon October 8, 2012
In the past 10 years we've seen cell phones transform into electronic Swiss army knives with a wild variety of functions and features.
updated 8:03 AM EDT, Tue October 9, 2012
If you're like Derek Smith, you spend a lot of time on your smartphone. Then again, maybe nobody is quite like Derek Smith.
updated 10:03 AM EDT, Sat October 6, 2012
I am part of a dying breed. I am among a quickly shrinking slice of Americans who have yet to step foot in smartphone land.
updated 6:24 PM EDT, Wed October 3, 2012
If you're looking for a harbinger of the zombie apocalypse, look no further than all those people on the street pecking at their tiny, handheld windows into a private world.
updated 3:15 PM EDT, Tue October 2, 2012
There are many ways to lose or ruin your smartphone. Forgetfulness, crime, gravity, anger, intoxication, acts of God.
updated 5:55 AM EDT, Fri September 28, 2012
A Sumo wrestler talks on a mobile phone
It is a device that three quarters of the world's inhabitants have access to, but the words to describe it and etiquette of how to use it differ starkly across cultures.
updated 12:21 PM EDT, Thu September 27, 2012
While about a quarter of adults in the United States suffer from some form of mental illness, most of them are not getting adequate treatment, if any.
updated 4:24 PM EDT, Wed September 26, 2012
There are millions of cell phone users in the United States. But one day last week, there was one less. Here's how comedian Dean Obeidallah survived it.
updated 4:20 PM EDT, Wed September 26, 2012
In a world where people are glued to their smartphones every minute of the day, what happened to observing the people and places around us? And what is it doing to our brains?
updated 9:09 AM EDT, Thu September 20, 2012
Physical therapists have a diagnosis for the headaches, neck cricks and achy shoulders affecting smartphone users, gamers and e-mailers. They call it "Text Neck."
updated 11:49 AM EDT, Wed September 19, 2012
Works of art photography aren't just for people with DSLR or film cameras anymore. Smartphones are helping create incredible art.
updated 11:39 AM EDT, Wed September 19, 2012
What if you found yourself stuck alone at a faraway airport -- with no money, credit cards or ID? Never fear, all you need is your phone.
updated 11:37 AM EDT, Tue September 18, 2012
China is on the verge of a smartphone revolution. For migrant populations, such technology has served to liberate workers, restructuring their social identity.
updated 2:02 PM EDT, Fri September 14, 2012
africa mobile phone boys
A little over a decade ago there were about 100,000 phone lines in Nigeria, mostly landlines run by the state-owned telecoms behemoth, NITEL. Today NITEL is dead, and Nigeria has close to 100 million mobile phone lines.
updated 10:39 AM EDT, Fri September 14, 2012
How does sleeping with your smartphone inches from reach affect your life? You might be surprised.
updated 12:17 PM EDT, Mon September 10, 2012
They've helped ignite the Arab Spring and given people better access to education and health care. How smartphones are changing the world.
updated 4:21 PM EDT, Thu September 20, 2012
From the Samsung Galaxy S III to the next iPhone, here's a look at some of the most popular new handsets.
Many parents complain that cellphones, computers and tablets are dividing families. But some experts disagree.
updated 10:26 AM EDT, Mon September 10, 2012
Ten years ago, I helped work on the next great revolution in digital media. It was going to be wireless. Only most people didn't know it then.