Total warns against oil drilling in Arctic

Greenpeace activists demonstrate on March 16 in the port of Helsinki Shell plans for Arctic gas exploration.

Story highlights

  • Total SA says energy companies should not drill for crude in Arctic waters
  • First time an oil major has spoken out against offshore Arctic oil exploration

Total SA says energy companies should not drill for crude in Arctic waters, marking the first time an oil major has publicly spoken out against offshore oil exploration in the region.

Christophe de Margerie, Total's chief executive, told the Financial Times the risk of an oil spill in such an environmentally sensitive area was simply too high. "Oil on Greenland would be a disaster," he said in an interview. "A leak would do too much damage to the image of the company".

Last week, Royal Dutch Shell had to postpone until next year an attempt to drill into oil-bearing rock off the Alaskan coast after a piece of safety equipment was damaged during testing. It has spent $4.5bn and seven years preparing to drill.

ExxonMobil, ENI of Italy and Norway's Statoil have also signed deals to explore for oil in Russia's Arctic waters, while others have secured licences to drill off Greenland.

Mr de Margerie emphasised that he was not opposed to Arctic exploration in principle. Total has a number of natural gas ventures in the region, including a stake in the vast Shtokman field in Russia's Barents Sea. The Total chief executive said gas leaks were easier to deal with than oil spills.

Shell weighs risks in Arctic drilling
Shell weighs risks in Arctic drilling

    JUST WATCHED

    Shell weighs risks in Arctic drilling

MUST WATCH

Shell weighs risks in Arctic drilling 02:04
PLAY VIDEO
Arctic oil vs. Alaska's natives
Arctic oil vs. Alaska's natives

    JUST WATCHED

    Arctic oil vs. Alaska's natives

MUST WATCH

Arctic oil vs. Alaska's natives 03:45
PLAY VIDEO
Is Shell ready for an Arctic oil spill?
Is Shell ready for an Arctic oil spill?

    JUST WATCHED

    Is Shell ready for an Arctic oil spill?

MUST WATCH

Is Shell ready for an Arctic oil spill? 04:14
PLAY VIDEO

His comments were welcomed by environmental groups that are opposed to Big Oil's presence in what they see as a near-pristine wilderness.

"The rest of the oil industry should heed his warning," said Ben Ayliffe, head of Greenpeace's Arctic campaign. "Given the risks, companies shouldn't be touching the Arctic with a barge pole."

Shell declined to comment. It has said in the past that it is well prepared for spills, with round-the-clock response teams on Alaska's North Slope and a fleet of specialised vessels that will be in place before drilling starts.

According to a 2008 study by the US Geological Survey, the Arctic contains just over a fifth of the world's undiscovered, recoverable oil and gas resources. The melting of the polar ice cap has made the area more accessible to the majors than ever before.

The region's challenges are formidable, however, ranging from icebergs the size of cities to storms, darkness and fierce cold. There is also no certainty of success: UK-listed explorer Cairn Energy spent $1bn exploring off Greenland and failed to find commercial volumes of oil.

Total's Arctic projects are concentrated in Russia. As well as its stake in Shtokman, it has interests in a number of onshore developments, such as a big liquefied natural gas venture in Russia's far north known as Yamal LNG. It also operates a Siberian oilfield called Kharyaga.

Gazprom announced in August that it was shelving Shtokman due to excessive costs. But Mr de Margerie said as far as he was concerned, it was still on. "Gazprom never told me in writing that the project is over," he said. "Discussions are not ... as active as I would like. [But] the reserves are still there."