Skip to main content
Part of complete coverage on

Fears for bubble burst after Ramallah boom

From Leone Lakhani, CNN
updated 8:35 AM EDT, Mon September 10, 2012
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • Palestinian economy grew at an average of 7.7% a year between 2007-2011
  • Ramallah is experiencing booming consumer economy as result
  • World Bank report: Economy too heavily based on foreign aid, not sustainable
  • If government money goes, no one will have money to spend in my bar, says owner

Ramallah, West Bank (CNN) -- Mingling with customers in the bar he opened two years ago, Yazan Khalili is enjoying the booming consumer economy in his home city of Ramallah, in the West Bank.

But despite the success of his bar, Beit Aneesah, Khalili worries that the boom is unsustainable and his customers could soon have no money to spend.

"The economy itself is based on a bubble and you never know when this bubble will burst," said Khalili. "It's like living on the hand of a genie. Things might just disappear."

The city has boomed over the past five years, with new restaurants, cafes and even luxury hotels. The West Bank's first five-star hotel, Movenpick Ramallah, a locally owned franchise of the Swiss chain, opened in 2010, aimed primarily at corporate clients.

Does Ramallah need a 'real economy'?

Like many, Khalili worries that the new age of consumerism is just too good to be true.

"Since banks give loans, anyone who wants to open a business becomes a possibility. In that sense, it's not hard to open it," he said.

"It's not hard to get permission to open a bar from the municipality. From the ministry of economy, from the bank to get a loan, it's not hard to do it, it was possible."

In this new economic world, Khalili sometimes longs for the old days.

It's like living on the hand of a genie. Things might just disappear
Yazan Khalili, bar owner

"There were businesses, but they were more organic businesses that understood the conflict, that were able to survive the hardship of the occupation.

"That's based on more local products, consumption. Enough, depending on what you have," he added.

The United Nations describes the Palestinian Territories as Occupied, but Israel disputes the use of the term. Israel controls the flow of goods into and out of the West Bank, it says, to maintain security and prevent terror attacks.

Most of the money in the economy comes from the government -- The Palestinian Authority -- the largest employer in the West Bank, and most of its money in turn comes from donor aid.

Many Palestinians are borrowing money to fund their basic needs and it is feared that, if donor aid dries up, many will be without work to fund their lifestyles.

We have around $5 billion in public debt that consists of around 70% of GDP, too huge for a government that's just born
Naser Abdelkarim, professor of financial economics, Birzeit University

Naser Abdelkarim, professor of financial economics at Birzeit University, said: "So the money comes from donors, yes. The largest borrower from the banking sector in (the Palestinian territories) is the government, and that's the danger.

"The large debt, public debt, we have around $5 billion in public debt that consists of around 70% of GDP, too huge for a government that's just born."

A World Bank report in July concluded that the Palestinian economy has grown at an average of 7.7% a year between 2007 and 2011, but that the growth was not sustainable.

It said the growth had been driven by foreign aid and that the private sector would need to take over to strengthen the economy.

John Nasir, lead author of the study, said in a press release: "Economic sustainability cannot be based on foreign aid so it is critical for the Palestinian Authority to increase trade and spur private sector growth."

Something the government says it is trying to do, even as it grapples with cash shortfalls.

Shryine Ziadeh opened Ramallah's first ballet school last year, but finds it difficult to cover her costs.
Shryine Ziadeh opened Ramallah's first ballet school last year, but finds it difficult to cover her costs.
CNN

The economic boom also allowed Shryine Ziadeh to follow her dream of opening the West Bank's first ballet school.

"When I was young and dancing ballet, I wished that I could do this and teach ballet," said Ziadeh, who opened her school last year with the help of her family. "I started it because in Ramallah we don't have ballet schools, we don't have dance schools in general."

However, now the costs are mounting and Ziadeh is working two jobs to earn enough money to repay her parents.

"I'm young and I don't have enough salary to go to the bank every month," she said. "I needed to rent the place, a good place, to have floors and mirrors and sound system.

I'm young and I don't have enough salary to go to the bank every month
Shryine Ziadeh, ballet school owner

"So my parents started to help me with it and now I'm working two jobs to repay."

Restaurant owner Sari Sarikini said he feels the impact of Israeli security restrictions, which mean he has to buy all his supplies from Israeli wholesalers.

"We have to build our country," he said. "Any country that's been built from scratch will have a lot of debt. The question is where is this money being geared? Is it being geared at service providers?

"I don't like to see service business, I like to see more self-sustaining businesses."

If the economy stalls, people will not have money to spend in bars like Khalili's.

"Encouraging a kind of economy that you can spend, that there's money to spend, that you can consume, in the same time you're living on the edge of, not a catastrophe, of economical catastrophe," said Khalili.

"The minute the economy fails, the first thing people will stop doing is going to bars, restaurants. Places like this will not survive in a destroyed economy."

Follow the Inside the Middle East team on Twitter: Presenter Rima Maktabi: @rimamaktabi, producer Jon Jensen: @jonjensen, producer Schams Elwazer: @SchamsCNN, writer Catriona Davies: @catrionadavies and digital producer Mairi Mackay: @mairicnn.

ADVERTISEMENT
Part of complete coverage on
updated 7:20 AM EDT, Thu August 21, 2014
Meet Erdal Inci, a digital artist from Turkey who is transforming the medium.
updated 9:39 AM EDT, Thu August 14, 2014
Iran is pumping billions of dollars into a scheme to save a lake. What's so important about it?
updated 10:18 PM EDT, Thu August 7, 2014
A volatile Middle East has changed the tenor of Ramadan programming in Egypt. Now, no topic is too taboo.
updated 10:53 PM EDT, Mon July 28, 2014
Dubai has got some big animal attractions in its mega malls. But not everyone is wild about the idea.
updated 11:14 PM EDT, Sun July 27, 2014
Orhan Pamuk, Turkey's Nobel Prize-winning author, is neither afraid to confront the human condition nor the state his country is in.
updated 10:57 PM EDT, Wed July 23, 2014
The smell of traditional dishes served during Ramadan fill the house of Iman, a Lebanese mother of four.
updated 7:22 AM EDT, Tue July 15, 2014
Unmanned aerial vehicles aren't generally thought of as technology that improves lives; the UAE wants to change that.
updated 9:49 PM EDT, Wed July 16, 2014
How an Iranian musician took ancient Persian poetry to the top of the U.S. charts.
updated 3:36 AM EDT, Wed July 2, 2014
How will the elevators work in the world's tallest building?
updated 8:24 AM EDT, Thu June 26, 2014
When Saher Shaikh first moved to Dubai, the rights of the city's labor population was the furthest thing from her mind.
updated 6:00 AM EDT, Thu June 19, 2014
It's not quite greening the desert, but an ambitious plan for an underground park could transform Abu Dhabi.
updated 7:06 AM EDT, Thu June 5, 2014
CNN's Ben Wedeman explores ancient footpaths in the wilds of the West Bank.
ADVERTISEMENT