Gallery: Who else should judge 'Idol'?
By Maria LaMagna, Special to CNN
updated 11:18 AM EDT, Tue July 24, 2012
After we learned that Steven Tyler and Jennifer Lopez would not return to "American Idol," rumors swirled that Mariah Carey was in talks to join the singing competition. The 43-year-old singer confirmed the news via Twitter on Monday: "It's gonna be so much fun working on @AmericanIdol." Who will join Carey and Randy Jackson (if he stays put) at the judges' table next season?
"Idol" could be a family affair if Carey's husband, Nick Cannon, joins the show. He has experience hosting programs like "America's Got Talent" and "Nick Cannon Presents: Wild 'N Out." But then, who would stay home with the twins?
"Idol" alum Adam Lambert has also been rumored to be in the running to become a judge. He told British radio station Capital FM he would "jump at the chance" if offered the spot.
The megapopular British singing star recently announced that she is pregnant. "Idol" would undoubtedly benefit from enlisting someone like her — a songstress known for her powerful vocals and heartfelt ballads — for its judging panel. And it could be the perfect break from performing for the new mom.
His stamp of approval did wonders for Justin Bieber, so who better to endorse another fledgling star? Usher could lend his expertise on both vocals and being a dynamic performer.
Thicke, an R&B star who broke through with the single "Lost Without U" in 2006, now dishes advice and criticism on ABC's "Duets." He has called himself the "underdog" of the show's judges, who also include John Legend, Kelly Clarkson and Jennifer Nettles. He may be enough of a household name now to snag "Idol" consideration.
Rap star Drake is one of the hottest and most talked-about artists right now, and his name alone would probably draw viewers. Plus, his youth and honest lyrics make him relatable, and we can only imagine his critiques would be on-point.
Clarkson, like Thicke, is a judge on "Duets," but we'd like to see an "Idol" homecoming in her future. The show's first winner could come full circle. She would look like a natural sitting at the judges' table.
"Idol's" Nigel Lythgoe has reportedly said he'd like Charlie Sheen to judge the singing competition show. And Sheen sounds like he'd be on board.
Who else should judge 'Idol'?
Nick Cannon
Adam Lambert
Adele
Usher
Robin Thicke
Drake
Kelly Clarkson
Charlie Sheen
Most popular stories right now
© 2012 Cable News Network. Turner Broadcasting System, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
|