Skip to main content

Former Israeli security chief slams handling of Iran

By Kevin Flower, CNN Jerusalem Bureau Chief
updated 4:46 AM EDT, Sun April 29, 2012
  • NEW: Ehud Barak describes Yuval Diskin's comments as 'irresponsible'
  • Diskin is the former head of the Shin Bet, the country's internal security service
  • He accuses Netanyahu and Barak of mischaracterizing the possible effectiveness of attacking Iran
  • Netanyahu says sanctions are not having a meaningful effect on Tehran's nuclear program

Jerusalem (CNN) -- Israel's former security chief is slamming the country's prime minister and defense minister for their handling of Iran, saying neither one inspires confidence.

"I don't trust a leadership that relies on messianic leadership," said Yuval Diskin, the former head of the Shin Bet, the country's internal security service, at a public conference Friday night in Israel.

"Our two messiahs from Caesaria and from the Akiorv Towers are not fit to stand at the helm of the government," Diskin said, referring to the respective residences of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Defense Minister Ehud Barak.

His comments were widely reported in the Israeli media Saturday.

Barak said while he welcomed Diskin's entry into politics, the comments are irresponsible.

"It is both embarrassing and saddening to see the weakening of judgment and responsibility and the low language a man who served the public for years was dragged into," said a statement from Barak's office. "Diskin is acting in a petty, irresponsible manner motivated by personal frustration. He is harming the heritage of generations of Shin Bet heads and the operational norms of the organization."

A senior Israeli government official said that the comments lacked credibility because the domestic security focus of the Shin Bet made the organization a "peripheral player" when it comes to Iran.

Benjamin Netanyahu told CNN this week time is running out for Western sanctions on Iran to have a meaningful effect.
Benjamin Netanyahu told CNN this week time is running out for Western sanctions on Iran to have a meaningful effect.

The same official, who declined to be named publicly due to the sensitivity of the issue, said Diskin's comments were "both surprising and strange" because he had worked under both Netanyahu and Barak, and sought to become Mossad director under their leadership.

"Are you saying these things because you didn't get the position?" the official asked rhetorically, adding that Diskin's attack seemed more "personal than policy."

Diskin, a widely respected former security official, also took the two Israeli leaders to task for mis-characterizing the possible effectiveness of a military strike against Iran and its nuclear program.

He said the Israeli government presented "a false view to the public on the Iranian bomb, as though acting against Iran would prevent a nuclear bomb. But attacking Iran will encourage them to develop a bomb all the faster."

It is not the first time a high-profile figure has criticized the Israeli government's handling of Iran.

Meir Dagan, the former chief of Israel's spy agency, the Mossad, has been a frequent and vocal critic of talk about an Israel strike on Iran, famously calling it a "stupid idea."

Israeli vice-premier and Likud party member Silvan Shalom told the Jerusalem Post that Diskin should not have spoken in public.

"I think that Diskin was wrong to say what he did, and that when he considers what he said he will realize that he was wrong," Shalom said.

Diskin's blunt commentary follows controversial remarks by Israel's top general, who said Iran is led by "very rational people" and doesn't appear poised to build a nuclear bomb that would threaten his nation.

Iran "is going step by step to the place where it will be able to decide whether to manufacture a nuclear bomb," Chief of Staff Lt. Gen. Benny Gantz told Israel's Haaretz newspaper in Wednesday editions. "It hasn't yet decided whether to go the extra mile."

Those comments were in stark contrast to those of Netanyahu, who suggested to CNN that time is running out for Western sanctions on Iran to have a meaningful effect on Tehran's nuclear program.

The sanctions "are certainly taking a bite out of the Iranian economy," Netanyahu said in an interview broadcast Tuesday on CNN's "Erin Burnett OutFront." But, he said, "They haven't rolled back the Iranian program -- or even stopped it -- by one iota."

Part of complete coverage on
Iran: Mounting tensions
updated 9:03 AM EDT, Fri April 13, 2012
Two months ago, Emad Ghavidel turned on the television in Tehran and saw graphic footage of an injured Syrian child crying out in pain.
updated 9:38 AM EST, Fri March 9, 2012
Iran's biggest customers are responding to increasing pressure to cut imports from Tehran.
updated 5:44 PM EST, Thu March 8, 2012
Faced with mounting pressure from world powers over its controversial nuclear program, Iran's ambassador to the IAEA says this country "is ready to re-engage with (the) IAEA."
updated 4:52 PM EST, Tue March 6, 2012
Republican presidential hopefuls and U.S. President Barack Obama trade barbs over Iran.
updated 9:56 AM EST, Fri March 9, 2012
Why is the international community suspicious of Iran's nuclear program? CNN's Hala Gorani reports.
updated 5:05 PM EST, Fri March 9, 2012
President Barack Obama's rebuke of Republicans who are "beating the drums of war" for military action against Iran should also be directed at Israel, Asher Kaufman says.
updated 12:51 PM EST, Thu March 8, 2012
Opinion: The only way war with Iran may be avoided is if the country believes an attack from the West is a real possibility, Frida Ghitis says.
updated 9:30 AM EDT, Mon March 19, 2012
Iran's controversial nuclear program began more than 50 years ago with aid from the West.
updated 11:39 AM EST, Thu March 8, 2012
(file photo) Ayatollah Ali Khamenei has criticized Barack Obama's threat to impose more sanctions on Iran.
Recent remarks by U.S. President Barack Obama that he is not thinking of military action against Iran are positive, according to Iran's supreme leader, Iran's state-run Press TV reported.
updated 5:31 PM EST, Mon March 5, 2012
CNN's Matthew Chance reports U.N. inspectors have "credible information" that Iran may be developing a nuclear device.
updated 2:31 PM EST, Tue March 6, 2012
LZ Granderson looks at the effect of Mahmoud Ahmadinejad and his nuclear weapons "game."
updated 11:22 AM EST, Fri March 9, 2012
A threatened Israeli attack on Iran's nuclear program carries enormous risks for the Jewish state, including international isolation, retaliation at home and abroad, and steep economic costs.
updated 3:36 PM EST, Tue March 6, 2012
Erin Burnett breaks down the mixed messages between Israel and the U.S. on Iran.
updated 1:34 PM EST, Tue March 6, 2012
Israeli President Shimon Peres discusses his concerns about Iran.