Skip to main content

Will shootings affect French election?

By Agnes Poirier, special to CNN
updated 6:24 AM EDT, Fri March 30, 2012
  • French election campaign suspended in the wake of shootings in Toulouse and Montauban
  • Latest polls suggest the attacks have had little effect on the elections so far
  • Education and unemployment remain top priorities for French voters, says Agnes Poirier
  • Poirier: Candidates have four weeks to answer people's questions and stop bickering over non-issues

Editor's note: Agnes Poirier is a French journalist and political analyst who contributes regularly to newspapers, magazines and TV in the UK, France and Italy. Follow her on Twitter @AgnesCPoirier

Paris (CNN) -- Re-election to the Elysée Palace was looking like mission impossible for President Nicolas Sarkozy: Trailing far behind the socialist candidate François Hollande in the polls for months, Sarkozy had only just recently narrowed his rival's lead, but only at the price of a pugnacious and robust few weeks of campaigning, exploiting the extreme right's favorite themes, immigration and halal meat.

Then tragedy struck in the streets of southwestern France, in the otherwise picturesque towns of Montauban and Toulouse.

The killing spree of a homegrown terrorist, radicalized in French prisons and trained in Pakistan and Afghanistan, acted like a jolt: Here was a Frenchman executing his compatriots at point blank range -- among them, little children aged three to eight -- in the name of Allah.

The election campaign stopped in its tracks, time seemed suspended. For three days, candidate Sarkozy became President again. French police reacted swiftly once the means were put into the investigation. The killer was identified, found and shot down after a 32-hour siege during which terrorist Mohammed Merah first said he would surrender and then swore to kill as many policemen as possible.

French gunman's brother charged
Bullet holes riddle Toulouse scene
Close up look at French raid
Could more have been done in Toulouse?

During those three days, French media kept quiet, didn't ask difficult questions, they were mainly processing the shock felt by the whole country. Never had France's children been harmed in a school before. In France, a school is a sacrosanct place at the heart of the French republic, the place where children become citizens.

Nicolas Sarkozy didn't waste much time. A few hours after Mohammed Merah was gunned down, he had traded his official clothes for that of the candidate's. At a political rally, he uttered the strongest words yet. He said it was immoral to ask questions surrounding Mohamed Merah's radicalization in France. The man was a monster and that was it.

The questions now are: Have the events in Toulouse changed the course and direction of the presidential elections?

The latest polls, carried out two days after the end of the siege, show that the events in Toulouse have not radically changed the situation.

Nicolas Sarkozy has only gained half a point, at 28% of expected votes on the first round of the elections, with François Hollande down by half a point at 27.5%. The socialist candidate would still win with ease at the second round. Marine Le Pen loses half a point, at 16.5%, while hard left Jean-Luc Mélenchon overtakes Centrist François Bayrou for the first time, with 13% of expected votes at the first round, leaving Bayrou behind on 11.5%.

Those polls seem to show that the French make a distinction between Sarkozy the president and Sarkozy the candidate. While 55% approve of his actions and tone during the events in Toulouse, they still reject him as a candidate.

The polls also show that security isn't really people's top priority, with only 8% of them listing it as their main concern.

Education and unemployment remain the top priorities of French people, both before and after the shootings in Montauban and Toulouse.

Strangely, very few candidates have elaborated on the economy. There have been a few announcements, such as François Hollande's promise to tax 75% of incomes above the 1 million euro mark, which 61% of the French approve of, and to create 60,000 jobs in the education sector, but apart from vague wording on how to try and cut the budget deficit, the campaign has mainly focused on the robust exchanges between camps and a controversy about halal meat.

This has so far been a disappointment to the French who were expecting more substance on topics which matter to them.

A recent poll has showed that the electoral turnout risks being one of the lowest since 1958 and the beginning of the Fifth Republic. In 2007, turnout was one of the highest, with 87% of voters turning out to cast their ballot at the second round of the elections.

The 10 candidates to the French presidency have four weeks left to finally answer the people's questions. And to stop bickering over non-issues such as halal meat.

Part of complete coverage on
France shootings
updated 9:12 AM EDT, Fri March 23, 2012
Did French intelligence services miss vital clues as Mohammed Merah showed signs of growing radicalization?
updated 12:11 PM EDT, Thu March 22, 2012
The Toulouse shootings refocus fears on trained attackers who are determined, living legally in the West and operating alone.
updated 7:38 AM EDT, Thu March 22, 2012
'Lone wolves' who plot to carry out small-scale attacks on soft targets could be the future of terrorism, a security expert warns.
updated 10:32 AM EDT, Fri March 23, 2012
Mohammed Merah, described as a self-styled al Qaeda jihadist, was named as the chief suspect in a series of deadly shootings.
updated 8:34 AM EDT, Thu April 12, 2012
CNN examines whether the handling of the crisis will have a bearing on the presidential poll.
updated 6:30 PM EDT, Tue March 20, 2012
In the pink-hued streets of Toulouse, France's "Ville Rose," flags are flying at half-mast: The city is in mourning -- and shock.
updated 12:08 AM EDT, Tue March 20, 2012
The city of Toulouse is at the highest security alert level, after a teacher and three children were gunned down at a Jewish school.
updated 7:51 PM EDT, Mon March 19, 2012
Agnes Poirier, a political commentator, talks about the disbelief in France after the deadly drive-by shooting at a school in Toulouse.
updated 6:06 AM EDT, Thu March 22, 2012
Out of nowhere a gunman appeared in the courtyard of a Jewish school in the French city just as students were arriving for morning classes.