Analysis: In key Romney win, some warning signs remain

Analysts: Is Romney really winning?
Analysts: Is Romney really winning?

    JUST WATCHED

    Analysts: Is Romney really winning?

MUST WATCH

Analysts: Is Romney really winning? 02:47

Story highlights

  • Romney picked up 6 of 10 Super Tuesday states
  • But exit polls hint at trouble for Romney in the fall should he become nominee
  • Conservative base backs Santorum over Romney in Ohio, other competitive states
  • In open primary states, Romney wasn't top choice for independent and Democratic voters

In a year when electability consistently tops Republican primary voters' lists of candidate qualities, Mitt Romney has made the sale. In contest after contest, he's generally chosen as the contender most likely to beat President Barack Obama in November.

On Tuesday, voters in Ohio agreed: They thought he was roughly twice as electable as Rick Santorum, according to exit polls.

But if Romney has primary voters' heads, Santorum seems to be reaching their hearts.

Super Tuesday results

Romney may have made up some ground with working-class voters, but Santorum held the advantage on the question of which candidate "best understands the problems of average Americans." He held it in the working-class battleground of Ohio; he held it in the evangelical stronghold of Tennessee. He didn't capture it in Vermont, where Romney scored a major win Tuesday; there, the title went to ... Ron Paul.

Still, Romney was the night's biggest winner.

Romney wins a close battle in Ohio
Romney wins a close battle in Ohio

    JUST WATCHED

    Romney wins a close battle in Ohio

MUST WATCH

Romney wins a close battle in Ohio 01:55
PLAY VIDEO
Romney's campaign costs adding up
Romney's campaign costs adding up

    JUST WATCHED

    Romney's campaign costs adding up

MUST WATCH

Romney's campaign costs adding up 01:26
PLAY VIDEO
Borger: Romney 'underperformed'
Borger: Romney 'underperformed'

    JUST WATCHED

    Borger: Romney 'underperformed'

MUST WATCH

Borger: Romney 'underperformed' 01:36
PLAY VIDEO
Romney: Real change is on the way
Romney: Real change is on the way

    JUST WATCHED

    Romney: Real change is on the way

MUST WATCH

Romney: Real change is on the way 01:10
PLAY VIDEO

Delegate tracker | Delegate calculator

As expected, Romney earned victories in home state territory with higher-than-average percentages of political moderates, like Massachusetts and Vermont; in Idaho, home to one of the nation's largest Mormon populations; and in Virginia, where his only rival to make the ballot was Ron Paul. He continued his strong showing with college-educated, wealthier voters, and seniors. But other key trends broke in his direction as well.

In recent contests, late momentum has tended to favor Santorum. Not Tuesday: Romney evened the playing field, with both candidates drawing roughly equal proportions of both early and late deciders in Ohio.

Then there was the gender breakdown. On first glance, there wasn't a major split: as in prior contests, men -- who made up a majority of Ohio's Republican primary voters -- favored Santorum, while women favored Romney.

Ohio exit polls

But breaking down the numbers still further: Rick Santorum had a 5-point edge among all Ohio voters combined, male and female -- except for the working women who made up around a fifth of the state's electorate today: Those voters gave Romney an 8-point edge. Romney continued to show strength with Catholic voters; virtually across the board, they supported him over fellow Catholic Rick Santorum. Even in Georgia, where home state candidate Newt Gingrich, also a Catholic, won a decisive victory, Catholics still backed Romney.

Romney also walked away with the night's biggest prize, Ohio. Still, should he become his party's nominee, exit polls hint at some hurdles in the fall.

Once again, the conservative base -- white evangelicals, strong supporters of the tea party movement, voters who believe abortion should always be illegal, and those who say the religious beliefs of candidates matter "a great deal" -- backed Santorum over Romney by significant margins in Ohio, as in other competitive states.

Romney captured independents in his home state of Massachusetts, but struggled to win them over virtually everywhere else. In open primary states with significant numbers of independent or Democratic voters, Ron Paul was the top pick for those blocs. In Ohio, Santorum took that title.

Santorum joined Romney on the losing end of one key stat in Ohio: More of their votes there came from people who still hold reservations about them than from strong supporters.

But an even more troubling number for Romney in a swing state that has historically been a required win for any successful Republican White House hopeful: Only six in 10 Santorum voters said they'd definitely back the GOP nominee no matter what. That's a good chunk of the GOP electorate -- and as Rick Santorum himself learned Tuesday, in Ohio, the slimmest margins can make all the difference.

      Election 2012

    • CHICAGO, IL - NOVEMBER 06:  U.S. President Barack Obama stands on stage with first lady Michelle Obama, U.S. Vice President Joe Biden and Dr. Jill Biden after his victory speech on election night at McCormick Place November 6, 2012 in Chicago, Illinois. Obama won reelection against Republican candidate, former Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney.  (Photo by Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)

      Obama makes history, again

      A black man is returning to the White House. Four years ago, it was a first, the breaking of a racial barrier. Tuesday night, it was history redux. And more.
    • CHICAGO, IL - NOVEMBER 06:  U.S. President Barack Obama stands on stage after his victory speech at McCormick Place November 6, 2012 in Chicago, Illinois. Obama won reelection against Republican candidate, former Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney.  (Photo by Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)

      Five things we learned

      The 2012 presidential election shattered spending records, further polarized a divided country and launched a thousand hashtags.
    • Demanding more from second term

      Even though voters indicated to pollsters that their financial situation is the same or worse than it was four years ago, they put their trust in the president.
    • US President Barack Obama addresses a crowd of supporters on stage on election night November 6, 2012 in Chicago, Illinois. President Barack Obama swept to re-election Tuesday, forging history again by transcending a slow economic recovery and the high unemployment which haunted his first term to beat Republican Mitt Romney. AFP PHOTO/Jewel Samad        (Photo credit should read JEWEL SAMAD/AFP/Getty Images)

      Victorious Obama faces challenges

      The president faces a long and familiar set of challenges after riding a wave of support from moderates, women and minorities to victory.
    • GOP retains grip on House

      Republicans kept a lock on the U.S. House of Representatives, a crucial victory after the party failed to wrest away the presidency from Barack Obama and the Senate from the Democrats.