Skip to main content

Why is North Korea willing to deal on nukes?

By Christine Ahn, Special to CNN
updated 1:10 PM EST, Thu March 1, 2012
Christine Ahn says more than 6 million North Koreans face food shortages, a powerful incentive for the regime to improve bilateral relations
Christine Ahn says more than 6 million North Koreans face food shortages, a powerful incentive for the regime to improve bilateral relations
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • Christine Ahn: Apparent breakthrough on N. Korean nukes comes at critical moment
  • She says Obama administration sees regime not likely to collapse
  • Ahn: China's sway could grow with food aid; and there are signs that U.S. influence waning
  • Ahn: Still, North Korea needs U.S. to lift its sanctions and to formally end Korean War

Editor's note: Christine Ahn is the Executive Director of the Korea Policy Institute and an advisory member of the Global Campaign to Save Jeju Island. She has testified at the United Nations, U.S. Congress and South Korean Human Rights Commission. She is a columnist with Foreign Policy In Focus and her op-eds have appeared in the International Herald Tribune, New York Times, San Francisco Chronicle and Asia Times

(CNN) -- The announcement Wednesday of a diplomatic breakthrough between the United States and North Korea is a welcome surprise at a critical time. Not only are more than 6 million North Koreans facing food shortages, but also the window is quickly closing for the United States to have any leverage over North Korea's nuclear program, given the changing global balance of power.

In exchange for an initial 240,000 tons of U.S. food aid and prospects for improving bilateral relations and returning to six-party talks, North Korea agreed to halt its uranium enrichment program, accept monitoring by the International Atomic Energy Agency, and stop testing its long-range missiles.

Christine Ahn
Christine Ahn

Contrary to some media assertions that U.S. food aid has not been linked to denuclearization, Washington has stalled for over a year on sending food to North Korea, despite a direct appeal from Pyongyang, and after several assessments, including by the U.N. World Food Program, the European Union, and a team of five U.S. nongovernmental organizations, all verifying the urgent need.

So what shifted?

N. Korea halts nuclear activities
WH: N. Korea actions a positive step
Deal first test of N. Korean leadership

For one, the Obama administration appears to have concluded that the succession to Kim Jong-Un has been a smooth transition and that the imminent collapse of the North Korean regime is unlikely. It has likely realized that nonengagement has been a complete failure.

South Korean President Lee Myung-bak has refused aid, trade and talks with North Korea until Pyongyang apologizes for its alleged sinking of a South Korean navy ship and shelling of Yeonpyong Island. Not only has the opposition Democratic Party in South Korea called for an end to sanctions and closer ties with North Korea, even members of Lee's own party are calling for more engagement.

Moreover, as China's trade and aid to North Korea have continued to grow, U.S.-led sanctions have not had their anticipated effect of undermining the North Korean regime. To the contrary, there are signs that Washington's ability to influence North Korea's behavior, including its nuclear program, is on the wane.

According to Katharina Zellweger, the former head of the Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation who worked in North Korea for 15 years, there are rumors that China already has or is planning to send food aid and fuel, though the amount is unclear.

"Why would [North Korea] deal with the United States?" she said. "The train has left the station."

This week's diplomatic breakthrough may indeed be one of the last opportunities Washington has to influence Pyongyang's nuclear program. As Secretary of State Hillary Clinton put it at a Senate hearing, "The world is transforming around us."

Why, then, is North Korea making concessions to the United States? North Korea still needs the United States to lift its sanctions and to formally end the Korean War. According to the Korean Central News Agency, the United States affirmed during talks in Beijing that its sanctions were not intended to target the North Korean people and that once six-party talks began, priority would be given to lift the sanctions.

North Koreans view resolving tensions with the United States as a crucial step to joining the international community, including being able to access loans from international financial institutions to recalibrate their economy.

This point was made last year by former President Jimmy Carter, who explained, "In almost any case when there are sanctions against an entire people, the people suffer the most and the leaders suffer least." In the case of North Korea, Carter said that "the last 50 years of deprivation of the North Korean people of adequate access to trade and commerce has been very damaging to their economy."

Most Americans don't realize that underlying tensions with North Korea stem from the unresolved Korean War, which ended not with a peace treaty, but only with a temporary armistice. We cannot lose sight of the fact that peace is the only solution to ending hunger in North Korea.

North Koreans need food aid, but they also need an end to hostilities, the lifting of sanctions and a genuine engagement plan that includes a formal resolution of the Korean War. This week's diplomatic breakthrough brings us that much closer to realizing peace on the Korean Peninsula and gives hope that denuclearization there and elsewhere can be still achieved through diplomacy.

Follow us on Twitter @CNNOpinion

Join us on Facebook/CNNOpinion

The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of Christine Ahn.

ADVERTISEMENT
Part of complete coverage on
A North Korean soldier stands guard at the Panmunjom border with South Korea, on December 8, 2010.
Follow all of our coverage about the key issues unfolding inside North Korea and how it affects you.
updated 9:30 AM EDT, Tue May 14, 2013
Myanmar was once a pariah, but it has surprised almost everyone by becoming a Western investor's dream. Can North Korea follow?
updated 7:29 AM EDT, Tue May 14, 2013
Abandoned by her parents, Yoon Hee lived on the streets of North Korea for years, surviving on grass and the mercy of others.
updated 4:45 PM EDT, Fri May 10, 2013
A defector shares the horrific experience of being born to a "total control zone", where guards beat children to death with no hesitation.
updated 6:53 PM EDT, Tue May 7, 2013
Chinese war veteran Duan Keke defended North Korea during the Korean War. Now he believes China will prevent another war.
updated 5:42 PM EDT, Sun April 14, 2013
When she was growing up in North Korea, Hyeonseo Lee thought her country was normal -- even though she saw her first public execution at 7.
updated 2:39 AM EDT, Tue April 16, 2013
CNN's Kyung Lah examines the reign of Kim Jong Un and notes its similarities to his grandfather, Kim Il Sung.
Check out a map of the known conventional weaponry in North Korea's arsenal and their estimated strike ranges.
updated 9:22 AM EST, Tue February 12, 2013
Experts say Pyongyang is moving forward to developing a nuclear warhead and a deliverable missiles. Question remains: How close is it?
updated 2:34 AM EDT, Thu April 11, 2013
Here's a look at Kim's escalating rhetoric and his country's actions since he came to power after his father's death in 2011.
More than two dozen countries have nuclear power, but only a few have nuclear weapons or are suspected of pursuing nuclear weapons.
updated 12:55 AM EDT, Mon March 11, 2013
The war never really ended -- leaving the peninsula splintered in 1953, killing more than two millions and drawing the alliances that exist today.
updated 9:07 PM EDT, Thu April 4, 2013
Why are we so fearful and fascinated by North Korea? Here's a round-up of what you had to say on social media.
updated 5:25 AM EDT, Thu March 28, 2013
Kim Jong Un is still an "unknown quantity." Is his behavior erratic or staged? Is he competent enough to run the North Korean government?
ADVERTISEMENT