Skip to main content

Syrian rebel leadership is split

By Ivan Watson and Omar al Muqdad
updated 6:24 AM EST, Tue February 7, 2012
A young boy carries the Syrian rebel-adopted flag during an anti-regime demonstration Friday in al-Qsair.
A young boy carries the Syrian rebel-adopted flag during an anti-regime demonstration Friday in al-Qsair.
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • Various officers say they are the lead opposition
  • "Higher Military Council," "Free Syrian Army" are two of the rebel groups
  • A third says it represents rebels battling government forces in the besieged city of Homs

Istanbul, Turkey (CNN) -- Rival dissident army officers are claiming to lead the increasingly armed rebellion within Syria, exposing rifts within the opposition.

In an interview by telephone with CNN, Maj. Mahar Naimi introduced himself as a spokesman for the "Higher Military Council," a newly formed organization that now claimed to lead armed defectors within Syria.

"This council represents the people fighting in Syria," Naimi said. He added that the council was led by Gen. Mustafa Sheikh, an officer who defected from the Syrian military.

But Naimi's claim was quickly rejected by another defecting officer, Col. Riad al Assad, who spent much of the last year claiming to lead a "Free Syrian Army" of rebel soldiers from a refugee camp on the Turkish border with Syria.

Discussing Egypt and Syria
U.S. shuts down embassy in Syria
Toner: 'We hear the people of Syria'
A member of the Free Syrian Army engages in an attack against the Syrian army in Al-Qusayr on January 27. The small town in western Syria has been under siege since early November. A member of the Free Syrian Army engages in an attack against the Syrian army in Al-Qusayr on January 27. The small town in western Syria has been under siege since early November.
On the front lines with the Free Syrian Army
HIDE CAPTION
<<
<
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
>
>>
Photos: Front lines of Free Syrian Army Photos: Front lines of Free Syrian Army

"This man represents himself," Assad said in reference to Sheikh. "He has nothing to do with the Free Syrian Army ... those people are representing themselves and do not represent the revolution and the Free Syrian Army. They don't represent anybody."

Assad spoke to CNN by telephone from the Turkish border region.

"This is a conflict for leadership, which happens in all organizations and political parties," explained a Turkish diplomat, who spoke to CNN following diplomatic protocol on condition of anonymity.

World seeks next step as deaths mount

The diplomat confirmed that more than a month ago, Sheikh had come to the same refugee camp in Turkey that housed Assad. The diplomat added that the general had tried to assume command over the colonel.

It is not clear how much command and control any of the exiled officers have over defecting troops and other armed opposition groups inside Syria.

But another former army officer based in Istanbul told CNN neither the Higher Military Council nor Assad's Free Syrian Army represented a rebel faction currently battling government forces in the besieged city of Homs.

Ancient city in the cross hairs

"We are not working under the control of the Free Syrian Army or the Higher Military Council, we are independent," said Lt. Bassim Khaled, who claimed to represent the rebel "Al Faroukh Battalion" in Homs from his places of refuge in Istanbul.

During the more than 10 months since the uprising began in Syria, competing civilian exiles have also claimed leadership of the revolution.

Some Western diplomats working closely with opposition groups have privately expressed frustration with dissidents' lack of unity, even as the death toll continues to rise within Syria.

The human toll of unrest in Syria

"A natural reaction for people who have been brutalized for so long is depression and grandiosity," said Andrew Tabler, author of "In the Lion's Den" and a Syria specialist with the Washington Institute of Near East Policy.

"It is also confounded by the fact that Syria is made up of various sects and ethnicities."

Bassem Imadi, a former Syrian ambassador who now works out of the Istanbul offices of the opposition Syrian National Council, argued that after decades of dictatorship, party politics were still a new concept for many of his countrymen.

"Look at it like [political] parties being formed for the first time right now," he said. "One day they will come together."

ADVERTISEMENT
Part of complete coverage on
Syrian crisis
There's more to the Syrian civil war than rebels versus the regime. Syria's neighbors in the Middle East also have a stake in the conflict.
updated 5:13 PM EDT, Thu May 9, 2013
Israel is taking steps to defend itself against threatened retaliation from Syria after claims it launched airstrikes on Damascus.
updated 12:36 PM EDT, Tue May 14, 2013
Domestic political will is a necessary for intervention and polls show Americans are reluctant to support military interventions in Syria.
updated 1:38 PM EDT, Mon May 6, 2013
Syria's claim that Israel launched airstrikes presents a dangerous escalation of Israel's involvement in Syria's war, writes Fawaz Gerges.
updated 5:41 AM EDT, Tue May 7, 2013
The U.N. says a Syrian rebel group may have used a nerve agent -- it would not be the first time the al-Qaeda-affiliated group used chemical weapons.
updated 2:00 PM EDT, Wed May 1, 2013
Having willfully avoided direct military involvement in Syria for the past two years, Obama may not be so lucky anymore, writes Aaron David Miller.
updated 5:44 AM EDT, Fri May 10, 2013
What began as a protest movement became an uprising that metastasized into a war, a vicious whirlpool dragging a whole region toward it.
A devout man prays. A fighter weeps over a slain comrade. These are a few faces of the Syrian conflict captured by photographer LeeHarper.
updated 4:59 AM EDT, Thu April 25, 2013
A group of pro-Syrian regime hackers that has targeted major news organizations but its cyber attacks can have real-life impact.
updated 6:24 PM EST, Thu March 7, 2013
A woman participates in a demonstration in support of the Syrian people on July 7, 2012, in front of the Pantheon in Paris.
The role of women in Syrian uprising is little reported, but many have played a key part as activists and medics since the bloodshed began.
Are you in Syria? Share your stories, videos and photos with the world on CNN iReport, but please stay safe.
ADVERTISEMENT