Skip to main content

U.S. Defense Department can't account for billions for Iraq, audit finds

By Josh Levs, CNN
updated 10:14 AM EST, Mon January 30, 2012
Iraqis work on a construction project in Baghdad in October 2003.
Iraqis work on a construction project in Baghdad in October 2003.
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • NEW: The U.S. is keeping Iraq out of the loop on some projects, report says
  • NEW: The U.S. Embassy in Iraq disagrees with that complaint
  • The Defense Department can't account for about $2 billion in past spending, report says
  • The department acknowledges a "records management issue"

(CNN) -- The U.S. Defense Department cannot account for about $2 billion it was given to cover Iraq-related expenses and is not providing Iraq with a complete list of U.S.-funded reconstruction projects, according to two new government audits.

The reports come from the office of the Special Inspector General for Iraq Reconstruction.

The Iraqi government in 2004 gave the Department of Defense access to about $3 billion to pay bills for certain contracts, and the department can only show what happened to about a third of that, the inspector general says in an audit published Friday.

Although the Department of Defense (DoD) had "internal processes and controls" to track payments, the "bulk of the records are missing," the report says, adding that the department is searching for them.

Other documents are missing as well, including monthly reports documenting expenses, the audit says.

"From July 2004 through December 2007, DoD should have provided 42 monthly reports. However, it can locate only the first four reports."

A letter accompanying the report is signed by Stuart Bowen, the inspector general. The audit was overseen by Glenn Furbish, assistant inspector general for audits.

In a response letter also contained in the report, Defense Under Secretary Mark Easton acknowledges "a records management issue."

The audit says it believes records management is to blame, and "has been an ongoing problem for DoD in Iraq. By all accounts, DoD established good internal processes and controls to account for and report on" the funds it was given after the Coalition Provisional Authority dissolved.

Where the records did exist, they matched other records and contained "good financial documentation supporting individual payments." Also, there is "sufficient evidence" that required monthly reports were sent to the government of Iraq, even though they can't be found, the audit said.

The audit deals with a time when Iraq's government was undergoing a transition. The Coalition Provisional Authority ran the country for 14 months from 2003 to 2004. During that time, the authority awarded numerous contracts. When it dissolved in 2004, the Iraqi government gave the U.S. Defense Department access to the $3 billion to pay bills for contracts the provisional authority had awarded.

The Defense Department letter from Easton -- the department's deputy chief financial officer -- thanks the inspector general's office for "the collaborative effort and professional courtesy" in a series of audits.

Separately, the inspector general's office sent a letter Sunday to the U.S. ambassador to Iraq complaining that the U.S. government is not providing Iraq with a complete list of reconstruction projects.

The U.S. criteria for selecting which projects to report to Iraq -- which include only those valued at $250,000 or more -- is a central part of the problem, the letter says.

The U.S. Embassy says the system is designed to help Iraq "focus its limited resources on sustainment of infrastructure and other large capital projects done through U.S. reconstruction efforts," the report notes.

The inspector general's office argues that the limited list -- which is also "hampered by unreliable data and other data entry problems" -- does not allow Iraq to decide where to focus its resources, and notes that the country might consider some smaller projects more important than those that are reported.

"Without more comprehensive knowledge about reconstruction projects the (Iraqi government) will not be in a position to maximize the use of its resources," the report says.

Billions of dollars in spending are not reported to Iraq under the current system, the report says.

In a response letter, Peter Bodde, assistant chief of mission for the U.S. Embassy in Iraq, says that while the current system is incomplete, "it does capture the vast majority of reconstruction projects and there is no other alternative that captures more."

He also notes that the Iraq reconstruction effort "is now in its very last stages, and all remaining capital projects will be reported through the asset transfer process."

The Office of the Special Inspector General for Iraq Reconstruction was created in 2004 to continue oversight of Iraq reconstruction programs.

ADVERTISEMENT
Part of complete coverage on
updated 5:46 AM EST, Wed February 29, 2012
CNN's Kyung Lah reports from inside the damaged nuclear plant which sparked mass evacuations after its meltdown last year.
updated 7:22 AM EST, Thu March 1, 2012
James Murdoch, head of News Corp's European operations
James Murdoch, who has quit as executive chairman of scandal-hit News International, was once seen as heir to the Murdoch empire.
updated 5:19 PM EST, Tue February 28, 2012
Syrian troops inflicted heavy losses on opposition activists trying to smuggle Western journalists out of the country, survivors say.
updated 2:58 AM EST, Wed February 29, 2012
The world's most valuable company has lost the first round ina court battle with a small Chinese company t over the right to use the iPad name.
updated 1:46 PM EST, Thu March 1, 2012
Its creators hope the credit card-sized Raspberry Pi computer will spark a new wave of interest in programming and coding.
updated 4:59 PM EST, Thu March 1, 2012
Motoring writer James Foxall says with developing nations demanding ever more fuel, the planet can't put up with gas-guzzling monsters any more.
Iran has been behind some provocative acts and bellicose rhetoric, argue analysts -- but what are we to make of it all?
updated 6:56 AM EST, Tue February 28, 2012
Unemployed young people wear bowler hats as they stand in line outside a job centre in central London during a photocall for the Battlefront Campaign, raising awareness of the large number of young people who are currently unemployed in the UK on October 10, 2011.
There's no question that losing your job can be a jolting experience, says one expert, but what if it could be a force for good?
Africa is quietly undergoing a tech revolution that could transform lives -- now meet the people who could change a continent.
updated 12:09 PM EST, Wed February 29, 2012
Some of the world's best-known telecoms brands are partnering with health-sector companies to enter the medical fray.
updated 5:31 AM EST, Tue February 28, 2012
Our phones are becoming uncontrollable monsters, argues 'professional skeptic' Andrew Keen.
updated 12:29 PM EST, Mon February 27, 2012
As one of Rupert Murdoch's newspapers makes another six-figure settlement, Max Mosley, asks how can tabloid excesses can be curbed.
updated 4:47 AM EST, Tue February 28, 2012
"The Artist" became the first silent film to win best picture at the Academy Awards in 83 years -- but was this a triumph of marketing over art?
ADVERTISEMENT