Skip to main content

Breast implant concerns spur legal action from South Americans

By Rafael Romo and Catherine E. Shoichet, CNN
updated 7:12 AM EST, Wed January 11, 2012
A woman shows the certificates of breast implants from French brand PIP, in Caracas Venezuela, on January 6, 2012.
A woman shows the certificates of breast implants from French brand PIP, in Caracas Venezuela, on January 6, 2012.
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • An attorney argues the European Union should pay to replace implants
  • Women with the implants in Venezuela are suing distributors
  • "We want these companies that sold PIP to held responsible," their attorney says
  • One woman calls her fear that the implants will rupture a "nightmare"

(CNN) -- More than 1,000 South American women who have breast implants made by a bankrupt French company are taking legal action to get money for replacement surgery, attorneys said Tuesday.

In Venezuela, a group of more than 1,500 women who have breast implants made by Poly Implant Prostheses (PIP) have filed a lawsuit against the company's distributors, attorney Gilberto Andrea said.

And a group of 500 Argentinian women with the implants are asking for the creation of a government fund in Europe to compensate victims, according to an attorney who represents the association's president.

The PIP implants were banned last year in Europe because they were made with harmful, industrial-grade silicone and prone to rupture.

Lawyer defends silicone implants
Germany, UK weigh in on implant concern
Defective implant victims want answers
Germany, UK weigh in on implant concern

The government of France has said it will pay to replace the faulty implants of about 30,000 French women. But there is no fund established for foreigners, Paris-based attorney Arie Alimi said.

UK breast implant victims want answers

Alimi said he would request a meeting with the European Commission and the French Health Ministry on behalf of the Argentinian women.

"The first goal is to have this fund created because of the responsibility and the liability of the European Union," he said, arguing that officials there should have done more to check and regulate the implants before they were sold.

"This is the only way for Argentinian women and for all the victims in the world to be indemnified,' he said.

Alimi said he would represent Argentinian attorney Virginia Luna, the head of the organization, in a suit over the implants in France.

Meanwhile, in Venezuela, women with the implants have filed a lawsuit against distributors of the implants.

"We want these companies that sold PIP to be held responsible," said Andrea, their attorney.

Andrea said he is also asking a court to conduct an economic study to determine how much profit was made from selling the implants and require companies that made money to award his clients double that amount in reparations.

Alimi said he had spoken with Andrea about the possibility of representing the Venezuelan women in France.

"What we're asking for is that the prosthesis be removed and that a new one be implanted at no cost. And of course, we want the freedom to choose a doctor to do the implants. Some private clinics have recently offered patients with PIP implants a free removal, but they still have to pay for the cost of the new implant," Luna told CNN earlier this month.

Luna said as many as 13,500 women have the implants in Argentina.

Some legislators there are asking the government to help pay for the replacement surgery, which costs an estimated $3,500.

Germany, UK weigh in on breast implant concern

About 300,000 women in 65 countries received breast implants from the company. The implants were banned in 2010, and the company went bankrupt later that year.

The implants are not approved for use in the United States.

Authorities in France and England have dismissed fears of cancer from the implants, but have said the devices are prone to rupture and could cause inflammation, scarring and fibrosis.

That's a constant concern for Silvia Rodriguez, who got the implants in Buenos Aires in 2009.

"It makes me nervous all the time. Sometimes I feel some pain, and I don't know if it's related to the implants or not. I try to calm down, but still feel I need to do something about it. I can't wait to go back to the operating room and hear the words 'it's been done' so that the nightmare is over," Rodriguez said.

CNN's Diana Magnay and Stefan Simons contributed to this report.

ADVERTISEMENT
Part of complete coverage on
updated 7:50 PM EDT, Wed May 30, 2012
It's an outside-the-box solution, says Clyde Prestowitz, but the German government can save Greece by reissuing its beloved deutsche mark.
updated 5:33 AM EDT, Wed May 30, 2012
Images of slaughter in the Syrian town of Houla provoked outrage around the world, but sometimes outrage isn't enough to spur action, says Tim Lister.
updated 3:56 PM EDT, Wed May 30, 2012
Alleged poison attacks against students in Afghanistan show the fragility of the country's transition, says Gayle Lemmon.
updated 5:27 AM EDT, Wed May 30, 2012
Airport dining doesn't have to be terminal, as a new wave of eateries elevates cuisine above the level of greasy burgers and wilting sushi.
updated 7:10 PM EDT, Wed May 30, 2012
Andrew Keen says our self esteem is determined by our use of social media -- so let's embrace tech which lets data degenerate over time.
updated 7:27 AM EDT, Thu May 31, 2012
Republican Graham Smith argues why the UK monarchy should be consigned to the history books.
CNN's Richard Quest rails against the censorious ratings warnings placed on inflight movies.
updated 12:06 PM EDT, Wed May 30, 2012
Queen Elizabeth was criticized for being aloof after Princess Diana's death in 1997. But one royal insider says that wasn't the case.
updated 5:45 AM EDT, Wed May 30, 2012
His Holiness the Dalai Lama sits on his throne during a tea ceremony in the Lerab Ling Buddhist temple on August 22, 2008 at Roqueredonde in Languedoc-Roussillon region, southern France.
Businessman Christian Stadil believes firms must care about more than money and that corporate social responsibility helps attract talented workers.
updated 11:08 AM EDT, Thu May 31, 2012
Female business leaders in Saudi
It's hard being a female busineswoman in a country where women need permission to work or travel. But some try.
updated 3:31 AM EDT, Mon May 28, 2012
How law enforcement agencies are readying themselves for this month's Euro 2012 soccer tournament.
updated 8:53 AM EDT, Thu May 31, 2012
Adoptions from Africa have surged three-fold in eight years -- but campaigners fear that children from the continent are becoming commodities.
updated 7:17 AM EDT, Thu May 31, 2012
He's been running all his life, running for freedom, running for peace. Now Reza Baluchi is heading for Mt. Everest by running across the Middle East.
updated 7:13 AM EDT, Tue May 29, 2012
An old meatpacking plant in Chicago is being transformed into an eco farm, which its founders say will produce food sustainably with zero waste.
ADVERTISEMENT