Rare Kabul attack: Who did it and why?

Holy day turns deadly in Afghanistan
Holy day turns deadly in Afghanistan


    Holy day turns deadly in Afghanistan


Holy day turns deadly in Afghanistan 01:39

Story highlights

  • Tuesday's deadly suicide attack didn't fit pattern of what had come before
  • Mass casualty attacks are rare now: insurgents prefer to hit strategic targets
  • Interior ministry points its finger at Taliban, despite an effusive denial
  • Many Afghans place blame at one source: Pakistan

Tuesday's deadly suicide attack targeting Afghan Shia just didn't fit the pattern of what had come before in this troubled country.

The police formed the usual cordon at the attack site -- this time a shrine in Kabul. Sirens pierced the odd moment of eerie silence, but the police chief's face was contorted with fury and confusion, like he'd seen something new and troubling -- even after decades of conflict here.

Yes, the insurgency has specialized in hitting targets right in the city center, often meters away from key institutions. Yes, they are aimed for effect.

But mass casualty attacks like we used to see in 2009 are rare these days. The insurgents prefer to hit strategic targets -- unless their roadside bombs are maiming civilians elsewhere.

And no, the Shia simply weren't targets before. Sectarianism was seldom an issue here: Afghanistan has lacked the Sunni-Shia divide in Iraq that helped to keep Saddam in power but made his fall so bloody.

It has been spared the brand of Sunni extremism in Pakistan, where ruthless attacks on Shia are a shocking part of the fabric.

Uncommon attacks target Shiite Muslims
Uncommon attacks target Shiite Muslims


    Uncommon attacks target Shiite Muslims


Uncommon attacks target Shiite Muslims 01:54
Video shows moment of Kabul blast
Video shows moment of Kabul blast


    Video shows moment of Kabul blast


Video shows moment of Kabul blast 01:02

The question of who did it was quickly answered but unsatisfactorily.

The interior ministry here points its finger at the Taliban, despite an effusive denial from spokesman Zabiullah Mujahid.

It's arguable that an offshoot of the Lashkar-e-Janghvi movement, which reportedly rang in a claim from Pakistan, is capable of mounting a sophisticated, targeted and vicious attack in the very heart of Kabul without some assistance.

If they are responsible, it does require some explanation as to how a small, rogue group of extremists -- which has links to al Qaeda and the Pakistan Taliban -- could suddenly develop the capacity to penetrate the capital of a neighboring state. And are Pakistani extremists really operating freely inside Afghanistan now?

Whether the culprits turn out to be the Pakistan-based Haqqani network -- the group blamed for recent high-profile and sophisticated attacks in the capital -- the Lashkar-e-Janghvi al Almi, or another complex part of Afghanistan's insurgency, fractured and complicated after 10 years, many Afghans place the blame at one source: Pakistan.

That's the "address" that Kabul thinks the Taliban now resides under. That's who they blame for most of the ills here, despite simultaneously hoping they will come to the negotiating table and help.

But we should not rush to attribute blame for one reason: The advent of Pakistani extremists trying to foment sectarian violence in Afghanistan at this late stage in the war is a prospect too terrifying to behold.

      10 years of war in Afghanistan

    • 10 years, 10 views

      10 iReporters outline 10 very different experiences of their years with the war.
    • walsh.afghan.war.witness_00000213

      Witness to a changed Kabul

      In Kabul, CNN's Nick Paton Walsh talks to a man who has witnessed the war and experienced first-hand changes in Kabul
    • The burning remains of a NATO supply convoy symbolizes the immense threat from Taliban insurgents.

      Tragedy mirrors Afghan story

      Ten years on, CNN's Nic Robertson tells the story of two brothers who helped CNN in the early days of the conflict
    • An Afghan policeman keeps journalists away from the alley leading to the house of head of Afghanistan's High Peace Council and former President Burhanuddin Rabbani after a suicide attack in Kabul on September 20, 2011. Afghanistan's former president tasked with leading peace efforts in the war-torn country was assassinated on September 20 in a suicide attack at his Kabul home, according to police. Rabbani, who was president during the chaotic 1992-96 Afghan civil war, was last year appointed chief of the High Council for Peace that President Hamid Karzai tasked with negotiating with the Taliban, so far unsuccessfully.

      iReport: Your views

      We want to hear from U.S. troops, contractors and Afghans about how the war changed your life during the past 10 years
    • Members of U.S. Special Forces ride horseback into Afghanistan in the early days of Operation Enduring Freedom. Horses were often the only way to travel over long distances in the remote parts of Northern Afghanistan.

      5 key moments of the war

      From horses and bombs at the start to Osama bin Laden's death, the Security Clearance takes a look at 5 pivotal moments