Skip to main content

James Murdoch like 'Mafia boss,' says lawmaker

By Peter Wilkinson, CNN
updated 12:29 PM EST, Thu November 10, 2011
  • News International chief rejects claims his company behaved like Mafia organization
  • James Murdoch grilled again by committee of Parliament over phone-hacking
  • Murdoch accused two ex-News of the World executives of misleading lawmakers
  • Newspaper allegedly intercepted phone calls and messages of almost 5,800 individuals

London (CNN) -- News International chief James Murdoch rejected allegations Thursday his company behaved like a Mafia organization over the News of the World phone-hacking scandal.

The accusation was put to the son of media tycoon Rupert Murdoch as he faced questions from lawmakers about what he knew and when. It is alleged that his company's newspaper intercepted cellphone calls and messages of almost 5,800 royals, politicians, celebrities and business leaders -- and most controversially of all, a 13-year-old murder victim.

Public outrage over the scandal later led News International to close the best-selling tabloid in July and abandon a bid to take over British broadcaster BSkyB.

Questioning Murdoch about why so little information was shared, Labour Member of Parliament Tom Watson suggested the company operated an "omerta" code of silence. He said the "omerta" was "a group of people who are bound together by secrecy, who together pursue their group's business objectives with no regard for the law, using intimidation, corruption and general criminality."

UK phone scandal recapped
James Murdoch on the hot seat
Murdoch heckled by Occupy protesters
Pressure may be mounting on the Murdochs

"Would you agree with me that this is an accurate description of News International in the UK?" Watson asked.

Murdoch replied: "Absolutely not, I frankly think that's offensive and it's not true."

To gasps of amazement from fellow MPs on the Culture, Media and Sport Committee, Watson went on: "You must be the first Mafia boss in history who didn't know he was running a criminal enterprise."

Murdoch rolled his eyes, before saying that comment was "inappropriate."

He said he "disputed vigorously" the version of events described by former News of the World editor Colin Myler and its former legal manager Tom Crone, who both left the company when the tabloid was closed.

Myler and Crone claimed they made Murdoch aware of the contents of the so-called "for Neville" e-mail in 2008, indicating phone-hacking was widespread. The document is known as the "for Neville" e-mail, apparently after its intended recipient Neville Thurlbeck, then News of the World's chief reporter.

CNN's Atika Shubert said Murdoch was caught in a "Catch-22" situation: if he wasn't aware of the extent of phone-hacking when the company paid an out-of-court settlement of $1.2 million to one victim, he could be seen to be incompetent; if he did know about it, it could be regarded there was a cover-up.

Murdoch has maintained he only found about the full extent of phone-hacking by staff and investigators at News of the World in 2010 and was not shown the e-mail.

Asked by Watson if he had misled the committee during his previous high-drama appearance alongside his father in July, Murdoch said: "No, I did not."

He added: "I believe this committee was given evidence by individuals either without full possession of the facts, or now it appears in the process of my own discovery ... it was economical."

Asked if he was accusing Myler and Crone of misleading the committee, Murdoch replied: "Certainly in the evidence they gave to you in 2011 in regard to my own knowledge, I believe it was inconsistent and not right, and I dispute it vigorously."

You must be the first Mafia boss in history who didn't know he was running a criminal enterprise.
Labour MP Tom Watson

Questioned about the "for Neville" e-mail that included transcripts of 35 hacked conversations, Murdoch denied again having seen it.

His statement contradicted a letter Crone wrote to lawmakers in the summer saying he had "no doubt" Murdoch was aware of the e-mail in a meeting before he signed the check for $1.2 million.

Murdoch said Thursday: "I want to be very clear. No documents were shown to me or given to me at that meeting or prior to it."

Taking a contrite tone, Murdoch told lawmakers that the scandal had "humbled" the whole company and that he was "very sorry" about what had happened.

He also said the company had "moved into an aggressive defense too quickly" when some of the claims were made against it in early 2010.

If he had known then what he knows now, he said, he would have acted differently.

Murdoch's position at the helm of News International is widely believed to have been jeopardized by the scandal, which has cost its parent company $150 million. Amid the furore, the Murdochs abandoned their attempt to buy the shares they did not own in British broadcaster BSkyB.

Thursday's hearing came only days after News International admitted the Sunday tabloid hired a private detective to spy on lawyers defending hacking victims. Murdoch said he had no knowledge of the "appalling" and "unacceptable" action for which he apologized "unreservedly."

The phone-hacking scandal blew up in July when News International admitted investigators hacked into the phone of missing teenager Milly Dowler, deleting messages to allow room for more. This gave the 13-year-old's family hope that she was still alive when she was already dead.

Then it was alleged families of soldiers killed in Iraq and Afghanistan as well as relatives of 9/11 victims had been targeted and police officers bribed.

Amid a storm of outrage and a boycott by advertisers, News of the World was closed down shortly afterwards while chief executive Rebekah Brooks and long-time Murdoch aide Les Hinton resigned.

In July the Murdochs were summoned before parliament. At the dramatic appearance, Rupert Murdoch denied he was to blame for the scandal, but declared that this was "the most humble day of my life."

Afterwards, Britain's Prime Minister David Cameron said James Murdoch had "questions to answer in Parliament," after Myler and Crone accused their former boss of giving "mistaken" evidence.

Until this year, News International had maintained that hacking was confined to one rogue reporter, Clive Goodman, and private investigator Glenn Mulcaire, who were jailed in 2007 for intercepting the royal family's phones.

CNN's Laura Smith-Spark contributed to this report.

Part of complete coverage on
updated 11:32 AM EDT, Thu July 3, 2014
Britain's phone-hacking scandal has seen former tabloid editor Andy Coulson move from the newsroom into the full glare of its spotlight.
updated 10:42 AM EDT, Tue June 24, 2014
Rebekah Brooks was once feted as one of the rising stars of the British media.
updated 10:19 AM EDT, Tue June 24, 2014
Rupert Murdoch
An old-fashioned press baron with ink running through his veins, a hefty checkbook, and a hunger for the next big story.
updated 10:20 AM EDT, Tue June 24, 2014
How did phone hacking grow into a scandal that threatened Rupert Murdoch's hold on his global media business? Track all the major events.
updated 10:17 AM EDT, Tue June 24, 2014
The phone hacking trial revealed much about the inner workings of Rupert Murdoch's sex-and-scandal tabloids.
updated 7:34 AM EST, Thu November 29, 2012
Revelations that murdered UK schoolgirl Milly Dowler 's phone was hacked sparked outrage. But who was the girl at the center of the scandal?
updated 1:21 PM EST, Wed November 28, 2012
Media expert Brian Cathcart says Fleet St. has grabbed its megaphone and started bellowing out its usual message: leave us alone.
updated 6:33 AM EST, Thu November 29, 2012
James Murdoch, head of News Corp's European operations
James Murdoch was widely regarded as heir-apparent to his father global media empire. All that changed when the hacking scandal broke.
updated 6:30 AM EST, Fri November 30, 2012
Could the phone-hacking scandal prove to be a blessing in disguise for Murdoch? He claimed to have been "humbled" by the scandal.
The Leveson inquiry is a British government-backed inquiry into illegal eavesdropping and bribery by journalists. Read the final report by Lord Leveson.
Phone-hacking scandal revealed the dark side of tabloid journalism. Should it lead to a stricter press regulation? Share your views with CNN.