Skip to main content

Finale stuns 'Idol' worshippers

  • Story Highlights
  • Musician pulled out a surprise win over Adam Lambert on "American Idol"
  • Fans and viewers expressed shock over the result
  • Multiple theories surfaced over what prompted the win
  • Professor: "Idol" has become a "national obsession"
By Lisa Respers France
CNN
Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font

(CNN) -- Even "American Idol" winner Kris Allen couldn't believe it.

Kris Allen wasn't the only one stunned when he won "American Idol" 2009.

Kris Allen wasn't the only one stunned when he won "American Idol" 2009.

When Allen, the clean-cut guy from Arkansas, triumphed over the spiky-haired rocker Adam Lambert to win season eight of the competition, he seemed positively astounded.

So shocked was he that Allen's first words culminated into something that has never been heard in the history of the hit show before -- an acknowledgment that the runner-up "deserved to win."

Allen's surprise couldn't begin to match that of viewers. By trouncing the guy-liner wearing Goliath that was Lambert, Allen's win sent a shock wave through a nation of "Idol" worshippers.

"Adam was robbed!!!" Stefanie Lee posted on CNN's "American Idol" blog after the finale. "This proves beyond a shadow of a doubt that the public is incapable of voting for anyone based on anything objectively," Vincent Petrosino wrote.

Allen had been the dark horse all along, seemingly coming from nowhere to clinch the victory. Video Watch Allen best Lambert »

He was the low-key married guy with the acoustic guitar who few expected to seriously challenge glam rocker Lambert. Judges, celebrities and bloggers alike had all but anointed the charismatic performer the winner. Photo See photos from the finale »

Theories behind the upset abounded on the Internet: tween girls had texted their fingers off to push Allen and his cuteness over the top; speculation over Lambert's sexuality and his sometimes theatrical performances turned off middle America. Blog: What did you think of the result?

'Idol' performers on 'Larry King'
"American Idol's" Adam and Kris join CNN's Larry King and take your questions!
Friday, 9 p.m. ET

Angry, die-hard Lambert supporters wondered if viewers had resented the assumption Lambert would win, if religious fans had galvanized to support Allen, who reportedly has done some missionary work, or if Allen had simply absorbed the supporters of Danny Gokey, who placed third on the show. Read Gokey's thoughts on the finale

And they questioned why, with reportedly almost 100 million votes cast, "American Idol" host Ryan Seacrest didn't announce how close -- or far -- the election had actually been.

"The fact that they didn't give [the vote tally] that separated them to me suggests that it wasn't close," said Brian Mansfield, who blogged about the show for USA Today.

Mansfield pointed out that when Gokey was eliminated, it was announced that only a million votes had separated Allen and Lambert to place them in the finale.

Don't Miss

Lambert as a contestant was extremely polarizing, Mansfield said.

"There were people that really loved Adam and there were people that really hated Adam and there weren't a whole lot of people in the middle," he said.

Vocal coach Heather Kent said she was shocked that Lambert wasn't able to pull off the win. Video Watch the shock surrounding the finale »

"I was crazy about Adam Lambert," said Kent, who runs a vocal studio in Boston, Massachusetts, and has worked with many artists in musical theater. "He was very polished and the voice itself was stellar."

Elayne Rapping, a professor of American Studies at the University of Buffalo and pop-culture expert, said that "Idol" -- which is about to top the Nielsen ratings for the fifth straight season -- has become "a national obsession in the same way that maybe baseball used to be or the Super Bowl."

"People really take it seriously," she said. "They watch it and they are very emotionally involved in it."

That emotion was high on CNN's "Idol" blog. Some posting vowed to "never watch the show again." Some compared the upset to the wins of past "Idols," such as Ruben Studdard and Taylor Hicks, who have struggled to find the success that some of the runner-ups have.

But Allen fans were thrilled that their contestant won.

Nate wrote, "America got it completely right." Jon in Texas wrote, "Like I said weeks ago, Kris is the most 'radio ready' of this season and that's what this competition is about ..."

The announcement of the winner wasn't the only surprise of the night.

Performers as diverse as KISS, the Black Eyed Peas and Steve Martin were on hand to thrill the crowd. Video Watch the stars arrive on the red carpet »

Beleaguered judge Kara DioGuardi shocked the audience when she flashed a skimpy bathing suit after singing Mariah Carey's "Vision of Love" during a skit that pitted her against a former aspiring contestant known as "Bikini Girl."

Allen and Lambert appeared tired yet buoyant as they enjoyed knockout performance pairings: Allen with Keith Urban, Lambert with KISS and the pair with Queen.

The competitors, who were roommates early on in the "Idol" mansion where contestants stay, are friends who have had nothing but praise for each other throughout the season. Visit AmericanIdol.com to learn more about them

That continued after the finale as Lambert was gracious in defeat.

"I knew it was going to be a close race," Lambert told the news media. "I think Kris is incredibly talented and he's a good person. We got to do a really cool finale and we're both going to get to do great things in the future so for me it's not really about what happened tonight, it's about tomorrow, it's about next."

Allen said he was "exhausted and shocked" and looked forward to now being able to see his wife of less than a year more often.

Lambert, Allen said, is an "amazing, amazing performer" who "deserves this as much as I do."

But there can only be one "American Idol" at a time, and Allen sounded ready to take his place in "Idol" history.

advertisement

"Adam does his thing and I'm going to do mine," Allen said. "That's what I've done through the whole competition and I think it worked."

Allen and Lambert are scheduled to appear Friday on CNN's "Larry King Live" and viewers can post questions for them on Facebook.

All About American IdolKris AllenAdam LambertTelevision

  • E-mail
  • Save
  • Print