Skip to main content

Borger: Q&A session showed Obama engaging opponents

  • Story Highlights
  • Obama hosts unusual Q&A session with governors, congressional members
  • Borger: White House wanted public to see President Obama was engaged
  • Session was intended to let public see complexities of budget-cutting, Borger says
  • Obama made clear majority will be "inclusive," but minority has to be "constructive"
  • Next Article in Politics »
By Gloria Borger
CNN Senior Political Analyst
Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font

WASHINGTON (CNN) -- Sure, it was a tad hokey and staged. After members of Congress and assorted good government-types participated in the "fiscal responsibility" summit at the White House, President Obama took their questions.

Rep. Steny Hoyer, D-Maryland, speaks after Obama called on him at the fiscal summit's closing session.

Rep. Steny Hoyer, D-Maryland, speaks after Obama called on him at the fiscal summit's closing session.

Calling first on Sen. John McCain, the new president was almost scolded and told his new fleet of helicopters will cost "as much as Air Force One."

Obama, however, was quick to agree: "My helicopter now seems perfectly adequate to me." Of course, he added, "I've never had a helicopter before." The audience loved it.

All of which was the point, at least from the White House point of view: Open up this session, let the president take questions. Let the voters see he's engaged on the cutting side of the budget as well as on the spending side.

After all, this administration is facing a $1.5 trillion budget deficit in 2010, a figure that is more than 8 percent of the gross domestic product. It's downright scary. Video Watch Obama and McCain's exchange »

But there was more to this open session, and it wasn't about the numbers. It was about the tone of the presidency, about opening up the doors of the White House and the lifting of the veil on how government works (or doesn't) work.

Presidential Address
Join the Best Political Team on TV as President Obama makes his first address to Congress.
Tuesday, 9 p.m. ET on CNN

And no matter how polite, it was refreshing to watch an American president engage his opponents, much as a British prime minister does in his parliamentary question-and-answer sessions. After all, we're used to the rat-a-tat-tat of campaign engagements; this intellectual discourse is going to require some adjustment.

Campaigns are for bumper-sticker solutions. This session was all about letting the public in on the complexities of budget-cutting, or rescuing Social Security or expanding health care.

So questions were taken about the need for Congress to have the will (and the courage) to take on sacrosanct entitlement programs such as Social Security or Medicare.

Some even mentioned the need to (gulp) raise taxes to solve some of these problems.

The president announced an upcoming health-care summit -- a key indication he believes that the growth in the cost of health care is a giant problem that will stunt economic recovery.

Indeed, as a senior White House adviser tells me, "Fixing health care is the single biggest thing we can do to improve our economic picture."

So Obama is letting the public in on the secret. These are tough problems, made tougher because we're spending ourselves into a huge hole now trying to dig ourselves out of this recession. Video Watch Obama respond to governors who say they'll pass on parts of stimulus »

And speaking of tough, Obama also made it clear he's still reaching out -- to a point. The majority is willing to be "inclusive," he said, but that means the minority also has to be "constructive."

So the president has set the table. Never mind that some conservative Republican governors have decided to reject small parts -- emphasis on small -- of his economic stimulus money because of the federal strings attached. Never mind that House Republicans have rejected his stimulus package unanimously. Watch Gov. Bobby Jindal describe his problems with stimulus Video


Obama will keep talking, both to the GOP and to the American public. At some point, the voters will get to decide who is being more constructive.

My bet is they go with the fellow who at least looks like he's trying to solve their problems.

All About Barack ObamaRepublican PartyEconomic StimulusJohn McCain

  • E-mail
  • Save
  • Print