Skip to main content

Good vs. bad compromise in love

By Karen Salmansohn,
There are bad ways to compromise in a relationship.
There are bad ways to compromise in a relationship.
  • It's NOT always a good thing to compromise in a relationship, author says
  • She gave up yoga and looking attractive to please an old boyfriend
  • Says when a compromise hampers your ability to thrive or be authentic, it's bad
  • Relationships
  • Dating
  • Romance

(OPRAH.COM) -- About a decade ago, I dated a guy who every time his name was mentioned, inspired my girlfriends to sing the theme song to Batman.

Not because this man looked great in black Spandex tights. No, no. It was because he was a bad man.

"Dadadadadadada Bad-man! Bad-man!" my girlfriends would sing, right after I'd finish telling a particularly bad Bad-man episode -- of which there were many.

What made him a Dadadadadadada Bad-man? I'll call him Bruce Wayne to protect his not-so-innocent secret identity.

Bruce Wayne didn't want me to attend my favorite morning yoga classes. He explained he did not want anything -- other than himself -- to bring me morning pleasure. So I stopped going (to make him happy and relaxed) and began drinking red wine (which made me happy and relaxed instead).

I remember when I first confessed this "compromise" to my girlfriends, I did so as a joke. I said, "Can't make it to your favorite morning yoga classes?" while holding up a glass of Cabernet. "Try yoga in a glass! Same relaxing effects, only faster, more convenient and it won't upset boyfriends." Why men do crazy things

My girlfriends would all shake their heads in disapproval. "I can't believe you're giving up your beloved Jivamukti!"

Next up was Bruce Wayne's request for a wardrobe change. "I prefer you stop dressing in anything sexy," Bruce Wayne scolded. "It makes me think you're interested in meeting other men."

For the record: I wasn't. I like to dress sexy to feel sexy for me and my man. Kaput. But while dating Bruce Wayne, I entered into what I refer to as "My Amish Girl Period." Basically, turtlenecks became a staple throughout all four seasons.

Next were Bruce Wayne's objections to my hair. At that time, I had a wild, shoulder-length, thick and manic mane of wavy hair which everyone complimented except Bruce Wayne, who seemed to have a Samson-and-Delilah reaction to this mane o' mine. He felt my hair gave me too much power over men. Somehow Bruce Wayne convinced me to cut my hair to a non-threatening earlobe length.

"If you ask me," one girlfriend told me. "You're not involved in a relationship. It's a hazing experience."

When I look back now on this relationship, it's clear how Bruce Wayne is a good example of a man who asks for "bad compromise." The kind of compromise which demands compromising your soul and your authentic self. How to be your authentic self

Looking back I'm surprised how this old me (who I suppose is really the young me) would bend so radically to please a guy, even giving up bending myself into my favorite yogi poses.

Happily, the new me (who I suppose is the old me) knows better. The new old me can clearly see how there's a huge difference between "bad compromise" and "good compromise" in a relationship.

What makes for this difference?

• A "bad compromise" is changing your habits and self in such a way that you wind up becoming less of your full, authentic, thriving self.

• A "good compromise" is changing your habits and self in such a way that you grow more into your most full, authentic, best self

In my book "Prince Harming Syndrome," I offer some interesting love advice from Aristotle who explains that the reason why so many people are unhappy in life is because they choose mates simply for pleasure or utility. In other words, mates who are only sex-mates, ego-mates and/or wallet-mates. Are you dating a Prince Harming?

Real-deal love happiness, according to Aristotle, comes from being involved in "a relationship of shared virtue," where you pick a mate who gets you at your core and lovingly inspires, challenges and supports you to become your best possible soul self.

"A relationship of shared virtue," therefore, is when you and your partner both welcome putting up with the temporary pain of personal change for the greater gain of personal growth -- or what Aristotle calls "the education of the soul."

According to Aristotle, this personal growth or "education of the soul" is definitely worth developing because every time you put forth the effort to stretch and strengthen your soul, you increase your overall happiness. Basically, he believed that true happiness comes from surrounding yourself with people, habits and experiences which help you grow into your best possible self.

With all this in mind, putting in the work of "good compromise" is a positive way to ensure you're stretching and strengthening your soul so you can grow into your best possible self and increase your overall happiness.

What is a good compromise? Here are some examples in action:

• When one partner requests the other to attempt to be a little neater or more organized.

• When one partner requests the other to take better care of their health and fitness.

• When one partner requests the other try to be a more direct communicator and to speak up more often. When one partner requests the other to speak less and listen more.

Or, to sum up "good compromise" in a highly memorable movie line, it's when Jack Nicholson's character in As Good As It Gets says to Helen Hunt's character: "You make me want to be a better man."

Are you right now wondering whether a specific compromise request is a good compromise or bad compromise? If so, I want you take some time to quiet your mind and meditate on this question. Breathe in love, breathe out fear. Breathe in growth, breathe out stagnation.

Now ask yourself the following two questions:

1. Will this compromise request lead to someone compromising their authentic self -- their purpose for being here and their spirit's fiery flame of passion? Is this compromise request trying to add far too much "obey" into that "love, honor and obey" relationship formula? If so, this is a bad compromise.

2. Will this compromise request help empower someone's authentic self in order to boost them to become a better man or woman (as Jack Nicholson's character so succinctly put it)? If so, this is a good compromise.

Thankfully, the old me is now happily involved in a "relationship of shared virtue" which only involves good compromise. So, if you haven't seen me in my favorite morning yoga class lately, please know that I only have myself to blame!

The good news is: The new old me is now getting older and wiser.

The bad news is: The new old me is getting older and wider as well!

Karen Salmansohn is a best-selling author known for creating self-help for people who wouldn't be caught dead reading self-help. Get more information on finding a loving, happier-ever-after relationship in her book "Prince Harming Syndrome."

Subscribe to O, The Oprah Magazine for up to 75% off the newsstand price. That's like getting 18 issues FREE. Subscribe now!

TM & © 2011 Harpo Productions, Inc. All Rights Reserved.