Skip to main content

Bodies floating off Florida Keys baffle authorities

  • Story Highlights
  • Dead men found floating in ocean off Florida carried no ID
  • Authorities believe that the men started out together
  • Their bodies were found along a 30-mile stretch of the Florida Keys
  • Authorities were able to get fingerprints from two of the bodies
  • Next Article in Crime »
  • Read
  • MAP
By Patrick Oppmann
Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font

MIAMI, Florida (CNN) -- Currents, tides and Tropical Storm Fay scattered the bodies over 30 miles along the Florida Keys in just a few days.

One of the four bodies found last week was floating off this stretch of Plantation Key.

The only thing the authorities in the Keys can say for sure is that four corpses were found floating offshore a week ago. The men carried no identification, said the Monroe County Sheriff's Office, which is investigating.

Authorities believe that the men started out together, perhaps on the same boat. But it will not be easy to determine who they were, much less how they wound up in the water, where they may have spent three days. Their bodies showed signs that sharks had fed on them.

Were they migrants who died trying to reach the United States? Victims of Tropical Storm Fay? Or the body count from a vendetta among drug smugglers?

"The possibilities are pretty wide open at this point," said Becky Herrin, the sheriff's spokeswoman.

Mysterious doings are nothing new for the Florida Keys, an island chain at the state's southern tip.

Illegal immigants from Cuba are regularly found waiting for a ride to Miami by the side of the 110-mile-long road that links the southern tip of the United States with the mainland.

Hundreds of people each year are brought in by paid smugglers piloting go-fast boats. Cubans who make it to dry land are permitted to stay because of a special immigration status granted to them under the so-called wet foot/dry foot policy.

Despite a crackdown on human smuggling, the Coast Guard says, the traffic is still busy.

Drug runners could be another connection. Over the years, smuggling has became so commonplace that a watering hole on Cudjoe Key is named the "Square Grouper" - a term for bales of marijuana thrown overboard from traffickers' boats and planes.

About 50 miles up the road, a lobsterman saw something floating on Thursday. It was not a drug load but a body. Deputies described the dead man as a white male, 5 feet, 10 inches tall and appearing stocky. He had dark hair about 2 to 3 inches long. Authorities said the man was wearing "a distinctive ring" on his left hand but are not releasing details.

"Detectives are using that information to weed out the missing person calls coming in," Herrin said.

The next day, Friday, a family snorkeling along a reef near Indian Key came across a second body in the water, said Florida Fish and Wildlife Officer Bobby Dube. The family called 911 from a cell phone in their boat.

The man authorities brought out of the water was described as about 5 feet, 7 inches tall, slim and having reddish-brown hair about 6 to 8 inches in length.

Hours later, two more men were found floating off the upper Keys. One man was 5 feet, 7 inches. The other was 5 feet, 10 inches, investigators said, with 4-inch-long black hair. He had what police described as a "distinctive tattoo."

Even though the bodies were found along a 30-mile stretch of the Keys, investigators believe that they may have been together initially.

Tropical Storm Fay's winds were lashing the Keys around the same time the men were believed to have gone into the water, Herrin said. The winds and resulting currents could have dispersed the bodies across the Keys.

For two days, the Coast Guard searched the waters off the Keys with a helicopter, a jet plane and boats, looking for other bodies, survivors, sunken boats or other signs that would tell them where the men came from, said Petty Officer Jennifer Johnson. They found nothing. See where the bodies were found »

An autopsy by the Miami-Dade Medical Examiner's office was unable to determine the men's ages or cause of death. There were, however, no signs of trauma other than that inflicted by "marine life," said a statement released by the sheriff's office.

"There may have been more evidence," Herrin said, "had there been more of the bodies."

Investigators, she added, were able to get fingerprints from two of the bodies. Those fingerprints are being run through law enforcement databases now, Herrin said. Investigators are hopeful that someone who knows that the two men are missing will come forward.

"Somebody is missing them," she said.


None of the calls from people who think they know the men has yielded a match. If no-one comes forward to identify them, the bodies will be buried in graves that Florida reserves for the poor and unidentified.

Anyone with information about the four dead men is asked to call the Monroe County Sheriff's Office at 305-289-2410.

All About Florida KeysMonroe County

  • E-mail
  • Save
  • Print