Skip to main content
Entertainment Weekly

EW review: Pointless 'Daughter'

Also: Terrific 'Lapham Rising'

By Jennifer Reese
Entertainment Weekly



Maile Meloy
Roger Rosenblatt

(Entertainment Weekly) -- In her lovely and rhapsodically received 2003 debut novel, "Liars and Saints," Maile Meloy offered a sparkling contemporary revamp of that ponderous literary relic: the multigenerational family saga.

With her smooth, elliptical account of the Santerre clan -- presided over by guilt-plagued Catholic matriarch Yvette and her laconic husband, Teddy -- Meloy covered 50 years of Southern California domestic life, encompassing wildly divergent points of view and some genuinely shocking family secrets in an admirably economical 260 pages of honed, level-headed prose.

Readers charmed by the grace and simplicity of "Liars and Saints" may approach its sequel, a metafictional reworking of the same material, with dismay.

Once again, Meloy unspools the story of the Santerres, but in "A Family Daughter" everything seems slightly -- and sometimes not so slightly -- askew. If it's been a few years since you read "Liars and Saints," you may wonder if your memory is playing tricks. It's not. Meloy's perplexing new book is intended as the "real" story of the Santerres, before (and after) one of them adapts the family history into a novel: "Liars and Saints."

The Santerre family author is Abby, grandchild of Yvette and Teddy, neglected daughter of flaky sometime lesbian Clarissa, and incestuous lover of uncle Jamie (Clarissa's brother). In a memorable "Liars and Saints" seduction scene, Jamie woos virginal Abby on a moonlit Santa Barbara beach just outside the club where Yvette and Teddy are celebrating their 50th wedding anniversary, a momentous one-time liaison that Meloy makes both troubling and tender, and which leaves Abby pregnant. In the new version, a sexually experienced Abby initiates the affair in the hall of her student apartment, and the tetchy relationship continues, off and on, indefinitely.

Abby does not become pregnant, nor does she die of cancer shortly after giving birth to Jamie's son, as she does in "Liars and Saints." Instead, Abby begins working on a novel, weaving together scandalous bits of her biography with wild guesses about her family history and outright inventions (like her own death), twisting and embellishing the raw stuff of life, as novelists -- and, sadly, some memoirists -- do. Her relatives read her manuscript with understandable trepidation, and the volume begins to play an unpredictable role in their lives, sparking at least one affair and leading inadvertently to a death.

But Meloy is not an idea-driven novelist, and rather than teasing out the provocative questions she raises about the relationship of fiction to life, she turns compulsively back to human-scale narrative -- in this case not all of it of the highest quality.

Since the Santerres' best tales were crystallized in "Liars and Saints," she pads the sequel with soapy subplots and an ever-expanding web of random new characters, among them a spoiled seductress named Saffron, a conniving Hungarian prostitute, and an ex-beauty dying on an Argentinean ranch. She may have rigged up a mighty clever postmodern game, but she's written a mediocre sudsy melodrama.

EW Grade: B-

'Lapham Rising,' Roger Rosenblatt

Reviewed by Rebecca Ascher-Walsh

From the moment nihilistic writer Harry March awakens in his home in the Hamptons, that New York summer refuge, only to be bitten in the ear by his talking West Highland terrier, it's clear that our hero is not in a good place.

Roger Rosenblatt's uproarious debut, "Lapham Rising," unfolds over one day as March tries to halt construction of a neighboring McMansion and ignore his wisecracking dog, who wants to go to business school. "One reason I became a writer is that a writer's connections with people are made at long distance," March explains. "I would seek therapy, but I do not want to connect with an analyst."

Infusing a miserable, eccentric grouch with such humanity is a true feat; Rosenblatt wields his satiric saber with skill and compassion.

EW Grade: A-

Click Hereexternal link to Try 2 RISK FREE issues of Entertainment Weekly

Story Tools
Subscribe to Time for $1.99 cover
Top Stories
Get up-to-the minute news from CNN gives you the latest stories and video from the around the world, with in-depth coverage of U.S. news, politics, entertainment, health, crime, tech and more.
Top Stories
Get up-to-the minute news from CNN gives you the latest stories and video from the around the world, with in-depth coverage of U.S. news, politics, entertainment, health, crime, tech and more.

© 2007 Cable News Network.
A Time Warner Company. All Rights Reserved.
Terms under which this service is provided to you.
Read our privacy guidelines. Contact us. Site Map.
Offsite Icon External sites open in new window; not endorsed by
Pipeline Icon Pay service with live and archived video. Learn more
Radio News Icon Download audio news  |  RSS Feed Add RSS headlines