Skip to main content
Inside Politics
CNN Europe CNN Asia
On CNN TV Transcripts Headline News CNN International About Preferences
powered by Yahoo!
Robert Novak is a nationally syndicated columnist.

Mary Landrieu's dilemma

By Robert D. Novak
Creators Syndicate

Story Tools

WASHINGTON (Creators Syndicate) -- Ever since her disputed election to the U.S. Senate from Louisiana six years ago, Mary Landrieu has nimbly performed the dance favored these days by many Southern Democrats seeking statewide office: voting liberal and talking conservative.

Thanks to her state's baroque election laws, however, she may trip in quest of a second term.

Sen. Landrieu campaigned as George W. Bush's best friend in Louisiana's November 5 election against three Republican opponents, but failed to reach the 50 percent needed for election, thanks to an anemic African-American turnout.

Now, with the White House mobilized behind Republican Suzanne Haik Terrell, Landrieu has to appeal to black voters without alienating her white support. Writ large in Louisiana, this is the dilemma faced by Landrieu's Southern colleagues.

When I arrived in Washington in 1957, all 22 U.S. Senate seats from the states of the old Confederacy were held by Democrats (as they had been for nearly a century since Reconstruction). Now, in the new Congress, only eight of these senators will be Democrats. Landrieu's possible fall would make it seven.

Just how difficult it is for Landrieu under campaign pressure was shown when she and Terrell appeared jointly on NBC's "Meet the Press" Sunday. Asked by moderator Tim Russert whether she would vote to make permanent President Bush's tax reduction, she went into denial: "I will vote to extend the tax cut if we can afford to do it, if our military doesn't need the money or Social Security."

Russert persisted, asking, "Can we afford it as we speak today?" "We can if we can get the economy going again," she replied. "But if we can't get this economy going as of today, can we afford it?" "I don't know what we can afford right now." When Russert asked the tax question a fourth time, she replied with a non sequitur: "This senator is not going to leave our guys in the middle of Afghanistan without the weapons they need or the support they need."

That Landrieu has been in the Senate the past six years is testimony to Louisiana's distinctive political hijinks. On Election Day 1996, mid-afternoon exit polls showed State Rep. Woody Jenkins with a clear advantage against Landrieu to become the state's first Republican senator of the 20th century.

Also threatened was local option for video poker and riverboat casinos. Gambling interests immediately dispatched a convoy of buses to New Orleans' predominantly black housing projects after 5 p.m. to recruit voters. The gambling industry saved itself and Mary Landrieu. Landrieu in the Senate attached herself to the state's senior senator, Democrat John Breaux.

In fact, she followed a risky course unlike her famously clever colleague's. While sounding like Bill Clinton on television talk shows, Breaux hugs the middle of the road -- rated 55 percent by the liberal Americans for Democratic Action (ADA) and 48 percent by the American Conservative Union (ACU). In contrast, Landrieu adopted moderate rhetoric while voting 85 percent liberal (ADA) and 28 percent conservative (ACU).

Their divided votes on some 200 issues are even more vivid. A small sample: Prohibit federal funding of abortion: Landrieu, no; Breaux, yes. Mandatory trigger locks: Landrieu, yes; Breaux, no. Broad prescription drug coverage under Medicare: Landrieu, yes; Breaux, no. Federal funding for school distribution of "morning after" pills: Landrieu, yes; Breaux, no. While Landrieu repeatedly declared her support for the president prior to November 5, she was seldom there when Bush needed her.

She voted against confirmation of John Ashcroft as attorney general and Theodore Olson as solicitor general, against school vouchers and against the Bush administration on a variety of budget questions, including caps on spending. Most recently, she was lined up with government workers unions to restrict presidential control over employees of the new Department of Homeland Security.

Nevertheless, on a key procedural vote Tuesday necessary for expedited passage of homeland security, Landrieu was one of only three Democrats (not including Breaux) to join the Republican phalanx. While desperate to generate African-American support on Dec. 7, she cannot alienate the 35 percent of the white vote that she needs. It's really hard being a Southern Democrat.

Click here for more from Creators Syndicate.

Story Tools

Top Stories
Panel: Spy agencies in dark about threats
Top Stories
CNN/Money: Security alert issued for 40 million credit cards
© 2004 Cable News Network LP, LLLP.
A Time Warner Company. All Rights Reserved.
Terms under which this service is provided to you.
Read our privacy guidelines. Contact us.
external link
All external sites will open in a new browser. does not endorse external sites.