Skip to main content
ad info

 
CNN.com technology > computing
    Editions | myCNN | Video | Audio | Headline News Brief | Feedback  

 

  Search
 
 

 
TECHNOLOGY
TOP STORIES

Consumer group: Online privacy protections fall short

Guide to a wired Super Bowl

Debate opens on making e-commerce law consistent

(MORE)

TOP STORIES

More than 11,000 killed in India quake

Mideast negotiators want to continue talks after Israeli elections

(MORE)

MARKETS
4:30pm ET, 4/16
144.70
8257.60
3.71
1394.72
10.90
879.91
 


WORLD

U.S.

POLITICS

LAW

ENTERTAINMENT

HEALTH

TRAVEL

FOOD

ARTS & STYLE



(MORE HEADLINES)
*
 
CNN Websites
Networks image


States seek sales-tax simplification

Computerworld

(IDG) -- A state-by-state legislative attack on the sales-tax advantage many Internet retailers now have over Main Street merchants will begin next year with a drive to simplify complex and sometimes bizarre sales-tax rules.

A group of tax and policy officials from some 39 states, meeting as the Streamlined Sales Tax Project, this month may finalize "model" tax simplification legislation for adoption by state legislatures. The state group posted the proposed legislation on its Web site.

This tax simplification, by itself, won't end the Internet's reputation as a sales-tax-free zone, but it would remove a major stumbling block to any agreement concerning online sales-tax collections. Congress isn't likely to support any national legislation unless many states -- especially large states -- first agree to simplify their tax rules, said Frank Shafroth, a policy expert at the National Governors Association in Washington and a participant in the project.

IDG.net INFOCENTER

IDG.net - IDG.net Multimedia & Leisure page
 - Free daily newsletter for tech-savvy professionals
 - Get instant answers from the Dummies Network
 - Computerworld's topic-oriented communities

Related IDG.net Stories
 Net-tax question takes center stage at Gartner ITXpo
 Does shopping online cheat your library?
 States missing out on billions in Internet sales taxes
Features
 - Scholars: e-mail reveals 'language of love'
 - Tech skills help blend work, home lives
 - Getting a degree from inside a cubicle
Visit an IDG site


IDG.net search



Many large retailers are supporting the action.

"The [Internet] pure plays are getting the benefit to build their business and their brand without having to pay the same sales tax that others do," said Robert Molloy, vice president and assistant general counsel at Staples in Framingham, Mass.

But Seth Geiger, who heads research at BizRate.com, a Los Angeles-based online retail performance comparison service, says its customer surveys show that the absence of sales taxes on invoices is a "perk" for many customers. Applying sales tax "will put a chilling effect on the growth" on Internet commerce, he said.

Shopping on the Internet isn't tax free, although it may seem that way. Under current law, retailers don't collect sales tax on a purchase unless they have a physical presence in the state where the buyer is located. The buyer still owes a "use tax" -- the equivalent sales tax -- but most people never pay it. State officials say they stand to lose billions in tax revenue as online sales increase.

However, online retailers and trade groups such as the Direct Marketing Association in New York say they can't consider broader tax-collection obligations unless tax requirements are simplified nationally. A small online retailer, in particular, could be buried in administrative cost if it had to comply with the laws of more than 7,000 state and local taxing district as well as dealing with odd rules that, for instance, exempt tea from sales tax in one state but tax herbal tea in another, these groups say.

The pressure for taxing online sales is certain to grow.

Consumer Internet spending reached $1.3 billion during Thanksgiving week, a 140% increase over 1999, according to a report issued last week by Goldman Sachs & and PC Data in Reston, Va. But consumer spending at specialty stores at physical malls was down 6.9% from last year for the same period, based on a sample of stores, according to the International Council of Shopping Centers in New York.

Council research director John Konarski blamed the economy and longer selling season for the shortfall, and said online sales -- which account for less than 1% of retail sales nationally, according to government figures (see story) -- are still having a minor impact. "But who knows where it is going," he said.

If online retailers have to collect sales taxes from all customers, it won't turn off customers, believes Albert Noyes, executive vice president of online retailer SmarterKids.com Inc. "I don't think sales tax savings are very evident for people online. In the end, they shop online for the value that the site can deliver and the efficiency," Noyes said.

The tax situation for SmarterKids may change next year. The Needham, Mass.-based company is merging with Earlychildhood.com in Monterey, Calif., which now collects taxes in 28 states, said Noyes.

The states involved in the Streamlined Sales Tax Project are also testing technologies in a pilot program with three vendors: Esalestax.com in Englewood, Colo.; Taxware International Inc. in Salem, Mass., and Pitney Bowes Inc. in Stamford, Conn.

Connected to a store's retail systems, these service providers calculate taxes on the final bill, as well as remit taxes to the states. If a state conducts an audit, it will examine the tax vendors' systems, not the retailers'. The vendors are paid a percentage of taxes collected, freeing retailers from the administrative burden, said Charles Collins, director of the sales and use tax division at the North Carolina Department of Revenue, one of four states participating in the project along with Kansas, Michigan and Wisconsin.

The goal is to combine tax simplification with technology that eliminates tax-processing burdens for retailers, Collins said.

Collins said the states are also investigating the possibility of certifying legacy tax system software typically used by larger companies, and freeing those companies from audits if their software meets certain standards.




RELATED STORIES:
EU postpones decision on online taxation
November 29, 2000
California governor vetoes Internet tax
September 27, 2000
California may pass state Internet sales tax
September 1, 2000
Report: China to tax e-commerce
August 4, 2000
Internet tax losses anyone's guess
July 27, 2000

RELATED IDG.net STORIES:
Net-tax question takes center stage at Gartner ITXpo
IDG.net
Does shopping online cheat your library?
PC World
States missing out on billions in Internet sales taxes
The Industry Standard
EU likely to impose taxes on digital deliveries
IDG.net
Priceline shoppers face taxing problem
PC World
House OKs new Net-tax moratorium
IDG.net
California may pass state Internet sales tax
IT world
Program aims to level sales tax playing field
IT world

RELATED SITES:
Streamlined Sales Tax Project
National Governors Association

Note: Pages will open in a new browser window
External sites are not endorsed by CNN Interactive.

 Search   

Back to the top  © 2001 Cable News Network. All Rights Reserved.
Terms under which this service is provided to you.
Read our privacy guidelines.