ad info  technology > computing
    Editions | myCNN | Video | Audio | Headline News Brief | Feedback  




Consumer group: Online privacy protections fall short

Guide to a wired Super Bowl

Debate opens on making e-commerce law consistent



More than 11,000 killed in India quake

Mideast negotiators want to continue talks after Israeli elections


4:30pm ET, 4/16










CNN Websites
Networks image

All the president's IT men


(IDG) -- Pop quiz: Which candidate said what about the new economy?

A."Every child in America - regardless of income, geography, race or disability - should be able to reach across a computer keyboard and reach the vast new worlds of knowledge, commerce and communication that are available at the touch of a fingertip."

B."Technology has brought so many opportunities into our lives. Now we must make sure that these opportunities are shared as widely as possible so that everyone can gain and everyone can contribute."

  CIO home page
  Net execs debate tech policy
  Bush and Gore downplay Internet issues
  Mixed views on presidential candidates
  Reviews & in-depth info at
  Questions about computers? Let's editors help you
  Darwin Magazine is here!
  Search in 12 languages
  News Radio
  * Fusion audio primers
  * Computerworld Minute

If you're having trouble answering, it's not because you haven't been paying attention. When it comes to IT policy, George W. Bush and Al Gore are reading from the same playbook. Though the two diverge on many details, Gore (A) and Bush (B) have similar stated goals for promoting e-commerce at home and abroad, training a tech-savvy workforce and spreading opportunity to the economy's have-nots. And the reason Gore and Bush sound alike is not just because, like all presidential hopefuls, they'll say just about anything they think will win them votes. The truth is their technology slogans and policies come from the same source: IT industry execs from vote-rich Texas and just-plain-rich Silicon Valley, along with their lobbyists in Washington, D.C.

So far, the candidates have been using those connections to drum up support and raise money. Later, however, when the candidate metamorphoses into the president, and the things he says will actually affect the way we live and do business, the power of those advisers will grow. Access is everything. After all, politics is all about how big a piece of the economic pie you get, and you're much more likely to get a bigger slice if you know someone (or you know someone who knows someone) who's handing the chief executive the knife.

Choosing Sides

Who will have the next president's ear? For Gore, it's a mix of old friends and new political allies. His inner circle of IT advisers is a tightly knit fraternity mostly made up of people who have held important staff or political posts during Gore's 23 years in elected office. As lawyers, lobbyists or corporate executives, almost all once worked or are currently employed by high-tech companies.

Bush, newer to public service than Gore, is closest to an alliance of high-tech executives he has courted ever since winning the Texas governorship in 1994. Most of them are also relatively new to politics, becoming active in the past decade as government began debating how much to regulate technology and the Internet. Bush's IT team is drawn mainly from the board of TechNet, a bipartisan industry lobbying group that also has members supporting Gore. Both Bush and Gore count among their starting IT lineup partners from Silicon Valley's hottest venture capital organization, Kleiner, Perkins, Caufield & Byers.

Campaign veterans maintain that these high-tech honchos don't call the shots. A web of advisers to both campaigns, on everything from education to national security, gets to weigh in before its candidate decides whether to wire more schools or ease export controls.

"With the significant changes in our economy, technology issues are a part and parcel of every domestic area; they're not just a separate issue," says Stephen Goldsmith, a former mayor of Indianapolis who is Bush's chief domestic policy adviser. "They are part of changing the way we look at [the] environment, part of the way we fight crime and part of the way we reform government. There have been individuals the campaign has sought for specialty issues like taxation on the Internet or privacy, where there are interesting and complicated questions. But as a rule, the technology issues cut horizontally across every area."

Ditto for Gore. "IT policy is in no way an isolated thing for him. It's woven into every decision," says Jim Kohlenberger, the vice president's senior domestic policy adviser in the White House, who is helping the campaign in his off-hours.

Still, thanks to its money, high profile and money, when it comes to broad issues like education, trade and tax policy, the IT industry's agenda matters.

There's a level at which that's hardly worth mentioning. The IT business is business, and ideas like smoothing the way for more exports to China and making sure students leave high school computer literate probably mean much the same whether your company makes modems or soft drinks. But if the president is, say, negotiating to waive tariffs on Internet purchases, which in turn affects your supply chain or sales strategy, one policy may not fit all. That's when having access, or knowing someone who does, becomes important.

Although both Bush and Gore have met with dozens, maybe hundreds, of technology experts during the past few years in preparation for their campaigns, the political advisers profiled here are the ones who are most involved week to week in helping the candidates shape their IT policy. If you know one of them, you might get to know the president too.

The Gore Gang

  • Reed Hundt Senior Adviser, McKinsey & Co.

  • Roy Neel President and CEO, U.S. Telecommunications Association (on leave)

  • John Doerr Partner, Kleiner, Perkins, Caufield & Byers

  • Greg Simon President/CEO, Simon Strategies (on leave)

  • Jim Kohlenberger Senior Domestic Policy Adviser

  • Morley Winograd Director, National Partnership for Reinventing Government

  • The Bush Bunch

  • Michael Dell CEO, Dell Computer Corp.

  • James Barksdale Managing Partner, The Barksdale Group

  • Robert Herbold Executive Vice President and COO, Microsoft Corp.

  • John Chambers President/CEO Cisco Systems

  • Steven Papermaster CEO, Agillion

  • E. Floyd Kvamme Partner, Kleiner, Perkins, Caufield & Byers

    Tech issues kept mainly offstage in campaign 2000
    October 11, 2000
    GOP legislators: Schools filter Web -- or no Net funds
    October 19, 2000
    U.S. presidential candidates debate Napster online
    October 19, 2000
    Reform Party online balloting thwarts hackers
    August 17, 2000
    Analysis: Are instant Internet polls worthwhile?
    August 17, 2000
    Lieberman seen as boost to IT ticket
    August 10, 2000

    Presidential hopefuls wrangle over Napster on Web
    Techies: Vote Gore! No, Bush!
    (The Industry Standard)
    ITxpo : Lieberman says IT should police itself
    Al Gore: The early adopter
    (The Industry Standard)
    Mixed views on presidential candidates
    Opinion: Bush vs. Gore on the Internet Economy
    (The Industry Standard)
    Bush and Gore downplay Internet issues
    (The Industry Standard)
    Net execs debate tech policy
    (NW Fusion)

    Read about the Gore Gang
    Read about the Bush Bunch
    Gore on the Internet and technology
    (from the official campaign site)
    Bush on technology and the new economy
    (from the official campaign site)

    Note: Pages will open in a new browser window
    External sites are not endorsed by CNN Interactive.


    Back to the top   © 2001 Cable News Network. All Rights Reserved.
    Terms under which this service is provided to you.
    Read our privacy guidelines.