Skip to main content
ad info

Local
  Editions | myCNN | Video | Audio | Headline News Brief | Feedback

 

  Search
 
 

 
LOCAL
TOP STORIES

Tempe cuts off Scouts

Phillips facing fine for fatal plant blast

Judge: City guilty of denying AIDS patients benefits

Bilingual ed must go, Ariz. voters say in poll

Tempers flare over smog plan

Stadium price tag causes stir

(MORE)

TOP STORIES

6 Palestinians killed in West Bank

Gore, Bush roll out gags at $900,000 fund-raiser

Yemen's president says break is near in Cole case

(MORE)

 

  Search
 
 

 
LOCAL
TOP STORIES

Tempe cuts off Scouts

Phillips facing fine for fatal plant blast

Judge: City guilty of denying AIDS patients benefits

Bilingual ed must go, Ariz. voters say in poll

Tempers flare over smog plan

Stadium price tag causes stir

(MORE)

TOP STORIES

6 Palestinians killed in West Bank

Gore, Bush roll out gags at $900,000 fund-raiser

Yemen's president says break is near in Cole case

(MORE)

MARKETS
4:30pm ET, 4/16
144.70
8257.60
3.71
1394.72
10.90
879.91
 


WORLD

U.S.

POLITICS

LAW

TECHNOLOGY

ENTERTAINMENT

HEALTH

TRAVEL

FOOD

ARTS & STYLE



(MORE HEADLINES)
*

 
CNN Websites
Networks image


Bilingual ed must go, Ariz. voters say in poll

By Robbie Sherwood and Lisa Chiu
The Arizona Republic Online
September 22, 2000
Web posted at: 11:46 AM EDT (1546 GMT)

PHOENIX, Arizona (The Arizona Republic Online) -- Nearly three-quarters of Arizona voters favor dismantling the state's bilingual education system and replacing it with English immersion programs, according to an Arizona Republic poll.

Proposition 203 will be decided Nov. 7, but if the election were held today, 74 percent of the state's voters would approve the measure. Silicon Valley entrepreneur Ron Unz, who is financing the Arizona campaign after backing a successful movement to end bilingual education in California two years ago, called the poll results "absolutely remarkable."

"I can't believe the numbers on Election Day will be as high as that, but it's certainly very encouraging," said Unz, who was in Phoenix on Thursday campaigning for the proposition. "That says that ordinary people, regardless of ideology and ethnicity, believe children should be taught English when they are sent to school."

Unz said the measure passed by 61 percent in California, and he pointed to gains by immigrant students on recent test scores as proof the movement is working.

More from The Arizona Republic Online
Tempe cuts off Scouts

Scottsdale scoffs at arena plan

Gun law baffles police, cities

Back to drawing board

Jobs

Poll respondent Miguel Gonzalez, a sanitation truck driver in the border town of San Luis near Yuma, said he definitely will vote to end bilingual education. He came to Arizona from Mexico with his parents when he was 3, and said the only way to succeed in this country is to learn English and learn it quickly.

"Back in those days there were no bilingual classes; they threw you in the pool and you had to learn to swim," said Gonzalez, 39. "I'm not against bilingual classes, but you have to learn English first. They are not going to lose their basic language, because they hear it in their home. I learned English and I still speak Spanish."

State Sen. Joe Eddie Lopez, D-south Phoenix, an opponent of Proposition 203, took issue with the poll's question, which he said led respondents to believe a viable alternative awaits if they reject bilingual education. The 602 respondents contacted by pollsters were asked, "Do you favor or oppose the requirement that all public school instruction be conducted in English and that an intensive one-year English immersion program be established to teach English as quickly as possible to students for which English is not their first language?"

Said Lopez: "The issue gets lost when we suggest there is a program out there that is more effective than bilingual education, and that is what is making people respond like that. When I explain to people that bilingual education outperforms immersion programs in Arizona, they change their minds about that."

Unz and the fight against bilingual education gained a new ally Thursday in Rep. Laura Knaperek, R-Tempe. Knaperek has tried unsuccessfully in the Legislature to limit the number of years bilingual education is provided, but threw in her support after hearing about California's test results.

"I usually don't support initiatives because I feel like that's something that should come out of the Legislature. Unfortunately you'll see this issue is too political to really make some reform that's needed," Knaperek said during a news conference at the Capitol on Thursday. "Arizona's dropout rate is 11 percent and they are mostly minority children. We want children to be successful, and English is the language of success."

A small group of supporters held signs at the news conference that said, "English for the Children," while other signs said the same thing in Spanish, "Inglés para los Niños." The Spanish signs show the proposition isn't against the Spanish language, said Margaret Garcia Dugan, principal of a high school in Glendale. Rather, she said, it's in favor of English immersion.

Lopez said he was surprised to learn of Knaperek's support of the initiative because she had favored local school district control in the past. Knaperek denies this.

"Now she's changing her mind completely, evidently when it comes to minority kids, Laura changes her mind as far as local control is concerned," Lopez said.

Proposition 203 is favored most strongly by Republicans at 82 percent, according to the poll, but it resonated strongly among Democrats, as well, at 63 percent. There was a sharp divide in the way voters in Maricopa County (79 percent in favor) felt about the issue compared with those in Pima County (59 percent in favor.)

For poll respondent Deborah Fitchie of Phoenix, the issue is simple. She believes in being bilingual, and has spent years learning and using Spanish.

But mandatory bilingual education has got to go, she said.

"In order for students to get the best education they can get, they need to learn English as soon as possible," said Fitchie, who owns a construction business with her husband.

Fitchie said about 30 percent of her workers are Hispanic, and those who don't learn English simply cannot be promoted.

"When you do commercial construction there are plans you must be able to read and they are not in Spanish," she said. "It really hinders people when they are not able to speak English."

The poll was conducted Sept. 14 through Monday by the Analytical Group, for The Arizona Republic. It has a margin of error of plus or minus 4 percent.



RELATED STORIES:
For more Local news, myCNN.com will bring you news from the areas and subjects you select.


More Arizona Resources:
  KOLD Arizona
  KPHO Arizona
  KTVK Arizona
  KUTP Arizona
  KVOA Arizona

CNN/SI City pages:
  Phoenix, AZ
  Tempe, AZ
  Tucson, AZ


  AZ, Phoenix, KPHO
AZ, Phoenix, KTVK
AZ, Phoenix, KUTP
AZ, Tuscon, KOLD
AZ, Tucson, KVOA
CA, Eureka, KIEM
CA, Fresno, KJEO
CA, Fresno, KSEE
CA, Los Angeles, KCAL
CA, Los Angeles, KCBS
  CA, Los Angeles, KCOP
CA, Los Angeles, KTLA
CA, Monterey, KSBW
CA, Oakland, KTVU
CA, San Diego, KSWB
CA, San Francisco, KBHK
CA, San Francisco, KBWB
CA, San Francisco, KPIX
CA, San Jose, KICU
CA, San Jose, KNTV
HI, Honolulu, KHON
  NV, Las Vegas, KVVU
NV, Reno, KOLO
OR, Eugene, KVAL
OR, Medford, KTVL
UT, Salt Lake City, KSL
WA, Seattle, KIRO
WA, Seattle, NWCN
WA, Seattle-Tacoma, KCPQ
WA, Spokane, KXLY
ID, Twin Falls, KMVT
NV, Las Vegas, KTNV
 
 
 Search   


Back to the top  © 2001 Cable News Network. All Rights Reserved.
Terms under which this service is provided to you.
Read our privacy guidelines.