Skip to main content
ad info

 
Greta@LAW
CNN.com  law center > news
trials and cases
open forum
law library
  Editions | myCNN | Video | Audio | Headline News Brief | Feedback  

 

  Search
 
 

 
LAW
TOP STORIES

Prosecutor says witnesses saw rap star shoot gun in club

Embassy bombing defendants' confessions admissible, says U.S. Judge

Excerpt: John Grisham's 'A Painted House'

(MORE)

TOP STORIES

Bush signs order opening 'faith-based' charity office for business

Rescues continue 4 days after devastating India earthquake

DaimlerChrysler employees join rapidly swelling ranks of laid-off U.S. workers

Disney's GO.com is a goner

(MORE)

MARKETS
4:30pm ET, 4/16
144.70
8257.60
3.71
1394.72
10.90
879.91
 


WORLD

U.S.

POLITICS

TECHNOLOGY

ENTERTAINMENT

TRAVEL

ARTS & STYLE



(MORE HEADLINES)
*
 
CNN Websites
Networks image

find law dictionary
 

Scalia and Stevens clash over recount stay in Bush v. Gore

image
 

(CNN) -- By a narrow margin of 5-4, the justices of the U.S. Supreme Court halted the recount of Florida ballots ordered by the Florida Supreme Court and once again agreed to step into the Florida election dispute, setting oral arguments for Monday in the aptly-named case of George W. Bush v. Albert Gore.

At issue in the appeal is whether the Florida Supreme Court should have ordered a hand count of 9,000 disputed "undervote" ballots in Miami-Dade County, and ordered all counties with "undervotes" not previously manually counted, to count them by hand.

An "undervote" is a ballot on which no vote for president was detected by counting machines. In doing so, the Florida Supreme Court reversed a lower court ruling rejecting Gore's election contest appeal.

graphic  U.S. SUPREME COURT DOCUMENTS
Read the U.S. Supreme Court order granting a stay of recounts

Election-related filings

(These require Adobe Acrobat Reader)
 
graphic  RESOURCE
How the U.S. Supreme Court split
 
graphic  VIDEO
Comments from Ron Klain, Gore campaign legal adviser, and David Boies, Gore campaign attorney (December 9)

Play video
(QuickTime, Real or Windows Media)

Comments from James Baker, Observer for the Bush campaign (December 9)

Play video
(QuickTime, Real or Windows Media)

U.S. Sen. Barbara Boxer, D-California, emphasizes need to count every vote in Florida (November 9)

Play video
(QuickTime, Real or Windows Media)

Watch all up-to-the-minute video of Election 2000
 
graphic  INDEPTH
 
  LEGAL RESOURCES

Latest Legal News

Law Library

FindLaw Consumer Center

In issuing the stay, the U.S. Supreme Court split along familiar lines, with Chief Justice William Rehnquist and justices Clarence Thomas, Sandra Day O'Connor, Antonin Scalia and Anthony Kennedy concurring and justices John Paul Stevens, David H. Souter, Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Stephen Breyer dissenting.

In breaking with the majority, Justice Stevens wrote a forceful dissenting opinion in which he said, "Preventing the recount from being completed will inevitably cast a cloud on the legitimacy of the election." He continued, "(T)he Florida court's ruling reflects the basic principle, inherent in our Constitution and our democracy, that every legal vote should be counted."

Stevens' dissent prompted Justice Scalia to take the unusual step of issuing a concurring opinion in connection with the stay in which he responded, "The counting of votes that are of questionable legality does, in my view, threaten irreparable harm to petitioner [George W. Bush] and to the country, by casting a cloud upon what he claims to be the legitimacy of his election. Count first and rule upon legality afterwards, is not a recipe for producing election results that have the public acceptance that democratic stability requires."

In what may foreshadow the ultimate outcome of the case, Scalia also wrote. "It suffices to say that the issuance of the stay suggests that a majority of the Court, while not deciding the issues presented, believe that the petitioner has a substantial probability of success."

Bush v. Gore marks the second time the U.S. Supreme Court has agreed to review a case stemming from the Florida election dispute. On Monday, December 3, in Bush v. Palm Beach County Canvassing Board, the court vacated and remanded for further proceedings a Florida Supreme Court decision allowing manual vote recounts to proceed after a November 14 ballot-certification deadline set by that state's legislature.

In an unsigned, seven-page opinion, the U.S. Supreme Court sent the case back to Florida's seven justices so they could better explain the legal basis for their ruling extending the certification deadline to November 26.

The Florida Supreme Court had not revisited that case Friday when, in a 4-3 ruling, it reversed Leon County Circuit Judge N. Sanders Sauls who had rejected the vice president's contest of Florida's election results.

"Although in all elections, the Legislature and the courts have recognized that the voter's intent is paramount, in close elections, the necessity of counting all legal votes becomes critical," the majority wrote in its opinion.

In his dissent, Florida Supreme Court Chief Justice Charles Wells wrote, "The majority's decision to return this case to the circuit court ... has no foundation in the law of Florida," he wrote. "I have a deep and abiding concern that the prolonging of judicial process in this counting contest propels this country and this state into an unprecedented and unnecessary constitutional crisis."

Judicial process will be prolonged at least until Monday at 11 a.m. EST when the U.S. Supreme Court hears oral arguments in Bush v. Gore.



RESOURCES:
U.S. Constitution, Article II
14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution
1st Amendment to the U.S. Constitution
United States Code, Title 3, Section 5

RELATED STORIES:
Ballots where 'voter intent' is clear must be counted, Florida high court says
December 8, 2000
U.S. Supreme Court remands presidential election case to Florida's highest court
December 4, 2000
Minute by minute: How the U.S. Supreme Court hearing will proceed
November 30, 2000
Gore team asks Florida Supreme Court to speed recount
November 29, 2000
Bush, Gore U.S. Supreme Court briefs address constitutional questions
November 28, 2000
Vote certification does not stop legal fight
November 27, 2000
Constitutional scholars surprised by U.S. Supreme Court decision to hear Florida election case
November 24, 2000
Bush, Harris urge end to Florida recount; Gore seeks uniform standard
November 19, 2000
Gore asks Florida high court to set standards for recount
November 19, 2000
Presidential vote recounts yield few changes so far, officials say
November 19, 2000
Democrats protest exclusion of ballots in Palm Beach County
November 19, 2000
Lieberman says Dems not trying to block absentee ballots
November 19, 2000
Congress studying electoral college scenarios
November 19, 2000
Bush camp blasts 'flawed' count
November 18, 2000
Candidates' lawyers head for court showdown in Florida
November 18, 2000
Manual recounts continue as court refuses Republican request for a halt
November 18, 2000

RELATED SITES:
Supreme Court
Florida State Courts
Florida Southern District Court
Electoral College


Note: Pages will open in a new browser window
External sites are not endorsed by CNN Interactive.
 Search


Back to the top   © 2001 Cable News Network. All Rights Reserved.
Terms under which this service is provided to you.
Read our privacy guidelines.